The opinions that people are debating whether they agree with Phil on or not aren’t even, to my perception, actual opinions he has. Phil is a lizard creature. When he states an “opinion” on his streams he does it in the exact same way he has always stated “opinions” dating all the way back to his attempts to get attention on fighting game forums, or on his shitty Top Haters website. Everything he says is meant to either bait engagement (pure projection when he insults others for doing this), show what a special snowflake he is by being contrarian to a widely held opinion, or try to bait donations.
I am 100% convinced Phil does not even know what he himself believes. About much of anything, at this point, if he ever did. He operates under so many layers of deflection, delusion, and strange neuroses that anyone trying to piece together his belief system or find consistent opinions of his that aren’t the most generic common sense, is liable to lose their mind.