- Registrado
- 4 de Jun, 2018
Putting on my Devil's Advocate cap here for a moment, history is littered with quotes and examples of people stating 'Oh, this will never work' -- except it did. So I tend to not write off ideas outright.IMO a big problem is large chunks of the population are scientifically illiterate and their idea of "science" comes from sci-fi stories. Not even hard sci-fi, I'm talking soft sci-fi and even straight-up "Science-Fantasy" stuff like Star Wars. They see science as this linear progression where once you hit a special spot, magic powers are on the other end.
It becomes nearly impossible to get through to them at that point as they'll just write you off as a cliche "that'll never work" guy from said sci-fi when you try to explain science is a broad descriptor of fields examining the mechanics of our universe and not reshaping reality through sheer willpower.
MovieBob's thread is a decent example as he gets bent out of shape where someone points out that fully-automated luxury space communism doesn't work even theoretically and then suggests the issue can be solved with more money tossed at "science", never his ideas having no basis in reality. "We can make it real" after all.
However, a lot of these ideas are what are called 'blue sky' -- nice to think about, but no one is seriously pursuing them because the current technology won't allow us to explore these ideas. It's like 'what would you do if you won the Powerball?' -- we like to dream, but nobody's building their retirement plans around it (at least, I hope you people aren't...).
A good example is 'green' energy. Now, I think solar and wind are good for supplementing an existing power grid, but they are simply not viable for uninterrupted power at this time. Battery technology needs a quantum leap forward for starters, and then you have the simple fact that the sun does not always shine and the wind does not always blow.
But because 'it's the FUTURE!', people keep blathering on about how we need more solar and wind and less coal and oil, despite the shortcomings apparent.