Victor Mignogna v. Funimation Productions, LLC, et al. (2019) - Vic's lawsuit against Funimation, VAs, and others, for over a million dollars.

Destacado
HTTP Error 404 dijo:
The only thing I can see being an issue is that Slatosch said a conclusionary statement that the contract was breached, which isn't kosher as far as I know of.
Presiona para expandir...
Even removing that section, the entire rest of it provides more than enough evidence for a trier of fact to come to that conclusion. So not an issue at all.
 
There was far too many "I don't think so," 's in this from Chupp. I doubt he was being ironic about it either, I legit believe he simply isn't aware about a lot of what he ruled off-the-cuff on.
 
I will admit, the retweet = conspiracy angle Ty went for on page 54 and 55 seemed kind of... limp. Dunno if it legally counts as prima facie, though.

I really need to read this whole thing.
 
Última edición:
OneHandClapping dijo:
I will admit, the retweet = conspiracy angle Ty went for on page 54 and 55 seemed kind of... limp.

I really need to read this whole thing, though.
Presiona para expandir...

I will criticize Ty for not arguing that the conspiracy he was targeting was the conspiracy to defame Vic after his release from Funimation.

Chupp was fixated that the conspiracy was to get Vic fired, which for Monica/Toye/Marchi could have been true, but for Funimation's conspiracy, it'd be much easier to argue that conspiracy charge was to conspiracy to defame and tortuously interfere with prospective contracts. Because that's the evidence Ty was attempting to present to the Judge, the 20+ emails after Vic got fired and Chupp wasn't having it because he was stuck on wanting evidence of a conspiracy to fire Vic, and wanting evidence from before he was fired.
 
Dildo Shwaggins dijo:
Yeah this logic seems like "oh sure they committed a criminal act against you but you were able to bounce back from it so we won't punish the person who committed the criminal act against you".

I doubt this kind of logic would fly if applied to any other situation.
Presiona para expandir...
"I know I stabbed you multiple times, but you went to the hospital and you recovered just fine so it's like my stabbings never happened"
 
Garm dijo:
Chupp seemed... Confused most of the hearing.
Presiona para expandir...
Can any of the law kiwis pull up Chupps judicial history? Could this be a case of this being outside what he normally does? If he is not used to this section of civil law, that would explain a fair bit, especially because the sheer size of the filings could have prevented him from being able to bone up on the relevent law. Would explain an awful fucking lot from the bench, alongside what we can also deduce. .
 
Gehenna dijo:
Can any of the law kiwis pull up Chupps judicial history?
Presiona para expandir...

From back in the thread, a comment which I HAVE NOT verified:
Immortal Technique dijo:
He might just be a lazy fuck that doesn't want complex cases. Look at his docket: 85% is personal injury (he's a former personal injury lawyer before becoming judge), 10% contract/debt, and 4.8% civil, and 0.02% other.
Presiona para expandir...

Honorable John Chupp's docket can be found easily from here:
141st District Court of Texas

I hope this helps a little while you wait for a proper answer, @Gehenna.
 
Long-time Lurker dijo:
From back in the thread, a comment which I HAVE NOT verified:


Honorable John Chupp's docket can be found easily from here:
141st District Court of Texas

I hope this helps a little while you wait for a proper answer, @Gehenna.
Presiona para expandir...
Nah, not only does that help a little, that outright answers it. Between the sloppy filing from Beard, the mountain of bullshit from the defendants, and the fact that barely even 15% of his cases as a JUDGE cover the topic (And his lawyer experience is well outside of it). The Honorable Chupp is probably well and truly out of his depth, he and his clerks were robbed of the time needed to bone up on it, Beard failed to make a clear case that would help him grasp it intuitively, and he probably also just wants the bullshit to end.

Hell, there is a fairly good chance he has very rarely ever dealt with the TCPA. 95% of his stuff is well outside what the TCPA would be used for.
 
Gehenna dijo:
The worst part about what you just said... I am seriously considering it, have been for a while now.
Presiona para expandir...
step 1: take lsat
step 2: get into law school
step 3: graduate
step 4: pass the bar
step 5: sit on twitter all day making bad memes and crowd-fund for asspats while begging popehat to touch your peepee
step 6: kill yourself
 
Destacado
Debes iniciar sesión o registrarte para responder aquí.
Atrás
Top Abajo