Victor Mignogna v. Funimation Productions, LLC, et al. (2019) - Vic's lawsuit against Funimation, VAs, and others, for over a million dollars.

I was sort of under the impression they had things roughly outlined for appeals and a gameplan for hitting the ground running before the final judgment and just needed to confirm dates like filing the appeal while going through the fees hearing. The fact that Chupp didn't really address anything in the written ruling with substance left it pretty open for making the arguments.
 
The appeals court is clearly interested in seeing this case tried as soon as possible, otherwise they wouldn't have put it on an accelerated schedule, and the plaintiff, who should be eager to get it on the road, is all "lol no let's put it off." Why? Why the fuck is this happening? I can't think of a single good reason.
Because they need more time from teacher to finish their essay. Appeals court want to resolve this swiftly and I imagine Vic does too....yet the plaintiff who has been wronged twice is now dragging this out and playing into stalling tactics the defendants have used previously.
 
I was sort of under the impression they had things roughly outlined for appeals and a gameplan for hitting the ground running before the final judgment and just needed to confirm dates like filing the appeal while going through the fees hearing. The fact that Chupp didn't really address anything in the written ruling with substance left it pretty open for making the arguments.
As was I, Ty babbled about the first quarter being over and how the game had just began. I think this counts as hitting the ground running and blowing your knee out.
 
I will take an optimistic position and hope that they are really going to be hammering on the record, in regards to marchi and the TI ect.
They already did that, Chupp's just a sped. What is due now is condensed argument of why the ruling was wrong and evidence to support their argument.

They can only use stuff that's currently on the record, if Chupp's lack of explaining what is and isn't on record is causing them issues they should just say so. Filing for an extension and saying "judge was a wishy washy spastic" is better than "busy lol".
 
Última edición:
They already did that, Chupp just a sped. What is due now is condensed argument of why the ruling was wrong and evidence to support their arguement.

I'm not sure why it takes so long to argue that that this fat Texan asshat high on his own farts can hire two extra lawyers and still not be able to file on time.
 
The appeals court is clearly interested in seeing this case tried as soon as possible, otherwise they wouldn't have put it on an accelerated schedule, and the plaintiff, who should be eager to get it on the road, is all "lol no let's put it off." Why? Why the fuck is this happening? I can't think of a single good reason.

Nick's slow poke mexican accent for Martinez is spot on!

Come the fuck on, they better get this done right. I wanna see funi's HR, social media twat, Jamie, and others in depositions!
 
I'm not sure why it takes so long to argue that that this fat Texan asshat high on his own farts can hire two extra lawyers and still not be able to file on time.

An Lee Hsu just got back from his scheduled vacation.

1580241676738.png
 
I'm not sure why it takes so long to argue that that this fat Texan asshat high on his own farts can hire two extra lawyers and still not be able to file on time.
What is odd to me is he rated this case a 3/5 on that filing for difficulty, but 6 lawyers with 2 months of time cannot hammer out a polished filing for CoA. So, it's either a 5/5 for these lawyers or they're going LemonAids on billing.
 
The appeals court is clearly interested in seeing this case tried as soon as possible, otherwise they wouldn't have put it on an accelerated schedule, and the plaintiff, who should be eager to get it on the road, is all "lol no let's put it off." Why? Why the fuck is this happening? I can't think of a single good reason.

I continue to maintain their lawyers have an insufficient amount of autism for this case. Ty treated the Lemon Fuhrer like a rational fellow lawyer, and tried to do a straightforward hearing in front of Chupp. Hsu and Martinez tightened up the filings, but each argument only had a single example, when they should have buried the court with examples of the defendant's impropriety (in an appendix if needed to keep the main text Chupp-simple).

I'll place my bets on Hsu and Martinez knowing what needs to go in there, but they're too slow in properly formatting, documenting, and linking case citations for every single aspect, especially with the word limit. The record is a disaster, as @AnOminous frequently points out; they probably need extra effort not just pointing at things in the record, but also arguing they are properly established to begin with. I think we'll wind up seeing a decent filing, with limited examples (again), and probably not the examples some of us think are the most egregious.

Asking for an extension was free, Vic's under no pressure to end the suit immediately, so I don't see a problem. I've never heard of a case where a lawyer turned down an available deadline extension. Unless there's some worry about the statute of limitations for something outside the immediate case, this seems like just a repeat of the freakout over the COA clerk's filing fee notice.
 
I stayed away from the Farms for the past little bit because I knew there would be some questionably hot takes on that extension.

On another note, I hope Hsu gives Lemoine the Wu Flu.
 
As someone else said, they/Ty had two months and an SUV full of lawyers and they could still not produce a short, to the point, filing that summarizes the important parts of what has already been filed and why Chupps ruling should be reversed.
That screams either incompetence or they gives-no-fucks to me and just want to cash in.
Makes no sense. It surely can not take THAT much time to do this paperwork?
 
I continue to maintain their lawyers have an insufficient amount of autism for this case. Ty treated the Lemon Fuhrer like a rational fellow lawyer, and tried to do a straightforward hearing in front of Chupp. Hsu and Martinez tightened up the filings, but each argument only had a single example, when they should have buried the court with examples of the defendant's impropriety (in an appendix if needed to keep the main text Chupp-simple).

I'll place my bets on Hsu and Martinez knowing what needs to go in there, but they're too slow in properly formatting, documenting, and linking case citations for every single aspect, especially with the word limit. The record is a disaster, as @AnOminous frequently points out; they probably need extra effort not just pointing at things in the record, but also arguing they are properly established to begin with. I think we'll wind up seeing a decent filing, with limited examples (again), and probably not the examples some of us think are the most egregious.

Asking for an extension was free, Vic's under no pressure to end the suit immediately, so I don't see a problem. I've never heard of a case where a lawyer turned down an available deadline extension. Unless there's some worry about the statute of limitations for something outside the immediate case, this seems like just a repeat of the freakout over the COA clerk's filing fee notice.
I agree with all but one thing: They have a reason not to drag his butt: round fucking 2. I guess Vic doesn't because he's the kinda guy who only cares about proving the accusations false so he can go on with his life but everyone else sure as shit cares about seeing justice served and so long as that filthy rat Sabbat isn't even on the suit that is impossible.
I'm sorry, I'm sperging, but it honestly seems like they gave up on that alltogether. They better at least get this round straight. Vic deserves it.
 
As someone else said, they/Ty had two months and an SUV full of lawyers and they could still not produce a short, to the point, filing that summarizes the important parts of what has already been filed and why Chupps ruling should be reversed.
That screams either incompetence or they gives-no-fucks to me and just want to cash in.
Makes no sense. It surely can not take THAT much time to do this paperwork?

You say that, but a TCPA expert had to spend nearly 200 hours researching how to file, and compile a TCPA.

Clearly this is super mega hard, and if such an expert has a hard time, what can a chink, spick, and country bumpken manage?
 
As someone else said, they/Ty had two months and an SUV full of lawyers and they could still not produce a short, to the point, filing that summarizes the important parts of what has already been filed and why Chupps ruling should be reversed.
That screams either incompetence or they gives-no-fucks to me and just want to cash in.
Makes no sense. It surely can not take THAT much time to do this paperwork?
All I'm going to say is giving a page limit to a lawyer is basically torture. Its the hardest thing for any lawyer.
 
I agree with all but one thing: They have a reason not to drag his butt: round fucking 2. I guess Vic doesn't because he's the kinda guy who only cares about proving the accusations false so he can go on with his life but everyone else sure as shit cares about seeing justice served and so long as that filthy rat Sabbat isn't even on the suit that is impossible.
I'm sorry, I'm sperging, but it honestly seems like they gave up on that alltogether. They better at least get this round straight. Vic deserves it.

Yes, that's the only ticking clock, I referenced that in my last sentence. But I vaguely recall seeing someone's analysis on here or on Nick's show that it's not a concern, if Sabat et al keep up what they've been doing they can be brought in later. Could be wrong though.

All I'm going to say is giving a page limit to a lawyer is basically torture. Its the hardest thing for any lawyer.

Yep. But I am also in favor of torturing lawyers.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo