Why should we not genocide all Mosquitoes right fucking now? - We need a break to discuss the real issues

  • 🔧 Site instability resolved. You can report double-posts and broken attachments. For bigger issues, use the Technical Grievances thread.
    🇵🇦 Nuestro primer dominio localizado está en español en kiwifarms.pa. Our first localized domain is on Spanish on kiwifarms.pa.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

What do we do about mosquitoes?


  • Total de votantes
    65

AMHOLIO

Under threat of Mogging
True & Honest Fan
kiwifarms.net
Registrado
4 de Ene, 2020
Defend mosquitoes. What is their purpose? How do we deal with them if not total mosquito genocide?
 
Unfortunately I can't defend a complete mosquito death as they are food for too many species and serve as pollinators.
 
Don't worry, we have Bill Gates to save humanity. Thank the Lord for giving such an altruistic son.

The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation funds Oxitec, a biotechnology company developing genetically engineered mosquitoes designed to suppress disease-carrying populations. These male Aedes aegypti mosquitoes carry a self-limiting gene that prevents female offspring from surviving, reducing the population that spreads viruses like dengue and Zika. [1, 2, 3, 4]
 
Wasps are good pollinators

Edit: They're not so scary, just stay still and let them be, they'll soon bugger off or drown in your drink.
I feel ambivalent about wasps. If they're outside where they're supposed to be, fine. If the wasps in the nest in my attic STAY in my attic, fine. But you come into MY HOME, in MY BED, and act SURPRISED that I'm there, you die.

I know mosquitos are a food source for a great many animals that are more important to the ecosystem (birds, spiders, wasps?, frogs, etc) but I could've sworn there was a study done by biologists that said "yeah we could wipe them all out by creating a super sexy male mosquito that shoots modified swimmers that make all the females and their offspring sterile and eventually kill them all with minimal consequences to the ecosystem" but there's always that lingering fear it's going to be like Mao Zedong's gigantic fuckup.
 
as with any animal, I assume that mosquitoes are connected to an uncountable number of other animals in a bunch of non-obvious ways, so removing them wholesale is like removing a block from the center of the jenga tower. will it affect nothing? will the whole thing collapse? will the tower still stand but be noticeably less stable? a bunch of the blocks are already missing or partially dislodged. you can study the tower all you want and make an educated guess, but you don't really know until you remove it, and after that you can't easily put it back without potentially fucking it up even more.

there are a bunch of considerations like, removing that much biomass from the environment requires it to be replaced with something so you don't destroy a vital food source. maybe there's another type of bug that will fill the void, maybe mosquito predators will simply change their diets, idk. it's possible that it would be fine but I don't think fucking with nature on such a large scale is a great idea.
 
If we eradicated all mosquitoes some other insect will replace it that is equally bad or much worse and their ecological position is really important for other animals to survive like frogs, lizards, spiders, etc. We just pray to god they don't evolve into a PsychoKillerRapistInsect number 53 that spreads PsychoKillerRapistDisease number 478343
 
We dont kill them because we don't know how to.
That's a load of bull. Humans are the CHINA NUMBUH ONE species killer on the planet. If we actually put our minds to it and threw caution to the wind we could eradicate mosquitos just fine.

But we're held back by other concerns like "ethics" and "biodiversity" and "morals" and "3rd Order Consequences".
 
- Aforementioned manipulation involving tricking viable females into mating with the irradiated sterile retard males
- A fuck ton of DDT w/ additional pesticides to nuke the resistant stragglers.
- Pie in the sky specially bred cordyceps strain targeted at the bitey mcfuckers
- Poisoning our own blood
- Finally (and I really like this one) we overbreed dragonflies in captivity and then release them into the wild en masse in regular intervals.

But again, we SHOULDN'T do this because I like frogs.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo