- Registrado
- 25 de Feb, 2021
Arise, thread, and hear my reviews of HiSmile toothpaste flavors!
I never joined their toothpaste-of-the-month club, because I am only one woman with one mouth, even if they do let you save up credits. I did order a few more tubes when they were having a really deep sale, and I couldn't pass up the "mystery flavor" which ended up being old club flavors. This lady on eBay seems to resell club flavors, and is a better list of the weird and discontinued flavors than their actual website. (Man, "blackcurrant" and "custard" have me rethinking my non-subscribing ways.)
Getting on the HiSmile mailing list is worth it; they usually have something boring to say about a collaboration, or hyping the toothpaste club, but then they'll occasionally announce a sale with selected flavors for less than $5. I have no idea what they're thinking in Australia regarding toothpaste pricing and availability.
Biscuit Spread (limited edition): aka fake Biscoff. Agreeable; nice mellow cookie flavor, weird to have a "crunchy" flavor in toothpaste form. I'm not a huge Biscoff fan so it mostly had me thinking how great spekuloos cookie flavor would be. Biscoff (the actual cookie) has a similar flavor strength to graham crackers; it doesn't sock you in the mouth, but it's nice and you can put most things on it.
Candy Cane (limited edition): really good! I can't explain how it's not just mint, but it isn't. It's candy mint. If mint toothpaste always tasted like this I wouldn't be mail-ordering fancy toothpastes. I think they didn't explain this difference adequately in their copy, because the candy cane flavor is marked down a ton, and I see it all over reseller sites.
Energy Drink (limited edition): this tasted exactly like Red Bull, which I do not care for, so I'm glad I only got a sample size. They really should have caffeinated it and sold it to gamers.
Gingerbread (limited edition): nice flavor but nothing at all like gingerbread, sadly. Mostly cinnamon. It's the flavor of picking Jelly Belly cinnamon jelly beans out of a multi-flavor bag, while you stand in the chocolate place in the mall that made fudge so the air is kind of a cold chocolatey backdrop to everything.
I was disappointed because I really like gingerbread, and got my hopes up after how accurate the Biscoff was.
Also the tube design seems weirdly penile; this background downplays it. I don't know why they went with a pink tip.
Lucky Charms (limited edition): perfect flavor recreation, albeit I was raised by granola parents who only got to try Lucky Charms when it was in the multi-pack of mini cereals we took camping. They didn't just make it marshmallow horseshoe flavor; they got the oatiness in there. I did end up giving the tube to a child-haver because it didn't have that "clean" aftertaste. I mean, my teeth felt clean, but I couldn't convince my brain I wasn't stewing in sugar cereal juice.
eta: I've figured out that you can get another couple of days out of HiSmile toothpaste pumps. Pop off the cap at the bottom (may need a lever, like a scissor blade). Inside there's a plunger that serves the pump; by the time you're near the end, the plunger will be high up inside the tube. Push the plunger up higher (toothbrush works well) and you should get a few more pumps, and you can do this several times.
I never joined their toothpaste-of-the-month club, because I am only one woman with one mouth, even if they do let you save up credits. I did order a few more tubes when they were having a really deep sale, and I couldn't pass up the "mystery flavor" which ended up being old club flavors. This lady on eBay seems to resell club flavors, and is a better list of the weird and discontinued flavors than their actual website. (Man, "blackcurrant" and "custard" have me rethinking my non-subscribing ways.)
Getting on the HiSmile mailing list is worth it; they usually have something boring to say about a collaboration, or hyping the toothpaste club, but then they'll occasionally announce a sale with selected flavors for less than $5. I have no idea what they're thinking in Australia regarding toothpaste pricing and availability.
Biscuit Spread (limited edition): aka fake Biscoff. Agreeable; nice mellow cookie flavor, weird to have a "crunchy" flavor in toothpaste form. I'm not a huge Biscoff fan so it mostly had me thinking how great spekuloos cookie flavor would be. Biscoff (the actual cookie) has a similar flavor strength to graham crackers; it doesn't sock you in the mouth, but it's nice and you can put most things on it.
Candy Cane (limited edition): really good! I can't explain how it's not just mint, but it isn't. It's candy mint. If mint toothpaste always tasted like this I wouldn't be mail-ordering fancy toothpastes. I think they didn't explain this difference adequately in their copy, because the candy cane flavor is marked down a ton, and I see it all over reseller sites.
Energy Drink (limited edition): this tasted exactly like Red Bull, which I do not care for, so I'm glad I only got a sample size. They really should have caffeinated it and sold it to gamers.
Gingerbread (limited edition): nice flavor but nothing at all like gingerbread, sadly. Mostly cinnamon. It's the flavor of picking Jelly Belly cinnamon jelly beans out of a multi-flavor bag, while you stand in the chocolate place in the mall that made fudge so the air is kind of a cold chocolatey backdrop to everything.
I was disappointed because I really like gingerbread, and got my hopes up after how accurate the Biscoff was.
Also the tube design seems weirdly penile; this background downplays it. I don't know why they went with a pink tip.
Lucky Charms (limited edition): perfect flavor recreation, albeit I was raised by granola parents who only got to try Lucky Charms when it was in the multi-pack of mini cereals we took camping. They didn't just make it marshmallow horseshoe flavor; they got the oatiness in there. I did end up giving the tube to a child-haver because it didn't have that "clean" aftertaste. I mean, my teeth felt clean, but I couldn't convince my brain I wasn't stewing in sugar cereal juice.
eta: I've figured out that you can get another couple of days out of HiSmile toothpaste pumps. Pop off the cap at the bottom (may need a lever, like a scissor blade). Inside there's a plunger that serves the pump; by the time you're near the end, the plunger will be high up inside the tube. Push the plunger up higher (toothbrush works well) and you should get a few more pumps, and you can do this several times.




