Halo MCC/Infinite/general Griefing thread - Six months, two maps, no refunds

What did you think of Infinite after the campaign showcase?

  • It looked good

  • Good, but they need to iron out some issues

  • Majorly apprehensive

  • It sucked donkey dick

  • I need to see more

  • I don't know

  • Craig monke


Los resultados solo se pueden ver después de votar.
Going to point out that in the context of Fall of Reach the Infinity doesn't exist. It was written before 343 raped Halo's canon.
Correct, from a writing perspective the mission was authored before the Infinity was authored, but that's an artifact of it not really mattering what the contingency plans were at the time the mission was planned. From the at-the-moment lore perspective, it was a practically suicide mission to buy time, and some time later they settled on what they actually bought that time for. This is a pretty normal writing thing, putting out threads having no idea what you'll do with them and resolving them some point later.
 
It would've made more sense if the Infinity was a straight up Forerunner Super Star Destroyer that the Earth government cooked up after the war. Humanity suffered great losses at the hands of both the Covenant and the Flood, but on the plus side got loads of Forerunner tech when they started pilfering the Ark's remains and exploring other Forerunner installations and foundries. They discover an old Forerunner shipyard whose AI still works, and it recognizes humans as living Forerunner. They then give it enough raw resources to create a powerful battle dreadnought, because while the Covenant Empire is broken, remnants of it still live and harass human settlements on occasion, so the UNSC pulls a page from Grand Moff Tarkin's playbook and they have a large warship like the Infinity made, with the most advanced Forerunner weapons tech on hand, piloted by a newly-minted Forerunner AI that is completely loyal to the human government. They use it as a terror weapon to frighten the Covenant remnants into surrendering. The Infinity is barely big enough to carry a city's worth of people, but it is big enough to be used as a terror weapon. The UNSC lacks the numbers to deploy troops everywhere due to the past war, so they would logically rely on terror weapons like the Spartans and Infinity to deter would-be attackers.
 
Última edición:
So if the forerunners are humans than I have a few curiosities.

How long was it that the forerunners died out before humanity evolves to what it is? Did they plant humans on earth? Did they set the seeds for specific evolution to make new forerunners aka humans? Are there differences between humans and forerunners like there being different breeds for dogs but they are same species? Were the forerunners apes before they became forerunners like apes were to humans? Why did they choose earth out of all the planets? And how is it that only one planet had humans when the forerunners could go anywhere?

I wonder if this is what went through guilty sparks head while he was learning about humanity.
 
So if the forerunners are humans than I have a few curiosities.

How long was it that the forerunners died out before humanity evolves to what it is? Did they plant humans on earth? Did they set the seeds for specific evolution to make new forerunners aka humans? Are there differences between humans and forerunners like there being different breeds for dogs but they are same species? Were the forerunners apes before they became forerunners like apes were to humans? Why did they choose earth out of all the planets? And how is it that only one planet had humans when the forerunners could go anywhere?

I wonder if this is what went through guilty sparks head while he was learning about humanity.
I suppose some of them just had amnesia when they landed on Earth. War does tend to destroy a lot of what once was there. It took 1000 years for Europe to recover what was lost when Rome fell.
 
Did they plant humans on earth?
Yes. After the rings fired, humanity and all the other sentient species were reseeded on their home planets.
Why did they choose earth out of all the planets?
That was their home planet, hence why the portal at Voi is there
And how is it that only one planet had humans when the forerunners could go anywhere?
Because all life had just been wiped from the galaxy due to the flood and the firing of the rings. They just put humanity (forerunners) back on the planet from which they came.

As for all your other questions, I do not know. Maybe somebody else does
 
How long was it that the forerunners died out before humanity evolves to what it is?
The Halo Array was fired 100,000 years ago.

Did they plant humans on earth?
In old Bungie Lore, Earth was the Forerunner homeworld, which is why you'd find more Forerunner technology the closer you got to our homeworld. Which is also why the Ark's portal was on Earth. in the original plans for Halo 2 before they ran out of time, the Ark itself was supposed to be on Earth.

Did they set the seeds for specific evolution to make new forerunners aka humans?
In the original idea for Halo the Forerunners left a machine on Earth that would slowly start re-teaching humanity everything the Forerunners had, which is why Earth's architecture when you visit during Halo 2 looks so similar to Forerunner architecture and why Spartan Armor is said to look similar to Forerunner combat suits in the OG.

Are there differences between humans and forerunners like there being different breeds for dogs but they are same species?
There probably are, we don't know though. in the original Earth Ark level an Elite would find a human skeleton in a forerunner tomb and it looks like a modern human skeleton.

1785440840140.png
Were the forerunners apes before they became forerunners like apes were to humans?
Probably yes, because the Forerunners ARE Human; their species wasn't called Forerunner by themselves; they were most likely still called humans.

Why did they choose earth out of all the planets? And how is it that only one planet had humans when the forerunners could go anywhere?

Because Earth, again, was their homeworld. They reseeded every species in the galaxy on their homeworld regardless of how advanced they were. They probably wanted humanity to reform as naturally as possible to avoid instant hubris and them becoming warmongers or something. Especially since, as far as we know based on Bungie lore, they stayed back in the galaxy fighting to the last man to keep the Flood at bay, and were all killed when the array fired. So there were no humans that survived to teach the reseeded Humanity anything. So the Forerunners probably wanted the reseeded humanity to learn everything from scratch instead of handing them the keys to a galactic empire that they wouldn't be able to fully understand.

It's like giving a teenager a credit card with no limit; they'd eventually fuck up somewhere.

Edit: here is what Forerunners looked like in concept art for Ensemble Studio's cancelled MMO

1785441634046.png 1785441704926.png
 
Última edición:
Generally read release order. But if you wanted to do chronological order you'd do

Halo Contact Harvest, Cole Protocol, Reach, The Flood, First Strike, Ghost of Onyx.

Anything after Cole Protocol can be ignored since Cole Protocol was the last Bungie Era Halo Book
I remember buying a Halo 3 comic back when the hype for the game was at a fever pitch. I doubt I have it anymore, but are the comic series relevant or can they be ignored?
Personally, and I know this is going to get me firing lined by Halo 1 Shotgun, but I don't mind Forerunners being a different species than humanity. I do mind learning so much shit about them in the 343 stuff. Do not explain them. Keep them a mysterious ancient species that died out well before Humanity took to the stars. Stop explaining the ancient species, everyone who does so sucks at it!
This is a concept that could have been done well. Problem is that 343 has shit the bed, with this and everything else.
 
I remember buying a Halo 3 comic back when the hype for the game was at a fever pitch. I doubt I have it anymore, but are the comic series relevant or can they be ignored?
My rule of thumb when it comes to books or comic books for Halo is to just straight up ignore anything that 343 had a hand in making. So anything that was published after 343 came into an existence I tend to ignore. So if the comic came out in the Bungie Era go nuts
 
I'm astounded at how badly people need this invincible wahmen conspiracy shit to be true.
(I'm also questioning Jamie's intelligence/sanity for willingly posting on twatter in 2026)
The fact that you're being this autistic and trying to "set the record straight" for this one thing is kind of hilarious. Of all the issues, people laughing at this one thing is setting you over the edge. Williams being a Mary Sue who talks shit to the MC (not just A Spartan, THE Spartan) and one shots Chief if he does something intentionally bad, and respawns if she somehow dies? Crickets, nothing from you. What was reasonably assumed to be woman being invincible, which turned into "ok they just have extra health" and "it might be modded (which you also went ape shit over)," and now you're going ape shit over it being bugged hitboxes? Don't know which it is as I just got here but it is worth sperging this hard over a shitty remake that'll be laughed at and then forgotten by August? Get a grip, nigger.
 
Última edición:
The fact that you're being this autistic and trying to "set the record straight" for this one thing is kind of hilarious. Of all the issues, people laughing at this one thing is setting you over the edge. Williams being a Mary Sue who talks shit to the MC (not just A Spartan, THE Spartan) and one shots Chief if he does something intentionally bad, and respawns if she somehow dies? Crickets, nothing from you. What was reasonably assumed to be woman being invincible, which turned into "ok they just have extra health" and "it might be modded (which you also went ape shit over)," and now you're going ape shit over it being bugged hitboxes? Don't know which it is as I just got here but it is worth sperging this hard over a shitty remake that'll be laughed at and then forgotten by August? Get a grip, nigger.
He’s overzealous but correct. There’s so much to shit on this game for without lying about it.
 
He’s overzealous but correct. There’s so much to shit on this game for without lying about it.
Like someone else pointed out it's less lying and more we had no idea what the fuck was going on. A few pages back, a former Bungie dev who actually worked on the level came out and talked about it. Basically saying that the current devs changed the models, didn't update their damage rules, which resulted in them taking damage as if they were in vehicles.

Jaime Griesemer, the game designer behind the Pillar of Autumn mission in Halo: Combat Evolved and also one of the head gameplay designers for the Halo games and Destiny 1, has hypothesized that the reason why the women were invincible was most likely damage transfer not being set up since the women are all new models.
 
Like someone else pointed out it's less lying and more we had no idea what the fuck was going on. A few pages back, a former Bungie dev who actually worked on the level came out and talked about it. Basically saying that the current devs changed the models, didn't update their damage rules, which resulted in them taking damage as if they were in vehicles.
Score one for the QA team, lmfao
 
Or how the prequel mission plan revolved around capturing a Prophet if possible. How would Chief, Johnson, or the UNMC know what a Prophet is or even look like? Up until that point, the only contact humanity made with a Prophet was in Halo Wars, but the Spirit of Fire never made it back to UNSC space to report it.
All the original First Contact lore for the Covenant races was retconned away even before the 343 era. Halo Legends has an episode about ODSTs and one Spartan being sent to kill a Prophet years before the 2550’s.
 
I changed my mind about waiting for the weekend to make a judgement on player numbers. This is looking pretty brutal.
Every single time people say "wait for the weekend", the result is always the same: it's a bump of like a few thousand, at most. Trying to pretend otherwise is Morbius-tier gaslighting.
 
Every single time people say "wait for the weekend", the result is always the same: it's a bump of like a few thousand, at most. Trying to pretend otherwise is Morbius-tier gaslighting.
Maybe I'm too nice to the slop when I try to give it the benefit of the doubt.
Screenshot 2026-07-30 165832.png
The spikes get shorter and the oofs get bigger with each day.
 
All the original First Contact lore for the Covenant races was retconned away even before the 343 era. Halo Legends has an episode about ODSTs and one Spartan being sent to kill a Prophet years before the 2550’s.
Is Halo Legends even canon? I thought it was AO3 level of fanfiction.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo