Read the CWCki more. Every one of your theories and "conjectures" are answered there.
Actually, it isn't and it seems it won't be. This is where there is a dearth of information on Chris's activities post 2016. Prior to Wise, trolls often released documents, audio, and videos which were widely available to people to view and peruse over. Even your activities as Liquid Bob are documented somewhat. We have no physical media (written, video, audio) of what Chris's activities were with Wise prior to the Idea Guys and subsequently during their time. The CWCwiki has basic outlines of events but in comparison to BlueSpike for example, they are woefully empty.
Yes certain things such as Chris pooping should never be viewed in public, but the only reference in the wiki is Null and/or TheCaptain talking about the video and that's it. For example, the video of Chris punching Barb. Reading the wiki we know it happened solely because it is referenced in a quote by Null. There is no talk of the video subsequent to the quote indicating that the writers themselves know little to nothing about it. If Null or TheCaptain decided not to release that information we'd never know it would have happened. Furthermore, I am sure that there are many events that aren't recorded in the wiki regarding the Idea Guys because simply the writers of the wiki do not know about it.
If I wanted to write about it academically, there would have to be evidence regarding why it happened, the conversation before, during, and after the punch, how lightly he actually punched Barb and where he punched her, and what was Barb's reaction just to name a few. Now I understand that much like Bob's Death audio it may never be released until Chris is dead if it was actually saved by anyone, which is a good thing, but we really have too little information. The only thing we do have is a biased account where Wise and Boyd talk about their conversation. However, I wouldn't trust them to give me a straight answer.
The one thing I will say though is that you have to take into account how old Bluespike was during that incident. He was 13. A middle schooler. He was just an immature kid barely out of his pre-teens. I could give him a pass on the shit he did close to 15 years ago because he's pretty much not that same person anymore. Wise though? Wise was 24 at the time of the IG saga. Old enough to know what he was doing was fucked up.
Sorry but that's a bad take. Trolling, malicious trolling at that, knows no age boundaries. A normal child of 5-6 knows that its bad to make other children cry, to hit and punch them and such. BlueSpike and Wise are both psychopaths' each at a different level. Age has nothing to do with it. Especially because we have evidence that other trolls who BlueSpike hung around with were clearly taken aback by his maliciousness.
Thank you for your insights into the other trolls and the watchmen.