Creepy Unsolved Mysteries - From unsolved murders to unidentified people to unexplained supernatural events, what are some of the creepiest unsolved mysteries you've ever heard of?

More like he fell or jumped in the river.
I didn't even know the river was so close or on his way home or whatever! Those hysterical true crime ladies need to learn to draw better maps.
Something I've been listening to a lot is creepy stories from military personnel, guys that were in Iraq, Afghanistan, and other places. Be interesting to hear some of those type of stories here.
They're probably the same as creepy stories from the Appalachians or Khyber pass. Moonshine + toothless yokels buttfucking behind shitty scrub bushes at 2AM. And whatever the region's version of "tiny malnourished wild dog" is.
 
Última edición:
I can't even remember if Tara Calico was solved. They never figured out the other kid in the picture did they.
Talk about mystic stuff - just yesterday I was reminded about that case again! From what I can tell, the sheriff department of that county claimed that there was a breakthrough and the case is basically solved, but the details weren't presented yet. Yes, the most prevalent explanation is hit and run plus coverup. However, what about that picture? We know for sure that the kid wasn't the one they originally thought, since his remains had been found later near the campsite where he disappeared. And the girl might not be Tara as well, so yeah, what the fuck was that picture then? Was it just a cruel prank to get people lose their shit? Ok, but then someone should come out and say "ha-ha, got you", yet no one did. Was it just a prop from some no budget movie? Was it just a hoax by the person who found it to get all those interviews? Then why the people from that pic didn't come out to tell that this is not fun and only makes things worse for everyone? So many questions.
 
Was it just a cruel prank to get people lose their shit? Ok, but then someone should come out and say "ha-ha, got you", yet no one did.

If it was a hoax or a gag, it was almost certainly not intended as one on Tara Calico specifically, and the people who made it might be completely unaware of her. Not everyone obsessively follows decades-old missing persons cases.
 
Something I've been listening to a lot is creepy stories from military personnel, guys that were in Iraq, Afghanistan, and other places. Be interesting to hear some of those type of stories here.
There is a military channel (I think he got banned) on youtube - old GenX ex-Green Beret.
He had some TERRIFYING ghost stories from some of the WORST human rights loci in the middle east.

He had to sleep in Bagram Air Base - where thousands of people were executed under the previous regime.

Imagine sleeping in the same area where being given a rope was a special gift from the guards, allowing you to self delete without enduring another day of torture.
 
If it was a hoax or a gag, it was almost certainly not intended as one on Tara Calico specifically, and the people who made it might be completely unaware of her. Not everyone obsessively follows decades-old missing persons cases.
Yes, but this doesn't make much sense. Let's say you want to prank someone, like you drop a fat wallet, but it is covered with shit inside. You won't just drop it and go away thinking "ooooh, someone's gonna be mad", no, you will hide somewhere in the distance to watch the result. So if it was indeed a prank, then there is no way people who did it weren't following it in some way, like through the news or people talking. If it was indeed a prank, the reason why no one came forward could be "fuck it, it's gone too far, I don't wanna go into jail over some unrelated girl disappearance".
 
Yes, but this doesn't make much sense. Let's say you want to prank someone, like you drop a fat wallet, but it is covered with shit inside. You won't just drop it and go away thinking "ooooh, someone's gonna be mad", no, you will hide somewhere in the distance to watch the result. So if it was indeed a prank, then there is no way people who did it weren't following it in some way, like through the news or people talking. If it was indeed a prank, the reason why no one came forward could be "fuck it, it's gone too far, I don't wanna go into jail over some unrelated girl disappearance".

There are all kinds of senses of humor out there, and it's not at all unbelievable that someone might drop a picture like that just to get off on the idea of who might have found it. Further, who says it has to be a hoax meant for public consumption? Some kids might have staged the photo to freak out their parents, and dropped one of a dozen or so Polaroids by accident. Or, in the extreme, it might be from an unrelated kidnapping. There are dozens of scenarios where the creator of this image might not have the faintest idea of who Tara Calico was.
 
I
I once took an ambien during a hurricane and apparently went downstairs in the night, opened a can of soup, dumped it in a bowl, and carefully placed the bowl in the pantry before going back up to bed. Zero memory about any of these events. Ambien's some evil shit, man.
I was prescribed it once and kept having to call a friend to make sure I was actually home. I was convinced my bedroom was a ship and I was lost at sea.
 
I got curious about the theory of Tara Calico getting hit by a car and looked up the thread where it was discussed.

Here it is.

I wanted to make a write-up on this case so I can have something to link to every time someone mentions The Polaroid.

Tara Calico is known by most people as a possible match for a tied-up girl in a Polaroid left in a parking lot in the 80s. She went missing on Sept 20, 1988, last seen taking a bike ride along a state road. Pieces of her Walkman and a cassette tape were found on her usual route. /u/kittykatinthehat made a case write-up here.

What most people overlook are the case docs in the public record. I'm attempting to summarize them here and separate the wheat from the chaff since it's a lot of content and 'this person said this thing in an interview'.

Dying man Henry Brown requested an interview with Deputy Frank Methola that is detailed in the case docs (date not included, but I assume it had been many years after her disappearance). Brown stated that he hung out with some troublemaking teens, one of them Lawrence Romero Jr., son of the Sheriff Lawrence Romero Sr. LR Jr. dealt drugs and was also interested in Tara but she was dating another guy, Jeff Abeyta, who also happened to sell drugs.

Brown was partying with LR Jr. and his buddies at LR Jr.'s trailer, specifically the makeshift basement under it. Part of the party talk included LR Jr. and friends talking about how they hit Tara with their truck, then raped and killed her. They hid her body in bushes, and when the search intensified, moved her under a tarp in the makeshift basement and then later to a pond. A man named Donald Dutcher also came forward in late 2013 to say one of the suspects confessed to him.

The problem with the investigation? Well, first off, one of the prime suspects was the son of the Sheriff. Second of all, speculation that Deputy Sheriff (later Sheriff) Rene Rivera was a dirty cop who had their backs. Thirdly? All of the suspects are now deceased. LR Jr. either committed suicide or played a game of Russian Roulette (depending on who you ask) in 1991 and supposedly left a note confessing, which was not entered into evidence by Deputy Rivera. The docs are vague on who the other suspects are so I'm not going to name names (although there are plenty!).

tl;dr Most likely scenario: Tara was deliberately run over by some druggies, one of whom was the Sheriff's son, and all the suspects are deceased so no confessions will be forthcoming, although there is a rumoured suicide note that was covered up by the Deputy Sheriff.

I have to admit. It's the most plausible one I've seen out of that entire mystery.

The photo is being discussed, I see. Tbh, after reading this, I don't believe that photo is Tara.


Talk about mystic stuff - just yesterday I was reminded about that case again! From what I can tell, the sheriff department of that county claimed that there was a breakthrough and the case is basically solved, but the details weren't presented yet. Yes, the most prevalent explanation is hit and run plus coverup. However, what about that picture? We know for sure that the kid wasn't the one they originally thought, since his remains had been found later near the campsite where he disappeared. And the girl might not be Tara as well, so yeah, what the fuck was that picture then? Was it just a cruel prank to get people lose their shit? Ok, but then someone should come out and say "ha-ha, got you", yet no one did. Was it just a prop from some no budget movie? Was it just a hoax by the person who found it to get all those interviews? Then why the people from that pic didn't come out to tell that this is not fun and only makes things worse for everyone? So many questions.

The same sheriff who has the son mentioned in the claim I posted here? If so, it doesn't sound like he's trustworthy, lol.
 
Última edición:
There was a comment about the sheriff (Rene Rivera) about how he mentioned that he wanted to write a book about the whole Tara Calico disappearance, About how he would have "solved" it, but the book was never written. It sounds like some OJ Simpsons "If I Did It" shit.

I found this post, but the link that was posted along with it doesn't work anymore.

Screenshot at 2025-10-08 00-40-48.png

I found this as well:

I posted this in another thread regarding Tara:

This case https://www.identifyus.org/en/cases/8364 mentions an old truck (Older model, Ford F-15).

This report https://www.scribd.com/doc/270970248/New-Mexico-State-Police-Tara-Calico tells us that the kids used an old truck from one of them to hit Tara while she was on her bike.

I found this case here: https://www.identifyus.org/en/cases/13719 Unidentified skeleton found in a shallow grave (about 1 foot) along side of Rio Puerco river. No obvious filings or indicators of modern origin. Possible trauma on skull. Renants of possible "carpet" (fibers) found with remains and a piece of ceramic (?? pottery) | Location: Mesa west of Belen, NM

I made a map with all three cases & Tara's story: https://goo.gl/4OSqL7

Pretty strange that 2 bodies were found very near to each other. The other body was found near Belen (high school) which is not far away from where Lawrence Romero Jr. lived. In my opinion, Mr. Brown, the teacher who came years after and reported everything to the police knew he will die soon. He was scared and full of fear years before, when the kids told him the truth about what they did to Tara. Btw. Mr. Brown died few months after his report.

The report states: Romero said, after they hit her with a truck and then put her in a back of the truck where they sodomized and raped her: "she got ballsy, stood up and said she was going to make sure we were all going to jail." Romero went and got a knife from the truck and David, Leroy and the tall red haired guy held her down while Romero stabbed and killed her. He said they drug her body and put her in a bush nearby until they got nervous when the search started for her. He said they kept her "near-by", but later he joked about that. **One body was found near the trailer where Romero was living (see map).

Mr. Brown (teacher) said this whole thing had to with drugs. Jeff Abeyta and Lawrence Romero Jr. sold drugs and the only reason they never got caught was because his dad was the Sheriff and that he heard Romero say that his dad hired Deputy Rivera and that "Deputy Rivera had their back". He said "the sheriff there is not innocent". Mr. Brown said they took the bike to the junk yard in Belen to get rid of it.

Mr. Methola (former Sheriff's Deputy) said when he got the report he did not know who was in charge of the case so he contacted Sheriff Rivera and was told to bring his report to directly to him. Mr. Methola said he needed to tag his cassette tapes into evidence first. Later he was advised by ms. Escuqibel taht there was a record he had taken a report but there is no report or any documentation of any tapes placed into evidence.

Mr. Chavez later said he understood that Rivera had conducted the investigation surrounding the suicide of Lawrence Romero Jr. and that he understood there had been a note left behind confessing to the Tara Calico murder but the note had been taken by Rivera and not placed into evidence. It is widely believed that this note really has existed.

Here you can read more about this truly adorable Sheriff Rivera: http://www.topix.com/forum/city/valencia-nm/TB0I8JBSEHGRKNP58/p2

Some opinions about him:

"I have known Sheriff Rene Rivera for 21 years. I am also a former Deputy Sheriff with VCSO and worked side by side with Rene. I recently attempted a return to work at VCSO but Rene gave me the total run around. I am still a fully certified law enforcement officer but he will not allow me the opportunity to even return. In recent days, I have learned of Rene and his various unethical activities in recent years to include a young lady that shared a specific story into her being sexually assaulted by Sheriff Rivera. The incident occured several years ago and she has been afraid to come forward. Not good at all!!!

"I know rene rivera he was the investagator in my brothers murder case. he was given names address & phone numbers.to contact the people.to get information. do you think he did his job. he also knows the person who killed my brother and knows his mother.what do you think happend? well this person is not in jail. nor has he served any time for the murder of my brother. i wonder why?I was told the person that killed my brother was taken to rene's office and told rene he killed my brother.they told me rene told the killer there is no body therfore we cant do anything. aprox one month later his body was found.rene was given alot of information but did nothing. I reported rene to his boss. the D.A's office said Rene F---ed up the case.this person has committed other violent crimes and is not serveing any time.

"I'm surprised that no one has brought up the fact that Rene is a known pedophile. He likes girls about 12 years old, same as most of his predecessors. He comes out of Lawrence Romero's old bar in Jarales where him and LAWrence, Richard, Manuel and the entire Garley family spent all of their off hours trying to lure little girls. Hell one of the Garley's got caught with a 13 year old girl in a motel room.........WITH HIS WIFE,and him, in bed NAKED. I know for a fact that Rene raped a 13 year old girl a few years ago, but it was swept under the rug by Mike Runnels, DA. Rene was on the NM drug task force, but only for a few days, and then was canned. [...] We all know that the Valencia County Sheriff's Department is, and has been, one of the most corrupt law enforcement agencies in the country. [...]

Look at this article https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/156395665/ dealing with the suicide of Lawrence Romero Jr.:

Suzanne Fetsco of the Office of the Medical Investigator has confirmed the autopsy Concluded Romero Jr.'s death on May 19 1991 was a suicide by gunshot. Former Valencia County Sheriff Lawrence Romero Sr. on Thursday and again Friday disputed the findings about his son's death. "I look forward to his amendment because it will be amended," Romero Sr. said in a telephone interview. "There is compelling new evidence that will show that he has to make an amendment." Romero Sr. has maintained that his son's death was a homicide. The Valencia County Sheriffs Office has said they believe Romero Jr. accidentally shot himself. A man who was with Romero Jr. when he died told police he was in another room of Romero Jr.s mobile home west of Belen when he heard a gunshot and emerged to find Romero Jr. shot on a kitchen floor. In the interview on Friday, Zumwalt said he determined the cause of death was a gunshot to the head. He said he also determined the manner of death. "The manner of death was determined to be suicide and that determination was based on autopsy findings, the investigative reports of the circumstances, the conversations with the Valencia County Sheriffs Office, and with the father of the deceased," Zumwalt said. He added the death certificate was issued June 28. Zumwalt said he based his findings on "reasonable medical certainty, although not absolute certainty." Asked to define reasonable medical certanty, Zumwalt responded, "In my opinion, it's much higher than just plain probability, much higher than 50 percent, but not absolute, not 100 percent ... I'm not sure what percentage I would put on it, but I think it's much more likely that the wound was self-inflicted."

And this article https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/158906097 says: Romero Jr. was found shot dead in his mother's mobile home west of Belen. He has not been charged in connection with the death. Chavez has told the Journal he didn't kill Romero Jr., whom he described as his friend. He said Romero Jr. liked to play with guns and accidentally shot himself, apparently while playing Russian roulette.

The interview with Donald Dutcher

In 2013 was an interview with Donald Dutcher, who stated he lived in New Mexco for all his life and was familiar with two boys involved in this "accident" and that he knew Tara Calico. One of the last gentleman involved that has passed away spoke to him, he was a known drug user and he spoke to him right before he died. He said "Tara Calico talks to me at night, she asks why we did it? She asks why buried out there?" He said the guy was freaking out because of that and that they buried her out by the green lagoons by the rock quarry out on top of the west mesa. He mentions pond of water, green lagoon and the street "Camino Del Llano" and when you go all up that street on top of the west mesa you would find her. He said Romero was one of the ones nvolved and Charles Houghton was the other one involved and he didnt know the names of the other two gentlemen involved but all four of them are dead now. The guy who talked with Dutcher was Charlie Houghton, who died in 2000, he believed. He said Charlie was hyped up on heroin all the day and he later died cause of an overdose.

What do you need more? They took drugs, they somodized, raped and killed her. They threatened the teacher, Mr. Brown, to not talk to anyone or they would come after him. They got covered up by the Sheriff Rivera who destroyed all evidence after one of the killers (Romero) committed (or got killed) suicide. Mr. Brown reported everything they told him because he knew he would die soon and his time has come, so they could not do anything against him. He died 2 months later. Than the interview with Donald Dutcher which mentioned Romero too and other suspects. In my opinion, this case is very clear if you take everything into account and count 1+1 together. Of course it will be hard to charge anyone today, but maybe one of the bodies in the map is Tara - one is very near to the description of the road and near Romero's old home.


Make of this what you will and whether or not this can be true. But the more I search on this, the more it seems like the whole hitting and killing Tara deal might have some kind of truth to it.
 
So a whole separate sheriff. At this point I find it hard to believe it'll ever get out.

But then there were claims that that previous sheriff had talked about writing a book about the Tara case, so what's up with that?
 
Here's a few I did research on for something.

Connie Smith - Connie was a 10-year old girl who disappeared from her camp in Sundance, Connecticut. She was the granddaughter of former Wyoming governor Nels Smith who served from 1939 to 1943. She and her family lived on a rance in Wyoming. During the summer of 1952 she and her mom visited her moms parents in Connecticut. Her mom thought she might get board with no friends to play with so she signed her up for camp at Camp Sloane. She seemed to have a good time there getting along with most kids and adults. On July 11 her mom and grandma visited her for her 10th birthday. It would be the last time they would see her. On the 16th Connie broke her glasses, hurt her hip, and got in a fight with another girl. The glasses might have broken from the fight. Later that day she told her friends she was going to the dispensary to return an ice pack she used for her hip. But she left the ice and never went to the building. She actually left camp and hitchhiked, Multiple people claimed to see her and talked to her saying she was asking for directions to Lakeville. Despite a big search she was never found. It was said she was last seen by some gypsies but when police sent to the site they were at they were gone. Her father believed she was homesick which is why she left. In 1958 the remains of a young girl were found in Arizona called Little Miss X. Some believed it might have been her due to the age of the remains. Her brother also thought the dental records were similar. But her dentist could not find a match. The remains were buried in a graveyard. Decades later some remains were looked at but did not match. However, they may not have been Little Miss X. No one is sure where at the cemetery they are at. Her brother died in 2023 in a car accident still hoping for answers.

Jim Gray - Gray was a brilliant man who changed the world of database. Without him we might not have some of the stuff we have today. He worked for Microsoft and won many awards. On January 28, 2007 he got on his yacht and sailed into the San Francisco Bay to go to the Farallon Islands to spread his mothers ashes. He never came back. He had a high-tech distress signal on his boat that would send out a signal if it sank. No signal was ever sent. The seas were calm that day with no storms. He and his ship were never found. In 2012 he was officially declared dead. Some think he might have turned off the signal and sank the boat on purpose due to depression from losing his mom. Some think he might have started a new life. Though family said he wanted to do more in his career. His fate remains unknown.

Susan Walsh - A freelance journalist who disappeared in 1996. Susan had dreams of being a writer since she was a child. In college she had to strip to make money for classes and also got into drugs. She met a man named Mark and they had a son named David together but they later divorced. She gave up drugs during this time. She eventually got a job at the Village voice where she wrote stories on the sex industry. She wrote an article on Russian mobs kidnapping women for sex. It got praise but also threats. She also wrote an unpublished article on the vampire community. She became interested in their culture but the paper wasn't interested and she had to strip for extra money. On July 16 she left David at Marks apartment to make a phonecall. She never came back. Theories range from getting back into drugs, to starting a new life, to being murdered by the mob or vampire club. No one knows though. In 2006 Mark was questioned but it looks like it went nowhere.
 
Última edición:
Funny that you mentioned her. I read about Connie Smith a while back. Old cases are interesting and should be discussed more. Sadly they disappear through time unless they were really famous.
 
Su Taraskiewicz - A pretty 27 year old airline employee. Sue worked as a baggage lady at Logan Airport in Massachusetts. She was the one who helped load and unload belongings. She also de-iced planes. Eventually she became a ramp supervisor. In 1992 she began getting sexually harassed at work by male employees. She recorded a lot of it in her diary. She didn't show up on time one day and her car was found in front of a tire service building. Her body was in the trunk of the car. She had been stabbed repeatedly and bludgeoned. One entry in the diary describes conflicts with a Bobby. She had frequently clashed with him and one incident occurred when Bobby stormed into the break room one day and dropped her radio on the table. When asked why he was in a fowl mood he said "because the Bruins lost" after which he then picked the radio up and threw it at the wall. Su's mother had gotten her that radio so obviously she took it personally (anyone would unless you're a filthy hippie). He threatened first her boyfriend then alluded to her. She filed multiple complaints but they were all ignored, presumably because late 1980s into early 1990s woman = no bueno to big corporations.

Her mom thinks there was a hit put out on her daughter.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo