So, I just watched that 8 hour PatricianTV video. I heavily recommend everyone do the same, I think this is the end-all video on the game that best explains not only why the game is bad, but what lead to this point so that it got made the way it did to begin with. The dude shows evidence as to what he's talking about, goes over interviews and early previews, even some community drama to give the whole picture of the game and where it was before and after it came out. As you might expect from the length, he also 100% the game and leaves no stone unturned, with 100% in this came meaning a whopping 10 playthrus with 40 hours each on average, each one being dedicated to a certain aspect of his video.
I've seen many people here ask "hurr durr why should I spend 80 hours watching some guy telling me that game bad when I KNOW the game is bad!"
Here is the thing, I doubt you actually know WHY the game is bad, or rather you wouldn't be able to articulate it properly when asked to write how in detail. Truth is that the rot that led to Starfield started years ago and you need all the context for that and the previous games to explain why many of it's parts work(or don't) the way they do, this is arguably just as much of a video on Bethesda(and Emil, boy does he have some choice words for him) as much as it is about the game itself. I haven't watched all his videos, but I did watch his Fallout 76 one and I recommend that one as well, unlike the others I saw that one actually goes over the game's entire history and lifecycle to paint a clear picture of that whole mess.
BTW I recommend watching the video in chunks unless you're some weirdo like me who needs to put something in the background at all times, within and outside of his home. 8 hours seems intimidating until you realize he paces the video very well and you can easily watch the video in small sessions as you see fit. Three 20 minute video breaks a day and you will finish it in just over a week, with the chapters ending and starting at just the right time so that it feels you're watching it in episodes rather than just one very long presentation, with his whole journey outlined as he goes along so that you don't just have "chapters" but rather a story with some tangents when they present themselves to make it easier to follow.
If you want a TL;DW as you don't plan ever seeing the video, let me spoil the very last sentence of it for you: "This is the game you(Bethesda fans) deserve", and he is absolutely right about that. Everyone knows the game is shit, we've known this for how many pages in this thread now? But it's one thing to laugh at the game from the sidelines and actively going over every inch of it to check just how bad things have gotten there, it's horrifying to think that Fallout 76 has it beat in more than one area and the fanbase cheered on them or at least enabled Bethesda every step of the way there. I think it's important not just to laugh at Bethesda, but to learn why this game failed, learn their lessons and then move on and forget this game exists. This is why I think this video is an important resource for people to understand and study this dumpster fire for years to come, rather than just another shitty video essay.
Looking forward to that 20 hour Skyrim one, I think this is an epilogue to that video in a sense in more ways than one.