Let's talk DVD's - Enhanced with DisneyFastplay!

  • 🔧 Site instability resolved. You can report double-posts and broken attachments. For bigger issues, use the Technical Grievances thread.
    🇵🇦 Nuestro primer dominio localizado está en español en kiwifarms.pa. Our first localized domain is on Spanish on kiwifarms.pa.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

What is the best format?

  • Vhs

    Votos: 6 16.2%
  • Dvd

    Votos: 19 51.4%
  • Bluray

    Votos: 7 18.9%
  • Gameboy advanced video

    Votos: 15 40.5%

  • Total de votantes
    37
That's how it should be always. The main feature should begin immediately, and I'll press menu if I want to see it.

Some DVD menus really are ridiculous. At the beginning here will be an animation, usually winding down a poorly rendered CGI hallway, that takes you to the main menu. Another animation will take you down another CGI hallway to see a sub-menu, and sometimes you have to watch another one to go back to the main! It's so pointless.
Im either way with whether the movie or menu pops first but oh god I remember the Lion King dvd being the worst offender of it. A full minute of zazu flying across the savanna till he gets to pride rock and then he talks to the audience.
And to my knowledge you can never skip the beginning until the option to play shows up.
 
Sorry to unbury and bringing back this thread from the dead but I saw that article who said then DVDs are the new vinyl records.

DVDs are the new vinyl records: Why Gen Z is embracing physical media​


Before the lights dimmed for the film, "The Lady from Shanghai" at Vidiots, Aidan Gannon and Jason Fine were busy perusing the aisles of endless DVDs. For these young cinephiles, the Eagle Rock hub isn't just a theater — it’s a gateway to film history.

In a matter of minutes, the 24-year-olds found themselves in the thick of its “Star Wars” DVD and Blu-ray collection, reminiscing about the special features they enjoyed as kids.

But for them, collecting and watching DVDs isn't merely a childhood memory. They've rediscovered the medium as adults.

“I want something I can put on my shelf," Gannon said, having recently collected 200 discs. "I can go shopping in my closet and grab something and pop it in, instead of spending an hour scrolling through Netflix to find something and then just turning on the same TV show.”
I guess a good bunch of people like to own physical media, whatever TPTB like it or not.
 
I know it's not an exact comparison because they still make new turntables upon which to play vinyl records while I don't think any new Laserdisc players have been made in at least the past quarter century, not even in Japan, but Laserdisc should be the new vinyl if we're talking about collecting cover art since the sleeves are the exact same size as those for vinyl records.
 
My only gripe with DVDs is that even when they are clean with little to no scratches, they sometimes skip and/or refuse to play. I'm not sure if it's the player specifically, but it's a big pet-peeve of mine, because it can make ripping them a huge pain in the ass.

Even when it comes to cleaning them, you can't ever get a straight answer. it's either you wipe up'n'down, polish them clock/counterclock wise, or the "unique" one I've seen where you use toothbrush and toothpaste to clean them.
 
My only gripe with DVDs is that even when they are clean with little to no scratches, they sometimes skip and/or refuse to play. I'm not sure if it's the player specifically, but it's a big pet-peeve of mine, because it can make ripping them a huge pain in the ass.

Even when it comes to cleaning them, you can't ever get a straight answer. it's either you wipe up'n'down, polish them clock/counterclock wise, or the "unique" one I've seen where you use toothbrush and toothpaste to clean them.
That's why I voted for VHS as the best medium. The picture quality isn't bad in comparison to DVD, and it's becoming clear that DVDs (and Blu Ray) are a crapshoot as far as longevity goes. Some of them were just manufactured poorly and will eventually crap out on you randomly after a decade or so. VHS tapes, on the other hand, as long as they are well cared for, are far more dependable for long term storage. The main downside to VHS tapes are finding and maintaining something to play them on.
 
My only gripe with DVDs is that even when they are clean with little to no scratches, they sometimes skip and/or refuse to play. I'm not sure if it's the player specifically, but it's a big pet-peeve of mine, because it can make ripping them a huge pain in the ass.

Even when it comes to cleaning them, you can't ever get a straight answer. it's either you wipe up'n'down, polish them clock/counterclock wise, or the "unique" one I've seen where you use toothbrush and toothpaste to clean them.
bitrot. most of my troma and b film collection is fucked by it. they've all been ripped into various format of course.

dvd is still the only way to watch the toxie movies in the original 4:3 aspect ratio.
 
bitrot. most of my troma and b film collection is fucked by it. they've all been ripped into various format of course.
I did some digging, and it turns out a lot of those Troma and B-movie titles were pressed on cheap discs that are prone to degrading. I absolutely loathe disc rot, but it’s definitely worth archiving what you have while you still can.
1772029602021.png
 
The homestar runner ones
i own all of them (except everything else vol 3, which i had to find online), and idk what dvd making program they used but they are a bitch and a half to rip everything from those discs. One example i can think of is the Halloween one where Strong Sad and Marzipan try to recurrent her dead plant. There's a Stinkoman easter egg that for whatever reason Handbreak or MakeMKV can't detect so I have to play the actual cartoon on a media player and record the screen.

otherwise in general they have like 50+ chapters of stuff on Handbreak that is a project to sort through because either they are duplicates, or you need to switch the angle to get the rest of the easter eggs to show (e.g. the website advert where Homestar is in different random outfits in a specific take. The dvd only adds 4 outfits, one of them is him in the nude)
 
i own all of them (except everything else vol 3, which i had to find online), and idk what dvd making program they used but they are a bitch and a half to rip everything from those discs. One example i can think of is the Halloween one where Strong Sad and Marzipan try to recurrent her dead plant. There's a Stinkoman easter egg that for whatever reason Handbreak or MakeMKV can't detect so I have to play the actual cartoon on a media player and record the screen.

otherwise in general they have like 50+ chapters of stuff on Handbreak that is a project to sort through because either they are duplicates, or you need to switch the angle to get the rest of the easter eggs to show (e.g. the website advert where Homestar is in different random outfits in a specific take. The dvd only adds 4 outfits, one of them is him in the nude)
Yeah I know which is why I just kept them as roms and hope against hope for a dvd player emulator plugin for media servers
 
Sorry to unbury and bringing back this thread from the dead but I saw that article who said then DVDs are the new vinyl records.


I guess a good bunch of people like to own physical media, whatever TPTB like it or not.
The browsing aspect of physical media cannot be overstated with how useful it is. It's something that you really can't recreate with a list on a screen. CDs made me realize that, but it is perfectly applicable to DVDs and Blu-ray as well.

Also, one of the best uses of physical media is avoiding modern day, dystopian corporate algorithms.
 
DVDs is the last good format to watch animated hand drawn cartoons on. I'm sorry, it just doesn't look right on Blu-ray or 4K. I watched Aladdin in 4K one time and it looked really bad. If you watching anything CGI you can go beyond that.

It really depends on how the remaster was handled. If the studio scrubs out too much grain with heavy digital noise reduction, the image can end up looking flat or waxy. But when they respect the original texture and do a careful restoration, Blu‑ray and 4K can preserve the animation far better than DVD. But sometimes a DVD is good enough.
 
I'm sorry, it just doesn't look right on Blu-ray or 4K. I watched Aladdin in 4K one time and it looked really bad
The last time I was at the orthodontist, they had a 4K TV installed, and Sleeping Beauty was playing on it. I hadn't seen it in years, but I knew it looked wrong because 4K inserts "invisible" frames to give it that "60 FPS" look that older media didn't have because that wasn't the proper technique. It's absolutely atrocious and I just know it's fucking with children's brains in giving them such false impressions on how animation actually looks.

If you watching anything CGI you can go beyond that.
Honestly, I don't know about that because CGI animation still adheres to the 24 FPS format we have here in the west. I haven't checked out a 4K CGI series to know, though, but I bet it looks just as uncanny as that LEGO TV show where it was done without skipping frames like the movies do.
 
Physical stuff is nice but you need to be sure that you have the right edition of the DVD (or DVD box set), sometimes the compression is different.

The last time I was at the orthodontist, they had a 4K TV installed, and Sleeping Beauty was playing on it. I hadn't seen it in years, but I knew it looked wrong because 4K inserts "invisible" frames to give it that "60 FPS" look that older media didn't have because that wasn't the proper technique. It's absolutely atrocious and I just know it's fucking with children's brains in giving them such false impressions on how animation actually looks.
That might be the TV being set at a wrong mode.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo