Freddy vs. Jason has probably aged well thanks to the mediocrity of the last 20 years and 2000's nostalgia, but back at release it was an absolutely terrible movie. Even I, someone who watched the trashiest of trash back then, hated it.
A big problem with movies like this is that they can't commit to either side winning lest one side of the fanbase will walk away unsatisfied. So what you have is a movie that literally pulls its punches.
And RLM's continual seething over being wrong about J.J. Abrams is just funny at this point. They can't live it down.
Also Jay is lame referring to fan "entitlement" for wanting original actors.