Victor Mignogna v. Funimation Productions, LLC, et al. (2019) - Vic's lawsuit against Funimation, VAs, and others, for over a million dollars.

Whats the remedy for this then?

Difficult to say. The court appears to have the ability to either send it back and order the defendants to amend the brief or supplement it to bring it to the proper lengths, all the way up to striking the motion/brief outright and continuing on as if they had not filed one. For Wick Phillips I could see Ty and Martinez doing the latter as they handed it off to their professional appeals department and they pulled off this abortion (look Wick Phillips, just because you can have an abortion during the quarantine doesn't mean you should put them out there); 50-50 on them asking the court to do the same thing for Funimation's filing, and I would wager they are going to give Sam Johnson a pass if it's not as egregious as the other defendants, if only because he's been the least combative and most professional of them. At the same time my expectation is that Ty is going to file a motion to have a 7,500 to 10,000 word limit for three responses as they have to reply to them all, and I think the court will give a lot of deference to the plaintiffs just because of the bullshit Wick Phillips in particular pulled.
 
For Wick Phillips I could see Ty and Martinez doing the latter as they handed it off to their professional appeals department and they pulled off this abortion

Honestly, I think has always been far too soft on them. He let them get away with blatant discovery abuse, and never pressed the motion to compell, or the other shit, and blatant lies in their filings.

I think they'll just let this slide again, once again getting themselves fucked over.
 
Honestly, I think has always been far too soft on them. He let them get away with blatant discovery abuse, and never pressed the motion to compell, or the other shit, and blatant lies in their filings.

I think they'll just let this slide again, once again getting themselves fucked over.

Nick confirmed he talked to Ty about at least FUNimation and MoROn going way over the limits, and the response from Ty is that that's absolute horseshit. According to Nick, he did not sound in the forgiving mood when he said that.
 
Nick confirmed he talked to Ty about at least FUNimation and MoROn going way over the limits, and the response from Ty is that that's absolute horseshit. According to Nick, he did not sound in the forgiving mood when he said that.

We'll see, but honestly he's been trying to be a gentleman in the face of frothing mob, and a mentally challenge chimp in a robe.

We'll see what happens, but so far I've only been impressed by Carey, Martinez and Hsu.
 
We'll see, but honestly he's been trying to be a gentleman in the face of frothing mob, and a mentally challenge chimp in a robe.

We'll see what happens, but so far I've only been impressed by Carey, Martinez and Hsu.

I'm not making excuses for Ty's blunders and I don't think he's want me to. However, Ty also knows that this is probably his last act when it comes to this entire debacle. If he fucks it up on appeal then he has to know that no matter what "win" Vic has when it comes to fighting back will be halved at the very least. It's impossible to believe he doesn't realize that and is going to become an absolute asshole. Taking someone's kindness for weakness is one of the biggest mistakes you can make in life.
 
Difficult to say. The court appears to have the ability to either send it back and order the defendants to amend the brief or supplement it to bring it to the proper lengths, all the way up to striking the motion/brief outright and continuing on as if they had not filed one. For Wick Phillips I could see Ty and Martinez doing the latter as they handed it off to their professional appeals department and they pulled off this abortion (look Wick Phillips, just because you can have an abortion during the quarantine doesn't mean you should put them out there); 50-50 on them asking the court to do the same thing for Funimation's filing, and I would wager they are going to give Sam Johnson a pass if it's not as egregious as the other defendants, if only because he's been the least combative and most professional of them. At the same time my expectation is that Ty is going to file a motion to have a 7,500 to 10,000 word limit for three responses as they have to reply to them all, and I think the court will give a lot of deference to the plaintiffs just because of the bullshit Wick Phillips in particular pulled.
Jesus did they all go over thier limits? I thought at least Marchis was within the word limit

Nick confirmed he talked to Ty about at least FUNimation and MoROn going way over the limits, and the response from Ty is that that's absolute horseshit. According to Nick, he did not sound in the forgiving mood when he said that.
When did he say this? It wasnt mentioned on last nights stream.
 
The cross-appellee’s brief for Vic is due on Monday, April 20th.

Annotation 2020-04-02 045451.jpg
 

Archivos adjuntos

Honestly, I think has always been far too soft on them. He let them get away with blatant discovery abuse, and never pressed the motion to compell, or the other shit, and blatant lies in their filings.
We can now say with hindsight that getting Chupp to do his job is a sisyphean task. There have been so many things Chupp should have done in this case that he simply didn't, because Chupp's idea of efficiency is kicking the can.
Ironically, this may work in Vic's favor in the appeal, provided that the appellate judges aren't complete Chupp-ups themselves.
 
Apparently, the CoA says the shenanigans that MoRon pulled is fine.
Whatever. The quicker this moot point in the appeals is done, the better.

Seriously, what is the point in the TRCP, and Appellette rules if parties can just shit all over them, and nothing is done about it.

This isn't like accidentally being over the word count by 50-100 words. Funimation is 33% over the word count, and MoRon is at double it.

Mental stuff.
 
Very interesting that this all started because some disgusting hags made a couple of false accusations. I am sure they think this makes them "stunning and brave," but in reality it just shows that they're absolute cunts. Cunts who tried to destroy a man all because of petty jelousy.

When you go back and look at it, without the "believe all women" mantra, their whole story falls apart like wet paper mache. As well it should. So scarce were their facts that they had to stoop to inventing ridiculous stories like "he ate a jellybean."

Not even a single accusation of actual rape - false or otherwise! "Everyone knows it, though," they said. "Vic has a long-standing reputation for this sort of thing." Except if you actually start asking people, you'll find that these accusations only circulated within their own tiny clique. Rather suspicious, don't you think?

Someone who was widely known as an abuser would have people crawling out of the woodwork with real accusations, not "he made a pregnant woman cry once by yelling at her because his signing table had no sharpies!" Even their worst accusations boil down to "he tried to proposition someone, and when they said no, he dropped it," so as far as their accusations of him being a pedophile? X to doubt on that. Unless they can come up with better evidence than him hugging a fan, that's just outright ridiculous. All sorts of voice actors engage with the public in the same ways they're finding fault with him for doing. Lots of projection going on here, if you asked me. Label him a pedo because he gave a fan a hug and a kiss on the cheek or forehead? You expect me to believe that they haven't done this too?

At the end of the day, this all boils down to their jealousy. They hated him because he was successful. They hated him because he was beloved. Rather than taking his example and becoming better toward their own fans, they opted to knife him in the back. A cowardly move. Can you blame him for opting to sue? They gave him no other choice. Either sue, or watch helplessly as his entire career went down in flames. Doubly hurtful because a lawsuit is so expensive, but at least he has the resources to pursue one.

To any other person, this could have been a death sentence. Others have killed themselves over this sort of thing.

Justice demands that false accusers must incur a price for their false accusations. Accusations which are serious and could destroy a man's life must be sifted to determine the truth, and whichever party is guilty must receive a fair punishment. Men facing these accusations are certainly punished; they have almost no hope of ever coming back from them. It's not even clear at this point whether ultimately he will. Encouraging as it is to see him getting invited back to some conventions after being canceled, there will be people no doubt still trying to undermine his career, and they have a frightening amount of control over the anime industry; they'll redouble their efforts at trying to force him out of it.

Maybe the tide will finally begin to be stemmed in these false accusations. As false accusers are held responsible for their malicious accusations, we can hope that they'll begin taking pause before they make them. Rather steep slope for us to try to climb, after we've already slid so far, but we cannot give up hope. Completely giving up now would just be accepting defeat. Having said all of this, now go back and read the first letter of every sentence. I rest my case.
 
Apparently, the CoA says the shenanigans that MoRon pulled is fine.
Whatever. The quicker this moot point in the appeals is done, the better.
I get the impression that the court would likely prefer to wait for one of the parties to motion for sanctions. I'll be disappointed of BHBC don't include a motion for sanctions along with their response.
 
Apparently, the CoA says the shenanigans that MoRon pulled is fine.
Whatever. The quicker this moot point in the appeals is done, the better.
I get the impression that the court would likely prefer to wait for one of the parties to motion for sanctions. I'll be disappointed of BHBC don't include a motion for sanctions along with their response.
Yeah, and that was actually only issued by the court's clerk. I doubt it'd be the clerk's place to possibly prejudice a party's case by rejecting their filing over some pedantic procedural BS. Even if the court felt aggrieved enough by the filing to dismiss it sua sponte (i.e. without Vic asking it to), I'd think that it would actually be a judge writing that order, not the clerk.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo