Feedback Edgelord rating?

[ToroidalBoat]

I think this covers edgy stuff already:

 

[shilly_mays]

Coldsteel is obviously the superior choice.

Spoiler

 

[RichardMongler]

Doubling that, Islamic Content applies to this as well.

Islamic Content is kind of a joke rating seeing that it's applied so liberally to even otherwise informative posts, so I think neutralizing it should be in order.

I wouldn't mind "Edgy" being a rating with a bleeding razor blade as the symbol. "Dumb" doesn't do edgeposting justice as you can articulate a logically consistent point and still be edgy. On the other hand, I can foresee this potential rating being widely abused.

 

[Apteryx Owenii]

Dumb, autistic, and a-log generally apply well to edgy shit depending on its flavor.

I'm still perturbed we don't have "off-topic" anymore. That was one of the more useful ones to see under a post because it meant the whole sperging could be ignored.

 

[KingQueen]

I responded to another thread with a similar suggestion, I didn't realize there was this thread. I should learn to scroll.

I agree with the Edgy rating, except I think it should also include regular temporary bans as your score increases. For every 10 ratings, perhaps, you get a week ban.

I disagree that autism or a-log are synonymous with edge.

 

[Pepito The Cat]

For every 10 ratings, perhaps, you get a week ban.

That sounds an awful lot like a public stoning. Only admins and mods must enforce bans.