💬 Off-Topic Transgender Legislation and Litigation

Meanwhile, in Australia, a woman has an apprehended violence order upheld against her, for referring to a man as a man.

A New South Wales court has upheld a two-year apprehended violence order (AVO) against women’s advocate Kirralie Smith for publicly opposing the inclusion of men in women’s sport.

The ruling, handed down on Friday 15 August, rejected Smith’s appeal against an order granted to Stephanie Blanch, who identifies as a woman.

Smith, the Director of Binary Australia, said she has “never named him, met him or asked others to target him” but was herself targeted for her political advocacy.

“I lost the appeal and I am still under a 2 year apprehension of violence order for identifying a male in a female soccer team,” she posted on X shortly after the decision.
...
The Court of Appeal dismissed Smith’s claims of legal error and constitutional breach, finding that her online posts constituted harassment under the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW), even without intent to harass.

In its judgment, the court cited Kirralie Smith’s references to Blanch as a male, noting: “The [applicant] repeatedly referred to the [respondent] as a male, a man, a bloke and ‘he,’ where the [respondent] does not refer to herself that way… it was belittling and offensive. It denigrates the [respondent’s] right to describe herself as she wishes, not as a stranger wishes to label her.”

The court further described Smith’s actions as “a sustained campaign of belittling, harassment and intimidation.”

I cannot see any path through this for Australia. We are going to be permanently subjugated to trans madness.
 
Isn't the Sall Grover case still ongoing or on appeal now?
The appeal has been heard, and a judgment wont come until later in the year.

In any case, no matter the judgment, it is likely to be appealed to the High Court. However, I do not hold much hope for sanity to win. I'm not a lawyer, but it is clear to me that if the Sex Discrimination Act had not been amended in 2013, this case wouldn't exist. But it was amended, and that's the entire problem. There can't be a judicial solution to a legislative problem. The problem is the legislation.

And a further problem is that the 'right wing' party in Australia does not have either the numbers or the political will to touch the Act.

Australia is fucked.
 
Link | Archive

States must ax transgender references from sex ed or risk losing funds, Trump admin says​


The Trump administration directed 40 states, five territories and Washington, D.C., to remove references to transgender people from their sex education programs or risk losing federal funding.

The Administration for Children and Families (ACF), a division of the Department of Health and Human Services, sent letters Tuesday demanding that the health departments in these states and territories remove “all references to gender ideology” from their Personal Responsibility Education Program, or PREP. The program is a federally funded initiative created in 2010 to help prevent teen pregnancy and sexually transmitted infections.

“Accountability is coming,” acting Assistant Secretary Andrew Gradison said in a statement. “Federal funds will not be used to poison the minds of the next generation or advance dangerous ideological agendas. The Trump Administration will ensure that PREP reflects the intent of Congress, not the priorities of the left.”

The 40 states that received letters are: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. The five U.S. territories are: Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Palau, Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands.

Links to all 46 letters were included in the administration’s press statement. The ACF’s four-page letter to New York, for example, includes a bulleted list of course content that was flagged during a “medical accuracy review” earlier this year and “must be removed from New York’s PREP curricula and program materials.”

The content flagged for removal includes definitions of gender identity and gender expression and directives that program facilitators allow students to share their pronouns and “demonstrate acceptance and respect for all participants, regardless of personal characteristics, including race, cultural background, religion, social class, sexual orientation or gender identity,” according to the letter.

If New York’s health department declines to comply, it could lose more than $6 million in federal funds, according to data provided by ACF. The other states and territories stand to lose $300,000 to $4.6 million each.

The letters come just days after the ACF terminated $12 million of California’s remaining PREP funding after the state’s health department declined to remove references to trans people from the curriculum, arguing that the references had already been approved by the agency, the materials were medically accurate and relevant to the statute, and ACF does not have the authority to take such an enforcement action, according to ACF’s termination letter to the state.

California’s health department has 30 days to appeal. A spokesperson for the department said in a statement that the state maintains its position that its PREP curriculum “is medically accurate, comprehensive, and age-appropriate.”

“CA PREP sexual health education curriculum promotes healthy relationships and reduces the rates of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and unintended pregnancy, as well as leads to delayed sexual activity in youth — all outcomes that lead to a healthier state,” the spokesperson said.

In an emailed statement, Elana Ross, a spokesperson for California Gov. Gavin Newsom, said, “If it’s a day ending in y, President Trump is attacking kids’ safety, health, and access to education as part of his culture war.”

The action from ACF is part of the Trump administration’s ongoing effort to prohibit federal recognition of trans people and penalize the use of federal funds for any program that includes or mentions them.

In the first few weeks of his presidency, Trump issued executive orders declaring that there are only two unchangeable sexes; prohibiting trans people from enlisting and serving in the military; barring trans girls and women from competing on female sports teams in federally funded K-12 schools and colleges; and barring federal funding from going to hospitals that provide transition-related care to minors. The federal government has taken several actions against providers of transition care, resulting in more than 20 hospitals over the last few months rolling back or ending their gender-affirming care programs for minors and some young adults.

Federal officials have also removed mentions of trans or intersex people from agency websites, including from the website for the Stonewall National Monument commemorating the site of the 1969 Stonewall uprising in New York, which is widely considered a turning point in the modern gay rights movement.
 
Does this retard know that there is video and a manifesto?

Screenshot 2025-08-27 193846.webp
 
“After proposing that I be Lord Tobin my administration said ‘No’, but I did not give up. I became a minister through the Universal Life Church so I now am Minister Toby Tobin as well as Lord Toby Tobin,” the teacher said.
Yeah, the school isn’t going to make students use a noble or religious title for their teachers, those are dubiously legal. I’m not sure how they managed to get away with cross-sex or non-binary honorifics in the past since those are obviously religious in their own right, but there was at least a paper-thin justification that it was somehow a medical thing. But “minister” is an outright violation of church and state in a public school.
 
Hope that something good can come out of this senseless tragedy. Namely, institutionalize all the trannies and seize their assets to pay for it.
 
I've seen some troon cope on Twitter talking about how "he was a detransitioner, he wasn't one of ours", but:
Westman, 23, later wrote that he regretted being trans and just wished he were a girl.

“I regret being trans.. I wish I was a girl I just know I cannot achieve that body with the technology we have today. I also can’t afford that,” he said.
He regretted being transgender, but he still wished he was born female. Which means he was still "trans". Troons trying to paint him as a detransitioner are being disingenuous, as always.
“I like feeling sexy and cute but my face never matches how I feel. I hate my face… maybe that’s why I like furries so much. You can give yourself a new body and face. I want to be that black face mask on Beyonce’s body lmao!”
And he was a furry, apparently. Or at least he was such as massive loser that he respected furries.
 
The further fuckedness of Australia:

Transgender soccer player Riley Dennis has won a vilification case in the NSW local court, against anti-trans campaigner Kirralie Smith.

The magistrate decided Ms Smith unlawfully vilified Ms Dennis through a series of social media posts that were "capable of inciting serious contempt" and could "severely ridicule" Ms Dennis.

...

The judgement concluded that Ms Smith's refusal to use Ms Dennis's preferred pronouns, and her dismissive attitude toward the impact of her posts, undermined her claim of good faith.

...

Ms Dennis requested the court grant her an injunction preventing Ms Smith from identifying her again. She also sought a public apology from Ms Smith, the removal of the offensive posts, a direction that Ms Smith implement an anti-discrimination policy within her organisation and up to $100,000 in damages if Ms Smith fails to comply with court orders within two months.

The court will hear further submissions about damages and costs later this year.
Note the last highlighted part. If those requests are granted to Riley Dennis, it means Smith's organisation, Binary Australia, if implementing an 'anti-discrimination policy' will literally be incoherent as the entire point of it is that the organisation believes that there are two sexes and you cannot change sex.

Also, every time a court orders a public apology, I am put in mind of those execution videos from Islamist terror organisations, who kidnap white non-Muslims, force them to confess to many crimes on camera, and then execute them on video.

Also, it is staggering that the magistrate thinks Smith using pronouns consistent with her worldview (that Riley Dennis is a man) means Smith didn't make claims in 'good faith'. To use Dennis's preferred pronouns would be to undermine Smith's very point and it would be inconsistent with her beliefs--surely that would be a sign of 'bad faith'.

Australia, why are you doing this? Are we now more down the trans rabbit hole than Canada?
 
Helen Joyce predicts that the last people holding onto gender ideology will be the parents who transed their own kids. Whatever we learn about this woman, and whatever she does or doesn’t do is going to set the tone of the mainstream discussion on childhood transition and detransition.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo