no he is not. He doesn't know +- frames, counters, he can't reliably execute combos, his sf6 gameplay is the same patterns since the release of the game, he is blocking while pushing action buttons (this is his frustration when he whines "I was blawcking"), he can't even advance from scrubcore, let alone struggling for weeks and months to reach master with some of the characters.
Check one of j. wong's stream. These are both oldfarts in SF. JWong plays sf while reading chat and replying to chat, it's a second nature to him.
Phail struggles while playing sf, any sf.
Also no on the second part. PoP was playing 6 months and he beat phail in 3/4 of the games they matched together. PoP playted cammy, according to him, because she has a nice ass, not because she is a counter pick to anyone phil plays.
Please correct me or educate me on that. I did some search 1-2 years ago, when phil was still playing sf6, because I saw a few former competitors to phil who claimed the same and the statements didn't reflect what I saw.
I saw phil playing some broken and mostly top tier characters, i.e. bison, t hawk, sagat, blanka, vega in those older games, he peaked once at 4rth place on a very special ocassion with a game everyone shits upon, he didn't have multiple years being up there.
This reminds me the 2005 USA F1 grand prix
If phil participated in the USA 2005 grand prix with his shitbox, he would have been 7th place.
If you show someone phil's gameplay of sf and tell him that this guy plays this game for 30 years, they won't believe you.