Ex Catholics? - Any ex catholics here want to share why they left

  • 🔧 Site instability resolved. You can report double-posts and broken attachments. For bigger issues, use the Technical Grievances thread.
    🇵🇦 Nuestro primer dominio localizado está en español en kiwifarms.pa. Our first localized domain is on Spanish on kiwifarms.pa.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
1864897514651 dijo:
You are misunderstanding me. 'Total bullshit' cannot be a catechism. I called this document 'total bullshit' and pointed you towards real catechisms because this document is not a real catechism, and it never has been a real catechism. A catechism is a book of instruction for the faithful—or it is oral instruction. The word catechism comes from the Greek katekhein, which means to resound. If a document does not resound the foundations of the faith in either Sacred Tradition or in Sacred Scripture, then it is not catechetical. It is impossible for this 1992 document to be a catechism for the teachings of the Catholic Church because it teaches heresy against the Church.

Jesus would not ever, EVER ask the faithful to catechize themselves with a document that teaches heresy against His Church. You have positioned this document preposterously in your mind. Just because the Church says that something is its 'catechism' does not mean that you must regurgitate that statement without due discretion on your part. God gave you a rational intellect to observe the situation for yourself and then draw your own conclusions from said observations. I have read and observed this document, and my conclusion from said observation is that this document is total bullshit. Paragraph 841 is not the only point of heresy in it; I could write an entire essay with examples on why the 1992 'catechism' is not a catechetical document for the Roman Catholic Church. Pope John Paul II answered for promulgating this piece of shit at his Particular Judgment, and we will all know the outcome at the General Judgment.
Presiona para expandir...

Too heretical ; didn't read.
 
1864897514651 dijo:
You are misunderstanding me. 'Total bullshit' cannot be a catechism. I called this document 'total bullshit' and pointed you towards real catechisms because this document is not a real catechism, and it never has been a real catechism. A catechism is a book of instruction for the faithful—or it is oral instruction. The word catechism comes from the Greek katekhein, which means to resound. If a document does not resound the foundations of the faith in either Sacred Tradition or in Sacred Scripture, then it is not catechetical. It is impossible for this 1992 document to be a catechism for the teachings of the Catholic Church because it teaches heresy against the Church.

Jesus would not ever, EVER ask the faithful to catechize themselves with a document that teaches heresy against His Church. You have positioned this document preposterously in your mind. Just because the Church says that something is its 'catechism' does not mean that you must regurgitate that statement without due discretion on your part. God gave you a rational intellect to observe the situation for yourself and then draw your own conclusions from said observations. I have read and observed this document, and my conclusion from said observation is that this document is total bullshit. Paragraph 841 is not the only point of heresy in it; I could write an entire essay with examples on why the 1992 'catechism' is not a catechetical document for the Roman Catholic Church. Pope John Paul II answered for promulgating this piece of shit at his Particular Judgment, and we will all know the outcome at the General Judgment.
Presiona para expandir...
That sounds like something @Skylar Ittner would say.
 
I read the 95 Theses and began a journey of self discovery filled with moments of clarity.

I now chuckle when Roman Catholics call themselves Catholic. You're misusing the word. You're Roman Catholic. Catholic means "universal" and you ain't that. Not by a long shot.
 
I live in Poland, one of the most catholic countries in the world and I really dont understand why would anyone want to belong to this pedophilic pseudo political cult of misogyny, usurpation and control.

Have faith if the thought of no after life scares the shit out of you but for gods sake (pun intended) stay away from that social cancer known as organized religion.
 
RussianBlonde dijo:
I live in Poland, one of the most catholic countries in the world and I really dont understand why would anyone want to belong to this pedophilic pseudo political cult of misogyny, usurpation and control.

Have faith if the thought of no after life scares the shit out of you but for gods sake (pun intended) stay away from that social cancer known as organized religion.
Presiona para expandir...

Cultural thing. Also not all priests are kid diddlers.
 
wellthathappened dijo:
They are, but you got Rabbis who bite foreskins off babies but no one views that as an overall representation.
Presiona para expandir...

Metzizah bpeh known as oral suction cirumcision takes place only in super orthodox jewish communities and is in fact very rare. And how did you come to the conclusion that it isnt seen as controversial? NY has been trying to put a stop to it and pretty much everyone is disgusted by it.

And it really doesnt matter. Why are you defending a pedo cult? Maybe you need to see Spotlight.
 
RussianBlonde dijo:
Metzizah bpeh known as oral suction cirumcision takes place only in super orthodox jewish communities and is in fact very rare. And how did you come to the conclusion that it isnt seen as controversial? NY has been trying to put a stop to it and pretty much everyone is disgusted by it.

And it really doesnt matter. Why are you defending a pedo cult? Maybe you need to see Spotlight.
Presiona para expandir...

Seen it. Great flick.
 
I grew up in a fairly observant Catholic home but was encouraged to be a free thinker. As I got older and started developing moral and ethical views I found it harder and harder to reconcile my Catholic faith with my personal convictions. One had to break, and I found it easier to abandon my faith than abandon my core values.
 
crunchysalty dijo:
The current pope is a joke. I was raised Catholic, now lutheran. Believe is what saves you, no matter your sins. The shed blood thing.
Presiona para expandir...

If you went to Lutherans over Catholics, you probably have some serious issues regarding the RCC that had nothing to do with the current pope.
 
crunchysalty dijo:
[redacted]
Presiona para expandir...

What an absolute idiot you are. No wonder you rejected Jesus. Do you realize who the biggest joke to humanity was? It was Jesus. Our King was scourged and heckled at the pillar by us. We put the crown of thorns on Him and called Him King of the Jews. We forced our King to carry our cross as we brought Him to His death. Our King was a Spotless Lamb that was made out to be the ultimate joke by us. We inscribed Iesus Nazarenus Rex Iudaeorum above His head, not realizing that we are the Jews that He purchased with His Most Precious Blood.

Pope Ratzinger is an awful pope, but if your metric for belief in the catholicity of Christ's One Church is whether or not you agree with the reproofs due to us sinners by Jesus, then you are profoundly stupid. We deserve this pope that sits in silence as cardinal Jorge Bergoglio usurps the Petrine See in a cold coup d'état. You did not even take the time to go through the logical progressions for why this situation exists. Do you know what you are doing to the Church by rejecting it and calling our pope a joke? You are doing exactly what it is that we sinners did to Christ roughly two thousand years ago. You are telling the Bride of Christ that She is not your King, and you are leaving Her to bear your cross.

But the Church will not bear your cross this time. Your sins have already been paid for, and the earthly authority established by Christ has already been given to the Catholic Church. By rejecting the Church, you reject Jesus as your King. So good luck with answering to that at your Particular Judgment before the Throne of Christ. Jesus is not going to take, "Pope Ratzinger is a joke," as a valid answer, and He will not find it funny.
 
1864897514651 dijo:
What an absolute idiot you are. No wonder you rejected Jesus. Do you realize who the biggest joke to humanity was? It was Jesus. Our King was scourged and heckled at the pillar by us. We put the crown of thorns on Him and called Him King of the Jews. We forced our King to carry our cross as we brought Him to His death. Our King was a Spotless Lamb that was made out to be the ultimate joke by us. We inscribed Iesus Nazarenus Rex Iudaeorum above His head, not realizing that we are the Jews that He purchased with His Most Precious Blood.

Pope Ratzinger is an awful pope, but if your metric for belief in the catholicity of Christ's One Church is whether or not you agree with the reproofs due to us sinners by Jesus, then you are profoundly stupid. We deserve this pope that sits in silence as cardinal Jorge Bergoglio usurps the Petrine See in a cold coup d'état. You did not even take the time to go through the logical progressions for why this situation exists. Do you know what you are doing to the Church by rejecting it and calling our pope a joke? You are doing exactly what it is that we sinners did to Christ roughly two thousand years ago. You are telling the Bride of Christ that She is not your King, and you are leaving Her to bear your cross.

But the Church will not bear your cross this time. Your sins have already been paid for, and the earthly authority established by Christ has already been given to the Catholic Church. By rejecting the Church, you reject Jesus as your King. So good luck with answering to that at your Particular Judgment before the Throne of Christ. Jesus is not going to take, "Pope Ratzinger is a joke," as a valid answer, and He will not find it funny.
Presiona para expandir...

Lol calm your 'tism down. The Lutherans believe in Christ. ML just didn't believe in the political bs the Catholic Church was spreading.
Like paying to be forgiven based on the sin. It was all about money and control. ML called them out on it. Faith is a personal choice. Not something the church decides. You tard. And the pope is still a joke.
 
Última edición:
crunchysalty dijo:
Lol calm your 'tism down. The Lutherans believe in Christ. ML just didn't believe in the political bs the Catholic Church was spreading.
Like paying to be forgiven based on the sin. It was all about money and control. ML called them out on it. Faith is a personal choice. Not something the church decides. You tard.
Presiona para expandir...

I was mostly thinking along the lines of following someone who began by nailing a letter to a Catholic church may have deeper disagreements than the current pope.

With that said, I have absolutely no idea what that weird fucker was ranting about.
 
Debes iniciar sesión o registrarte para responder aquí.
Atrás
Top Abajo