NOTICE:
I really hope this doesn't sound too off or unprepared, I just don't have much choice anymore.
So I didn't want to make this until Mulberry's Ayano cousin art officially comes out on the site so I could gather more things to further prove my point, but due to situations and videos coming out, I have decided to talk about it now. When the cousin art comes out, I might make a part 2. If this comes out sounding off or unprepared, you know why.
Tracing and Frankensteining:
Frankenstein tracing is the act of cutting up one or multiple pieces of someone else's art or poses and putting them together to make something new, its still considered tracing someone else's art and is still wrong to do. Here are examples of Frankenstein tracing I made as an example from my own art:
Example Part 1
Example Part 2
This is how people can easily get away with tracing, and a form of tracing I feel that is not spoken enough about, and that is just as bad as line for line tracing, and is one of the main reasons that Dev ignored or refused to admit is a thing that happens when I went to talk to him about it, and is why a form of proof he sent, I put aside due to the facts above:
Mulberry and her Tracing other artists and copy pasting things for her art:
This is here so I can prove that she actually does this/has had a history of doing this.
She's traced and used the work of the old artist Kjech and used and traced parts from his art to make a lot of her "official" yandere sim art that's on the character website:
Mulberry Kjech Frankentrace 1
Mulberry Kjech Frankentrace 2
Mulberry Kiwifarms Frankentrace proof
Mulberry Copy/Pasting Frankentrace
This is here to prove that she actually does the things I'm accusing her of, and is one of the main reasons I want to debunk from Kgon's video on this situation saying that the art has to be chopped up in pieces to prove tracing, its because that's what it is and how it works, the art being cut up and put different just enough to say "Oh its not traced" (Its what skilled tracers like Mulberry do, and is their defense from accusations like this.)
All artists of any kind know that when they create something, for themselves or someone else, a part of them is in that artwork, and you can tell and see that it's
your artwork.
I brought this up because the artwork I did for YandereDev of Ayano's cousin in the Medibang Contest video, I put part of myself in there. When I saw the silhouette of the cousin art Mulberry made, there was that innate feeling that I knew it was my work and I knew something was wrong with it, it felt like my art but it wasn't.
Cousin
I'll talk more about all of that later.
My conversation with YandereDev:
I feel like these are important facts to add before I talk about the fallout I had with dear old Devpai. I've been a fan of Yandere Simulator since I was a child, I idolized this man for so long and finally working for him felt like a dream come true, even after some of the drama came out about him, I gave him the benefit of the doubt, "Ohh its been years he's changed" (Spoiler he hasn't and you will see such.) I wouldn't have ever dreamt of getting mad or having a fight with this man, I don't like to get into arguments or conflicts in general. But seeing how he handled my concerns as a person and volunteer. Yeah. It didn't feel nice.
Now the conversation I am going to post about me confronting YandereDev about the issue, its not pretty. I didn't even bring it up to start an argument, only bring up a concern, and it devolved from there. We both got upset and the situation boiled out of control in quite the ugly manner. This conversation could have been handed better on my part but since he voiced his concerns elsewhere to what the problem was, its hard to keep calm and not devolve into upset yelling, so I apologize if I do not make sense in a lot of what I was saying.
Note: He has never EVER paid me for ANY of the work I've done for him so him saying that "the client who paid for the illustration" doesn't work. It was volunteer work not a commission.
I was more than willing to accept payment and put the issue aside for the most part but that didn't happen. I was upset at this point and said things like "pay me for all my things you can keep them and trace them and edit them all you want" thing, which could have been handled better. Here is me also calling him out on his wording of "paying" me when I haven't seen a single cent for any of my work.
We love a gaslighting king, telling me what I can and can't get upset over, especially with what I found out happened later.
I'm getting more upset, and I'm bringing up a point and (honestly an issue) YandereDev does with his volunteers. He gets multiple things of an asset he wants and targets it between two volunteers, and then takes the "better" of the two and doesn't bother to tell the other volunteer their stuff isn't going to make it. It honestly is gross, letting one person think their stuff is going to be out and they can get exposure, only for them to get slapped in the face that they're hard work was "subpar" compared to someone else. I feel bad everyday over remaking the cousin art and one upping the original artist who did it, if you see this, or you know who made the wonderful cousin art in the screenshot and below, I'm sorry. Your art is wonderful and Dev doesn't deserve your time. I sent this person's artwork to show to Dev that "remaking" a pose for an artwork doesn't mean, tracing the pose exactly. Both artworks are original in their own right while being pictures of the same thing.
Dev, offering me money to shut me up. Also Dev, saying he's not offering money to shut me up. Also the fact he said "She made it on her own, I don't see any problem with telling an artist to trace something I'm the owner of" (He never paid me. Its not his.) Plus he went straight to his go-to phrase of someone else being delusional while he's the sane one in a situation. Also there is no such thing as "recreating a reference image perfectly" especially with what I'm going to show later.
Look at how he references PrincessDie's situation, literally, what kind of high horse is he on to not see that what he does and allows his volunteers to do to other volunteers is severely harmful and to think that he's in the right in every situation. Speaking of PrincessDie, its not only art wise that tracing happens. He actively asks and allows modelers to trace her and her friend's models. Either way its not fair to the original creator of the art piece.
I was typing my response to the last message when he lost his cool and just started going off on this. Again, the gif he sent doesn't prove his point at all. He also went back to gaslighting me and telling me I'm delusional again. Especially when I found out what happened.
I feel like this is self explanatory even if it could have been handled better.
I frankensteined my own art to prove a point.
I've sent my proof for this claim above. Fresh smell of gaslighting in the morning.
The Mikasa example of Mulberry Frankensteining is from KiwiFarms. I made too many things for him I wasn't going to spend another moment talking to this man. What's funny about this is before this happened, he was praising my art and models, saying they were the best in game, then went immediately to "tell me what I need to chuck out".
Mistakes I have made with this conversation:
I made the mistake of bringing these up before it was time to tell people about it, and it got into the hands of people who don't know the full context of the situation, who henceforth misinformed a lot of people about the situation without me talking about the situation in whole. I also put this out in the air exactly after the conversation happened, I was greatly upset at the time, and went off on rants with it without giving it time to properly form in my head. I also found out more information about what happened, but that happened
after I posted all of these. So I wasn't really able to clear up some things that I have already said, that got reported on.
So what happened? Did Mulberry trace my cousin art?
I don't have the full answer so I can't claim for certain but judging by what I'll be showing next and what I showed earlier about her and kjech, I very much think so. Like I said before, I was waiting for the artwork to come out officially so I could compare and contrast what was made before making this big post. I only had a silhouette of the cousin to work with. I will make a continuation to this after that has been revealed and I have been able to make my own deductions.
The claims I did have at the time were mainly the boots:
Shoe Trace Silhouette
What did I find out after?
What I found out later, that really just makes the situation worse for me, is this:
YandereDev asked me to make this artwork for the Medibang Contest Video. You can see the video, which is time stamped here:
Medibang Video
Something that happened before the video was put up, was the fact Dev asked me for my sketch and line layers and final piece for the cousin so he could put a time-lapse like sequence in the video. I thought nothing of it at the time but I realized this was where the problem proved more points than none.
Trusting someone with your process sketches unwatermarked when making art is scary, at least for me it is. Severely so. Because there's always the chance someone is going to steal it and that's what happened here. Yandere Dev asked for my sketches, which he didn't pay me for so it isn't technically his, and he gave them to Mulberry who decided to steal the sketch and trace it instead of just "referencing" it like he said she did, and my proof is here.
YandereDev asking me for the sketches and line art.
My Base Sketch
Comparing my finished to the official silhouette you can see some differences, that is because of the process of changing the shape and details as you go on with an art piece. Look at this.
The silhouette on top of my sketch
and when you Frankenstein the sketch just a little bit to make it just difference enough.
:') ouch.
When the official drawing comes out, I will make a continuation to this to see if the line art matches up with my finished drawing but I feel like this is enough to show what happened in full. I love Yandere Simulator and I want nothing but the best for it but I will not tolerate me, my art, or my time being treated this way, and you shouldn't either.