The DC Animated Movie Universe and the Tomorrowverse have been mixed bags for me.
The DCAMU, I think, has by far the best DC look in animation. There’s a reason Phil Bourassa’s style became the standard. But they really started off on the wrong foot by basically adapting the New 52 before quietly backtracking on a lot of it. They introduced an arrogant jock Superman, only to silently retcon him back into the classic boy scout version later on.
There was still a lot to like, and there are honorable exceptions like Constantine, but most of the time it felt like you were getting weaker versions of previous adaptations rather than something that truly stood on its own.
Some people wrongfully assume Young Justice is set in this universe, and honestly, if it had been, it probably would have rivaled the DCAU. But it wasn’t.
Their Teen Titans never escaped the shadow of the 2006 series, they had one of the worst versions of Shazam, an out-of-character Hal Jordan, etc. I’d even argue Batman carried most of this universe, since most of its strongest moments revolved around him or his supporting characters. Including that flash time travel movie.
Killing all their heroes in a single movie was certainly a choice, but for me it mostly highlighted how little attachment I had to these versions of the characters. Beyond the prettier animation, for a whole universe, really I really only miss a handful.
With the Tomorrowverse, I appreciate that they mostly tried to stay closer to the classic heroes. But aside from a few exceptions, I couldn’t shake the feeling that most of the characters felt bland. They were fine, but very little truly stood out.
And I’ll address the elephant in the room: the art style was a massive downgrade. It’s clean, but also very flat and lifeless, almost like Flash animation. I do give them credit for avoiding constant rehashes and trying new ideas, like the alternate-universe World War II setting with Flash.
Still, they somehow managed to make Crisis on Infinite Earths — THE comic event — feel mid at best. The fact that most people only cared about the classic cameos, like Kevin Conroy’s Batman, while barely anyone cared about losing the Tomorrowverse characters as the universe rebooted yet again, says everything about how forgettable the whole thing ended up being.