I'm hearing Alex Stein had a bit of a melty on Timcast IRL recently.
The one week I decide to not pay that much attention, & it ends up having an episode that goes viral...I saw the first five to ten minutes go relatively well, & just decided to presume the rest would be fine. The more fool I.
Though I have to ask what Tim thought would happen if the man known for both his over-the-top
performative &
seemingly genuine outrage would do as the host, if the situation arose.
It is like calling up Gilbert Gottfried,
hearing his answering machine message, & thinking this is the man to hire for the job of
serenading the babies in the neonatal ward.
But there is some extra context to be had, as Karys Rhea, the guest, was not helping things. Alex did not present himself well, but the guest did the same in her own way.
I shall clip some red flag moments for the blow-up, & the full exchange, here.
-It begins with some light interruptions by Karys, as Alex is talking:
& needless hair-splitting:
Alex begins to be frustrated, though still hamming it up, when Karys acts confused when asked her opinion of Zohram Mamdani. She starts by claiming she lives in Washington D.C., as if that means she can offer no opinion, but later admits to living in New York for 18 years, as recently as during COVID, & knew of Zohram before his rise to prominence. Not helping things is calling herself a "
Jewish-American Princess" & all the attitude which comes with it:
It rises to the point Alex states he is fed up with Karys, by using the Jewish-American Princess label on her, which can be taken as an off-hand insult, or joke:
During a conversation, Karys asks what "diddling" means & Alex explains it is pedophilia, & brings up Jeffrey Epstein. Though he chose to add the claim of the deceased diddler having multiple passports from Israel. Karys appears less than amused. While Epstein
did have multiple passports, I could not find information on how many he may have had from Israel:
(Updated with the correct clip. Thank you for the alert,
@Retink Retunk)
But making this seem more performative is Alex having a similar flip out over maps with Libby the co-host, as he would have over Epstein, later in the show. Though he does throw a barb at Karys' choice of stickers for her laptop:
-Here is the full exchange, ending at where the shorter clip does. the conversation begins with talk of Pres. Claudia Sheinbaum only being in power because the cartels permit it. Her being Jewish comes up, & Alex asks "I wonder if there's any correlation with that", looking at Karys. She appears to not be paying attention, as both Phil & Alex ask if Mossad got her elected, in what appears to be a joke. However, when Karys continues to be confused, Alex exclaims how "thick" she is for behaving like this. He goes on to ask if Claudia was on Epstein's island, which there is no record of, & asks Karys if she knows of
Ghislaine Maxwell's father & his
interment in one of the most auspicious graveyards in all of Israel. Karys displays a very dismissive attitude towards the possibility of Jeffrey Epstein working with Mossad, to the point of egging Alex on, to "tell me more from the groypers, tell more more from Candace Owens". This winds up Alex, where he accuses Karys of gaslighting, with the rest of the table being unwilling to call out her agitating Alex. Phil tries to cut this resolve this by disagreeing there were explicit intelligence ties, but there are powerful people linked to Epstein, which can indirectly link him to things like foreign intelligence services. Karys responding that the only real Epstein connections to Israel are via Ehud Barak, the former Prime Minister, though this does disregard alleged emails showing
Epstein monetarily invested in several Israeli-based companies &
being trusted to pass messages to Ehud over vetting Israeli applicants for positions:
Here is the start of the clipped moment, but including the remainder of the argument, after those thirty seconds. Once the well-known part ends, Karys jabs at Alex about becoming emotional, & he responds with asking about
the recent case of an Israeli cybersecurity official being caught attempting to solicit a minor, in Las Vegas. During this, Alex claims Netanyahu defended the man, but I can find no evidence of this. Karys claims no knowledge of this, & refuses to trust Alex's framing, because she suspects he does not like Benjamin for the same reasons she dislikes him. Alex says he does not like the Israeli prime minister "because he bombs hospitals", which Karys seizes on as an unreasonable criticism. Karys claims "Netanyahu is the same type of figure, internationally, like Trump was", being falsely accused of wrong-doing. This exchange continues, but Phil interjects to say that disagreement is permitted, but not abusing each other. Alex admits he is riled up, over being gas-lit, but as Phil is appearing to agree with him, Jamie jumps in to offer some treacly words about recognising Alex's upset. Alex decides to ask Jamie what she thinks, but she says she has no opinion. When Alex asks why not, Karys pounces to ask why the hot-heated host does not care about Sudan, or Yemen. This same argument was worn out when Tim deployed it, & many of the same problems with this what-aboutism, (U.S. policy towards these nations, military vs humanitarian aid, etc.) apply the same. Alex refuses to take this, & jokes it must be how well Palestinians are at marketing which make him focus on it. Karys labels this a double standard, but Alex rightfully points out those two nations are not lobbying the same way Israel does. The Jewish-American Princess tries to claim that Qatar is doing a lot more lobbying than Israel's supporters do, but Alex retorts with the number of AIPAC-funded office holders.
Both are somewhat right, as Qatar does employ many PR firms, but AIPAC funds more political campaigns. This goes on for several minutes, until Phil forces an end to it, with super-chats:
I did take a look at the clip of this exchange
posted on Tim's channel, & it does open previewing the screaming segment. But the comments look to be more on Alex's side, despite the attempt to frame this as him being the solely unreasonable one, with the start of the clip:
Tim is so over Sam Seder, & hates talking about him so much, that he keeps engaging with him. Despite the fact that allegedly Sam's channel was falling into obscurity without Tim, the beanie boy decides to drag him back into relevance by
making a video about him:
(
archive)
(For some reason the video is not embedding correctly, for me)
On 2 September, Tim made his return. The guest was Joshua Hammer, a conservative commentator & podcaster.
The co-hosts were Phil, & Tate the producer.
Clip Collection:
-Tim waives off criticism of him abandoning his hometown of Chicago, to live in a remote compound in the woods, claiming that if he had stayed it would have been "like asking someone to knock down a skyscraper with a ball-peen hammer". File this clip away for when the beanie boy squeals about people not risking everything to fight the way he wants. Despite a long convalescence, Tim has not changed:
-Tim says that after his severe case of laryngitis passed, the first thing he attempted to eat was Taco Bell:
-Tim does comment on Alex's performance as host, dogging on him a bit, but says he shall still be coming back for live events. Also, Tim talks about how YouTube gave him another channel, unprompted, which he used to host the Sam Seder video. But it looks like the new channel shall be for reacting to videos: