Or maybe this is just Gen Z's Rocky Horror Picture Show.
At least Rocky Horror Picture Show had this self aware vibe to it, they absolutely knew they were making entertaining trash and, really, that was their goal. Its not a movie that claims you are morally superior for liking it.
Digital Circus is 100% meaning what they say and do, believing what they are saying and HOW they are saying is vanguard and amazing and will save lives.
Rocky literally has Tim Curry in drag singing about Transexual Transilvania and one of the musical numbers has a letter ending with a literal "AAAAAHHHH". It absolutel KNOWS it is nonsense and wants you to have fun with it.
Really, Jax and Ted are the only fair comparisons, but even Jax's similarities to Ted was eventually dwarfed by the bigger focus on his masculinity/femininity, his relationship with Ribbit, and the finale where he just dies. No noble sacrifice, no heroic turnaround where he helps the others, he just dies/abstracts and therapy happens.
Ted has always been an unreliable narrator but he does an unironically noble thing at the end when he kills the others when AM was apparently too busy lol-ing at their no can opener induced misery, allowing them to rest in peace at the cost of himself basically living in Hell for all of eternity.
I legit cant see Jax being that noble.
when people keep emphasizing it as the MAIN inspiration, keep comparing Digital Circus with it, and constantly point to this inspiration as to the reason why Digital Circus is ACTUALLY a DARK and DEEP PSYCHOLOGICAL HORROR show for ADULTS, it doesn't feel right
I legit see Digital circus suffering from a witdraw of the hype, similar to Steven Universe. Many fans kept gaslighting themselves and others that the finale of Future was amazing and gonna be talked about years to come.
The years came and went and now, well, barely ANYONE talks about S.U, except to mostly talk about its issues and "S.U was never good, admit it" type of videos.
I truly think we will see D.C enter that phase eventually where its haters will talk about it more than its fans. The only "con" to my prediction is that D.C is tied to the indie movement and many are attaching an unhealthy amount of investment in it as a "counter" to the mainstream, where you cant criticize indie projects* or else you are daring to support the mainstream and, GASP, AI even! (
when you can criticize one without supporting the other but hey, here we go, expecting reason from the unreasonable.)
*"indie" when, really, its just another mainstream product with extra steps