star wars vs star trek

[Watcher]

I don't bother comparing them since they have very different appeals

 

[drtoboggan]

@cat had the right idea allowing voting for both. Which is worse: Voyager, Enterprise, or the prequels?

 

[exball]

@cat had the right idea allowing voting for both. Which is worse: Voyager, Enterprise, or the prequels?

Voyager has the virtue of actually having some pretty good episodes and producing the best series finale out of any Star Trek (DS9 had a good one but it was ruined by the Black Jesus magic battle). Enterprise had the Xindi, who are hands down the most retarded concept for villains since the Ferengi being taken seriously.

 

[melty]

Voyager has the virtue of actually having some pretty good episodes and producing the best series finale out of any Star Trek (DS9 had a good one but it was ruined by the Black Jesus magic battle). Enterprise had the Xindi, who are hands down the most retarded concept for villains since the Ferengi being taken seriously.

You are right about the Voyager finale, but what's wrong with the Xindi? Sure they aren't the greatest villians but I don't know about being completely retarded. I'd say the Kazon are worse.

 

[exball]

You are right about the Voyager finale, but what's wrong with the Xindi? Sure they aren't the greatest villians but I don't know about being completely retarded. I'd say the Kazon are worse.

My biggest gripe about the Xindi is the space whales. It's the most retarded concept ever right down to the whale singing.

That, and season three has the worst ratio of good episodes to bad episodes.

 

[melty]

I kind of liked the aquatics tbh, I thought it was a cool concept to have sentient aquatic creatures in Star Trek. I have no idea how they'd ever work with technology, though.
The Mantises were a little janky looking. I think it's admirable that they kept trying to do some interesting CGI creatures instead of just rubberhead aliens but the CGI just isn't good enough. Like Species 8472, I think they're great but the CGI is off. Then again I don't know why I'm complaining when pretty much every alien in Star Trek looks stupid.

 

[Strelok]

Kirk shot first.

Spoiler: big

 

[NeverHappened]

Xindi didn't make since biologically. Other than that, they were a decent adversary that could have save the series if they were more involved sooner. I had more of a problem with the humans(the crew) and vulcans of enterprise. I had no idea vulcans were actually religious about their logic. Yeah they meditate, but did they really need a holographic logic bible to start a holy war over?

 

[melty]

Enterprise just didn't have any compelling characters. There isn't a single character I'd even put on my top 10, maybe top 20. I don't even know who my favorite character was. Trip maybe? They are not necessarily bad but just flat and boring.
I dunno, maybe it's just me but in every other series there are at least 2-3 characters I really love

 

[exball]

Enterprise just didn't have any compelling characters. There isn't a single character I'd even put on my top 10, maybe top 20. I don't even know who my favorite character was. Trip maybe? They are not necessarily bad but just flat and boring.
I dunno, maybe it's just me but in every other series there are at least 2-3 characters I really love

Strongly disagree. Dr. Phlox was awesome and not boring at all.

 

[melty]

I liked Dr. Phlox a lot. One of my favorite Enterprise episodes was Doctor's Orders. However I don't recall him being the focus of all that many episodes and sorry to say he doesn't redeem Enterprise much when other series have characters like the Holographic Doctor, Data, etc. It's kind of like if Garak was the only good character in DS9.

 

[NeverHappened]

Well, Dr Phlox did do that one genocide thing but on most days when he's not committing genocide, he's one of the better characters. It just fits the whole thoughtless writing that went into the series.

Which is worst: Enterprise or the Star Wars prequels?

 

[XYZpdq]

Well, Dr Phlox did do that one genocide thing but on most days when he's not committing genocide, he's one of the better characters. It just fits the whole thoughtless writing that went into the series.

Which is worst: Enterprise or the Star Wars prequels?

Prequels. Ent was about to ramp it up to cool and have Shran join up as a regular and Quantum Leap was starting to figure out how to captain things. All he needed was a few computer gods to kick in the balls.
Prequels got the three movies they expected.

 

[Sigyn]

Star Trek all the way; if it weren't for the Trekkies this site would either not exist or be incredibly boring, as a trekkie wrote the first "slash" fic and a majority of early fanfiction, revolutionizing Fandom spergery for future generations

Also Janeway ftw

 

[AnOminous]

Star Trek all the way; if it weren't for the Trekkies this site would either not exist or be incredibly boring, as a trekkie wrote the first "slash" fic and a majority of early fanfiction, revolutionizing Fandom spergery for future generations

Also Janeway ftw

Janeway is worst captain.

 

[Sigyn]

Picard is worst captain BY FAR.

 

[AnOminous]

Picard is worst captain BY FAR.

Even Data was better as Acting Captain than Janeway.

 

[Lipitor]

Star Wars has a way better video games. So As far as that's concerned Star wars wins there.

 

[Picklepower]

I really like Star Wars but if I had to pick one, I'd pick Trek. I love the Star Wars movies, I don't even hate the prequels, but I don't know anything about the expanded universe. I haven't seen enough of Enterprise to say whether or not I think the series is good or bad.

 

[XYZpdq]

Star Wars has a way better video games. So As far as that's concerned Star wars wins there.

I wish there was a Deep Space Nine game where Dukat turns into a giant scorpion monster.