@Prokhor Zakharov @Dysnomia @Mesh Gear Fox
The plantain was basically all black this morning so I cut into it and I have thoughts
The skin was similar to my shitty bananas but much, much tougher. I almost couldn't peel it even after running a slit all the way along it. A big similarity was that the inside of the skin separated from exterior requiring me to basically peel it twice
Texture wise, very similar. The plantain was more bitey/'crunchy' (not actually crunchy but I don't have a good word for it, just it snapped when I bit into it but not when I chewed it) than a normal banana, similar to my shitty bananas but more pleasant, if only because it wasn't unexpected
Flavor-wise, very different. The bananas had very little flavor, but what little flavor they had was standard banana. The plantain was almost sweet-potato-y in a good way. Based on descriptions I wasn't expecting it to taste like much but it would have been totally edible if I felt like eating it raw. Very pleasant, no complaints at all. If they weren't such a massive pain in the ass to peel I'd probably keep one or two on hand for a snack
I looked up how they're normally eaten and it seems like most people fry them. The recipes I found didn't look very pleasant so I just made one up myself. Tablespoon of butter in the frying pan on medium heat, light sprinkle of turbinado sugar, nutmeg, and cinnamon. Very good but kinda mushy, the other recipes had them cut into chunks rather than slices like I did which I think is important so there's still some toughness to the center, the thickest slice was far and away the best one because it still had some texture aside from the crispy exterior. I'll definitely keep it in my pocket as a 'special occasions' kind of treat when I have visitors
So, without googling it, my guess as to what could have happened (without just sticking to the boring answer of 'I got a shitty batch of bananas') is maybe I got a bunch of hybrid bananas/plantains which caused them to be bigger, have a lot of starch, and didn't allow either flavor to shine through. I don't know if that's a thing that can happen but it makes sense to me!
@Overly Serious
I paid the extra twenty cents/lb for organic bananas when I picked up my plantain and they were very good, so if you want some bananas I'd just buy those for time being