That one sandwich you will never forget. - You know the one.

[Norstein Bekkler]

Medium rare prime rib cheesesteak with horseradish and caramelized onions. I day dream about that sandwich more shamefully often than I care to admit.

 

[Shek$il]

The KFC Double Down was the first and only sandwich that gave me a severe case of depressive 'itis only a couple of bites in. I have a steel trap for a stomach and even my body was asking "are you sure?"

 

[Testacles Maximus]

At Subway I used to get a salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella sandwich with the vinaigrette they don't carry anymore. The ingredients got shittier over time so I quit doing it, but it was my favorite sandwich.

 

[VF-1J Armored Valkyrie]

Baltimore pit beef med rare with pickles 'n onions and the horseradish sauce was truly special. Philly roast pork with the greens, real deal Miami Cubano, and that first real Italian cold cut combo with three or four meats and good pepperoncini could all take that spot though. There are so many truly amazing sandwiches out there.

 

[Axiom.]

My first ever Rueben sandwich with extra mayonnaise, one of my happiest memories.

 

[Iron Jaguar]

Corned beef and picallili, on buttered Vogel's Bread sliced super thin, lengthwise. Circa 1990.

 

[Character from a movie]

The first and only time I ate a pastrami sandwich. One day I'll eat it again... one day.

 

[JohnnyG]

Once while traveling through Chicongo I had a Gym Shoe / Jim Shoe sandwich, basically a "throw everything in" affair.

Gyro meat, corned beef, Italian roast beef, all chopped up on a hoagie roll. Add cheese, tatziki (gyro/pita) sauce, and some mayo/mustard or oil/vinegar if you want, then top it with Giardiniera (chopped peppers in oil). I guess there are versions where they stack the meat sliced like a sub, but the chopped together mess was much more satisfying, regardless of how it looks.

 

[Norstein Bekkler]

The first and only time I ate a pastrami sandwich. One day I'll eat it again... one day.

Bro I thought pastrami was some like ghetto balogna type shit until I started working in a higher-end restaurant during college. They had some brisket pastrami with a black peppercorn crust that was just out of this world good.

Once while traveling through Chicongo I had a Gym Shoe / Jim Shoe sandwich, basically a "throw everything in" affair.

That looks fucking awesome. Honestly I love those kinds of concepts. Some of the best food I've ever had was literally just a "fuck it, we got it, why not put it in?" kind of affair. We used to call them "garbage can (dish)" here at home lol.

My first ever Rueben sandwich with extra mayonnaise, one of my happiest memories.

Fuck yeah Reubens. There was a cheeky deli when I was in college that used to serve reubens on a bagel with scallion cream cheese. It was called the "Paul Reubens" lol. Was embarrassing to order, but fuck it was good.

There are so many truly amazing sandwiches out there.

and not enough time to try them all

At Subway I used to get a salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella sandwich with the vinaigrette they don't carry anymore. The ingredients got shittier over time so I quit doing it, but it was my favorite sandwich.

Word. Was that the MVP Vinaigrette?

 

[More AWS-8Q Than You]

I had a muffuletta sandwich in some restaurant in Savannah, Georgia about twenty-five years ago, and I don't know that I've ever had anything better.

 

[Norstein Bekkler]

I had a muffuletta sandwich in some restaurant in Savannah, Georgia about twenty-five years ago, and I don't know that I've ever had anything better.

exactly what i'm talking about. a quarter century later and you're still thinking about that sandwich.
(edit: OT but savannah is fucking awesome. one of the coolest towns i've ever gotten to visit.)

 

[LowlyPheasent]

Ham and cheddar with honey mustard on a pretzel bun. Simplistic but damn was it good.

 

[Testacles Maximus]

Was that the MVP Vinaigrette?

I don't think so. I had to google the MVP vinaigrette but it doesn't look like it.

 

[R00k]

I had bahn mi from a little Vietnamese shop at the north market in Columbus and I've yet to find another place that makes them as good

 

[Ric Flair Woooo]

5 years ago, Gatlinburg TN, Landshark Bar and Grill. Turkey Bacon club. The best damn sandwich I have ever had. I've been since and it has not lived up to the memory. But that day, it was. God bless you whoever made that.

 

[Preacher ✝]

The first time I had a proper cuban.

I was in my early teens, on vacation with extended family but not my parents. Growing up I was never a fan of mustard so when I saw it on the menu at a lunch place I was hesitant but I went for it anyway. Turns out I just didn't like that generic yellow mustard, still don't, but other mustards are great.

 

[ElHijodeDeficienciaCogni]

Homemade bread, crusty but not too crusty with a fluffy sponge. Cold turkey breast with the skin still on. Healthy dollop of mayonnaise, doused in salt and pepper.

 

[SteinserGate]

The KFC Double Down was the first and only sandwich that gave me a severe case of depressive 'itis

I said this in another thread, but I'll say it here.
I got cholesterol problems because I was eating too many of these.
My doctor ordered me to stop eating them and take blood work.
I don't think I've ever tasted something and felt as much happiness that beats that damn sandwich.
I got the sandwich when it came back for a short time and a flood of memories from when I was young kid came back. I think about it a lot.

 

[PunkinMan]

roast beef, salami, bacon, cheese, shredded lettuce, red onions and spinach on Italian bread from a subway before 2018

 

[Daddy's Angry Juice]

I was visiting a friend out in Seattle, and she took me to this hipster ass sandwich shop that she swore by. I got the Caprese sandwich as per her recommendation, and it was pure fucking sex. I don't know how you make a sandwich that is literally just lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and vinaigrette taste so fucking good, but I assume it was black magic.
When I got back home I tried ordering one from Panera, but it just wasn't the same.
Still to this day, if a restaurant has a Caprese sandwich, I order it, trying to chase that high.