wtfNeedSignUp
kiwifarms.net
- Registrado
- 17 de Dic, 2019
At least in the west, shonen is exclusively referring to battle/game shonen. Even if technically it's on shonen jump, which is probably read by more adults than children.Frieren is a shonen. So is Komi can't communicate or Spy Family. While I'm ahead, Ruri Dragon (which people will talk about since Kyo Ani is doing the anime) is also a shonen. Not everything under the shonen demographic is a "battle shonen". That isn't to say those also don't lose most of their appeal when you aren't a teenager (especially the school RomComs) but it's essentially the same shit; comics with mass appeal whose target demographic are kids/teenagers. The mass appeal part is important because that is why 90% of discussion you see online will be shonen shit; battle or not.
The world would be a better place if more people read seinen or josei books but as much as we try to deny it, we're social by nature. We want in on the latest popular thing or to at least be kind of knowledgeable on it. That's why you get people who will read or watch JJK/Kimetsu and seethe about it online endlessly. Even I'm guilty of it since I've read both to completion despite not being a big fan of either. If I were to say Houseki Kuni or Lovely Complex are fucking garbage no one would care outside of maybe 1 neckbeard and a handful of tumblr schizos. We just have to accept we suffer by choice.
If you want to be philosophical about it, shonen is defined by being very clear cut good guys vs bad guys, with the good guys prevailing through friendship and hard work. It is very idealized and game like. Yu-Gi-Oh is a shonen, but Frieren isn't.
The whole discourse has become mega gay, it's gay to watch people beat each other up and it's gay to watch sexy women. Seemingly the only non gay anime according to right wing influencers is watching two men engage in sex.