🐱 She-Ra's Catradora Set A New Benchmark For Queer Animation

CatParty



LGBTQ+ characters in animation have become more commonplace in recent years, with shows like The Owl House and Steven Universehelping to show young viewers that it’s okay to be yourself - whether you’re gay, bisexual, transgender or anything on the queer spectrum. Only a few short years ago, studios were afraid to present such individuals on the screen, deeming it inappropriate for children who might be wrongly influenced by such honest portrayals of diversity. It’s a crass lie, but one that cemented itself in a society that remains abundantly heteronormative.

Fortunately, the landscape has and continues to change, with She-Ra and The Princesses of Power acting as a particular trailblazer in the world of animation. Made possible by the likes of Steven Universe, this modern retelling of the classic cartoon is confidently queer in almost every way. Helmed by Noelle Stevenson, known for works such as Nimona and Lumberjanes, it was clear from its opening season that the tale of Catra and Adora was more than just a simple friendship. Across its 52 episodes myriad hints were sprinkled in, leading fans to hope and hope that perhaps their wildest dreams could come true.

Even as the final season aired, naysayers were awash with doubts, laughing away at shippers who were just waiting to have their hopes dashed in favour of a platonic ending. The truth was far more rewarding, with Catra and Adora putting aside their rivalry and confessing their love for one another, the climax being a gay kiss that would rid Etheria of evil and save the world. I like to think that the entire saving the world part was just a coincidence, and Adora just decided to smooch this cute catgirl because they were both going to die anyway.

That’s the magnificence of it - their confession of love is pure and unfiltered. To them, the world could be doomed, with Catra begging for Adora to think about her own needs for once in her life as she valiantly sacrifices herself for the safety of others. Adora might be capable of transforming into She-Ra, but beneath that sits a young woman with her own quirks, flaws, and needs. She has spent so many years trying to be a leader for so many people that she seldom thinks about herself, or the childhood friend she left behind in favour of fighting for the greater good.

There was never a time to grieve, so when the two come back together and the odds are stacked against them - an honest declaration of their true love pours out. I took a day off work to binge the final season, squealing like a desperate fangirl as the kiss scene unfolded, shocked that all the doubts and theories materialised into something physical. Now a year has passed, it’s worth analysing how much has changed.

In the weeks following the final season’s release, I couldn’t scroll through my social media feed for a second without seeing fans shouting from the rooftops about Catradora, shocked that it actually happened or speaking about how it sets such a lofty benchmark for queer animation moving forward. I can’t help but agree with them, since so many projects have emerged following its release that aren’t afraid to be queer, whether this is through subtle or explicit means. The Owl House was Disney’s first animated children’s show to feature a queer romance without compromise, while Dreamwork’s own Kipo And The Wonderbeasts was equally as welcoming in its depiction of gay couples.

When all we got with the finale of Legend of Korra in 2014 was obscure hand-holding despite the creators absolutely confirming the central romance, it’s difficult to comprehend how far we’ve come. Obstacles still stand before us, and the best queer stories are still found in smaller, independent spaces, but it’s clear that larger companies can see the value in LGBTQ+ narratives, and I just hope that isn’t thrown away once the profits dry up. But I’m convinced they won’t, and even if they do, queer experiences will always find a way to bleed into creative mediums. They matter, and will continue to grow and expand as we move forward.

I think the brilliance of Catradora is how it isn’t a clean relationship. It’s romance born out of childhood bonding, a traumatic separation, and coming to terms with the flaws that define you. Catra and Adora spent so long determined to hate one another, or to at least convince themselves that it was impossible to comprehend any semblance of forgiveness. The reality is far more complicated, because people are messy, and can’t deny their true feelings regardless of whether they end up hurting those closest to them. Catra’s redemption arc isn’t a clean one. She hurt people, and needs to atone for these sins, but Adora is willing to help her on that journey, understanding that people are capable of change even after doing horrible things.

Throughout the five seasons they fight and bicker constantly, but their bond remains resolute. We often make enemies due to circumstances we can’t control, building resentment that will inevitably boil over and force us to face who we really are, and what we really feel about everything around us. Their confession scene is exactly that, an explosion of bottled emotions that finally erupt after years of being hidden away. Adora never hated Catra, and once that truth is out in the open, they both have time to heal, to foster a deeper, more honest love for one another. This raw storytelling, despite being wrapped up in a colourful children’s show, is exactly what makes it so special.

So as I look back on the show a year after its conclusion and forward to the possibilities it has opened up for queer creators, I can’t help but admire everything it managed to achieve. I’ve no doubt Catradora will remain prevalent throughout the zeitgeist for years to come. I got a tattoo based on the show, so I’m in it for the long haul whether I like it or not.
 
Ha. Well agree to disagree. Don't want my kids to watch lame christian stories and grow up to be lame-o nerds.



It's not so much they see X and they become X but they do soak up information around them like a sponge. One viewing won't do much but the constant reinforcement does have an effect eventually, especially when parents aren't present to correct any misinformation. I grew up on an unhealthy amount of tv and internet and can trace some strange behavior I exhibit as a kid because of "I saw my peers on tv do it".

Of course parental involvement will correct that but from I see these days there's a huge lack of in the generation growing up. More likely to get advice from YouTube influencer then their parents.

But to circle back. I don't trust this group of current queer writers who will mutilate themselves because it's currently trendy as they write not for kids but for their peer group masquerading as children's media.
I am sorry you have long, ongoing issues with telling the difference between reality and fiction. Maybe see a psychiatrist about it?
 
And you know what, SPOP wouldn't have been so bad if Noelle just kept her mouth shut about her bullshit headcanons (like how Catra leaks herself, or how Scorpia is her abused ex)
Source? Because if true....
:story: :story: :story:
cartoon lesbians won't make kids think abuse irl is ok.
Talk about missing the forest for the trees..... that's not the reason why we're taking issue with this. 1. Kids aren't watching this shit anyway.

2. It's the blatant hypocrisy of the alphabet people - like people ITT have pointed out, had Catra been male, the very same people would be screeching about how it's "ABUSE" and "MUH SOGGY KNEES!" But make her a lesbian, and suddenly all the abusive behavior is hand waved away because "YAAAAS CARTOON LESBOS YAAAAAAS". They'll latch onto anything and claim it as the pinnacle of LGBTQ+ representation in "children's" media. FFS, they tried to make ELSA one of them, because Disney needs to submit to the LGBTQ+ strapon now now now now now NOW! Fortunately, come Frozen 2, they failed miserably.....or did they?
TL;DR:
I don't trust this group of current queer writers who will mutilate themselves because it's currently trendy as they write not for kids but for their peer group masquerading as children's media
 
Source? Because if true....
:story: :story: :story:

Talk about missing the forest for the trees..... that's not the reason why we're taking issue with this. 1. Kids aren't watching this shit anyway.

2. It's the blatant hypocrisy of the alphabet people - like people ITT have pointed out, had Catra been male, the very same people would be screeching about how it's "ABUSE" and "MUH SOGGY KNEES!" But make her a lesbian, and suddenly all the abusive behavior is hand waved away because "YAAAAS CARTOON LESBOS YAAAAAAS". They'll latch onto anything and claim it as the pinnacle of LGBTQ+ representation in "children's" media. FFS, they tried to make ELSA one of them, because Disney needs to submit to the LGBTQ+ strapon now now now now now NOW! Fortunately, come Frozen 2, they failed miserably.....or did they?
TL;DR:
So if it's retarded to screech hysterically about how a het hero/villain ship NORMALIZES ABUSE!!!!, why is it not equally retarded to do the same thing with a gay one?
 
I am sorry you have long, ongoing issues with telling the difference between reality and fiction. Maybe see a psychiatrist about it?

Again. Difference between kids and adults. Do you have kids? Don't answer, i know you don't. But kids really are dumb and as a society we coddle them and reinforcement their dumbness in the media we give them. They believe in a man flying around the world once a year giving presents to the good kids that his stasi (elf on a shelf) reports on.

We teach them to fit in with their peers and always trust those older then them. So now we got children's media telling them that abusive relationships are great, everyone is gay and when they get older to mutilate themselves like the writer of media they watch did.
 
Again. Difference between kids and adults. Do you have kids? Don't answer, i know you don't. But kids really are dumb and as a society we coddle them and reinforcement their dumbness in the media we give them. They believe in a man flying around the world once a year giving presents to the good kids that his stasi (elf on a shelf) reports on.

We teach them to fit in with their peers and always trust those older then them. So now we got children's media telling them that abusive relationships are great, everyone is gay and when they get older to mutilate themselves like the writer of media they watch did.
I remember being a kid and even then I remember thinking people blaming fiction for real world problems is retarded.

Oh no the scary cartoon lesbians or space wizards will make kids think real abuse is ok just like how DOOM will convince them to shoot up their schools or pewdiepie will turn them into white supremacists
 
So if it's retarded to screech hysterically about how a het hero/villain ship NORMALIZES ABUSE!!!!, why is it not equally retarded to do the same thing with a gay one?
It's the blatant hypocrisy of the alphabet people
tumblr_inline_mgtttkMdQa1qfe5t2.png

Yes, both are equally retarded, but notice how said group gets pissy over one (e.g. Reylo) and yet excuses the other (Catradora) solely because they both happen to be female. It's like how whenever a black criminal gets shot by a white cop, BLM shows up in droves to "peacefully protest", and yet, whenever an innocent black child gets struck by a stray bullet shot during a gang shootout/drive-by, it's either crickets or "THAT'S DEFLECTING FROM THE REAL ISSUE OF SYSTEMIC RACISM". It's all for the benefit of their narrative - any "inconvenient truths" are either handwaved away or outright ignored. Again, you're missing the forest for the trees here.
Isn’t this the show that got in trouble for drawing their black character as a farmerplantation slave?
Yes. Unlike other people who were "canceled" however, Noelle seems to have gotten off scot-free. Hmm, I wonder why?
:thinking:
 
Nah actually fundie kids shit is fan-fucking-tastic viewing when you're baked. Especially shit like Psalty and the donut one that became a meme.

Blaming fiction for real life issues is retarded and it always has been. DOOM does not cause school shootings, video game boobs don't turn people into rapists, and cartoon lesbians won't make kids think abuse irl is ok.
Plus the original He-Man was so gay it's practically a meme now.
 
The only thing I bothered to remember about this show is that every character looks like they got a double mastectomy. There's zero reason why there's not even a scintilla of breast.

Oh, wait-- didn't the creator or someone around that high up get a double mastectomy?
It's the "13-year-old boy in drag" aesthetic they're going for. That's why the "woke" She-Ra looks like Dean Venture doing a cosplay bit, flat chest and all. It's no coincidence the creator went on to adopt that same look for herself.
Ver archivo adjunto 2146504
I guess looking like a depressed millennial is the new fad
 
It’s easy to criticize SJWs for idiocy, hypocrisy, and other bad behavior. But even a broken clock is right twice a day. Sometimes SJWs do make good points that are ignored or deflected.

I think society still has many problems with (in this case) sexism, objectification, homophobia, etc. It’s a lot harder to identify and discuss these problems and any potential solutions. SJW rhetoric and bad solutions made it needlessly difficult to broach.
 
listen, if Noelle wanted to make She-ra a lesbian, why didn't she just make Seahawk a woman? I'll take a dashing ginger pirate queen instead of Noelle's self-insert power fantasy. What they did to Seahawk in the show is an insult to men in general.
 
listen, if Noelle wanted to make She-ra a lesbian, why didn't she just make Seahawk a woman? I'll take a dashing ginger pirate queen instead of Noelle's self-insert power fantasy. What they did to Seahawk in the show is an insult to men in general.
Can Queen Seahawk have a beard to be more inclusive of women with beards and be ultramasculine to be inclusive of butch lesbians and tomboys? Oh, and can we have scenes where people constantly mistake her for a man and she just brushes it off because pronouns are a social construct (that aren’t even universal in all languages) and she doesn’t need social constructs to feel comfortable in her own skin?
 
Can Queen Seahawk have a beard to be more inclusive of women with beards and be ultramasculine to be inclusive of butch lesbians and tomboys? Oh, and can we have scenes where people constantly mistake her for a man and she just brushes it off because pronouns are a social construct (that aren’t even universal in all languages) and she doesn’t need social constructs to feel comfortable in her own skin?
What season of Steven Universe is this?
 
Atrás
Top Abajo