1. I do agree to an extent about how it's become a stale meme, though nobody can deny the fact that their direct connection to the company does create a lot of mistrust amongst the community. Very few people sit in such a privileged position, and the fact that he's had the ability to remonitize many channels that asked for help over Twitter goes to show that the guy holds a lot of power. Although we don't have any definitive proof of him using said power for malicious purposes, the fact that he's become very insecure and nontransparent (such as how he continued to claim that he never looked up nor heard of Gokanaru's video, and that it was some intern who searched for it once) only breeds more of that aforementioned mistrust people have.
2. There's a massive difference between the "drama" he started way back when vs the current behavior he engages in. The pranksters you mentioned for example: Much of the criticism Ethan levied against those guys was justified, and for the most part, consisted of poking fun of their shoddy videos and production quality. The responses the pranksters put out also never helped their case, with a guy like Chris(?) from PrankInvasion wanting to fight Ethan irl. Easy to write that guy off as being incredibly insecure and possibly crazy. Flash-forward to the last several months, and you now have the complete opposite with the drama between Ethan and James Charles. Sure, Ethan had the right to call the guy out, though for whatever reason, he was compelled to then dress up like James in an attempt to "steal James's identity" and proceeded to post pics of his own ass on social media. And then to also film some more videos in this ridiculous getup with Trisha.
The argument isn't that Ethan has only recently been starting drama, but rather, he's been doing an incredibly shit job of handling it appropriately. Which leads me into my next point:
3. As much as I dislike Keem and especially the Hamburgalur himself, some of the criticisms that Ethan sprinkled into his videos were incredibly disingenuous and shitty. Like how he claimed that Jeremy was shitting on young black children for mourning Chadwick Boseman, or how Keemstar had played some kind of incredibly negative role in Etika's suicide. And like with James, as much as Ethan was justified to make a response to Muta's video, the amount of smugness and insecurity scattered throughout was beyond obscene.
To put it simply, Ethan has become a far less likable person to the point of becoming incredibly petty, and even a bit vindictive.
4. This one I agree with and have previously argued against being true. If anything, it's also become a stale meme.
5. If some people want to believe that he got Leafy banned, well that's on them. Leafy made his own bed regardless of Ethan's existence. The bigger issue, I'd argue, is how he clearly tried to justify the reasoning for Leafy getting banned, while also trying to deny that he actually wanted that. Which once again plays back into that 3rd point I made about him being unlikeable and vindictive.
6. That point's already (kind of) been addressed. From what I remember, Felix came onto a stream months back to talk with Ethan about this criticism made in Gokanaru's video. I doubt anyone here fully knows what their current friendship/relationship is like these days, though at least in the public eye, the two have definitely been interacting far less and less. It could be due that one incident taking place, or it could more likely just be the two going their own separate ways. Regardless, I think the bigger gripe is how the dude's become far less relatable and genuine around other creators, as he instead chooses to surround himself with professional sycophants.
I think most people here, myself included, can care less about them using the podcast to pay the bills. What's a lot more worthy of ridicule, however, is how the podcast has become increasingly vapid and abysmal in terms of quality, which is a shame coming from two people who clearly had a passion for their videos.