Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

[God of Nothing]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

2
at the very least, you have some sort of closure with 1 no matter how bad it can get

 

[ZMOT]

2
at the very least, you have some sort of closure with 1 no matter how bad it can get

unless it gets so bad it retroactively runs the whole thing where you can't even enjoy "the good parts" anymore.

 

[God of Nothing]

unless it gets so bad it retroactively runs the whole thing where you can't even enjoy "the good parts" anymore.

you have to get pretty fucking bad for that to happen

 

[ZMOT]

you have to get pretty fucking bad for that to happen

just look at all the normalfag IPs like lost, GoT or walking dead.
depends how deep your into it, which I'd say is much worse when it comes to animu and mango. like did AoT ever recover (granted it was a slow decline anywas, not a hard crash, you could estimate where it goes), or oshi no ko for a more recent example - although the people in the know wouldn't trust the author after the whole kaguya stuff, so it was mostly a trap for newfags and secondaries.

save for Demon Slayer but that is the exception that proves the rule

wasn't there already some drama about certain arcs?

 

[ringtones]

Definitely 1 for me. My Hero Academia shitting its brains out is why I will never trust a big shonen series to conclude satisfyingly again (save for Demon Slayer but that is the exception that proves the rule).

that's not really fair. The author was a relatively new mangaka, he only had two minor series under his belt. One had two volumes, the other had 5. MHA exploded in popularity and he kept it good for 40 volumes, which was probably some 35 books longer than it was supposed to be. You can see that MHA:Vigilantes is much shorter and the primary author is someone completely different. They probably had the entire storyboard done before they started drawing the first chapter.

I'm pretty sure the entire last battle in MHA was ghost written. Everything from when All Might showed up in a robot suit for sure, but probably a little before then too.

 

[Oddjob OTP]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

Two for sure, a part of my dark soul still felt hope that Netflix adapting Bastard!! would get the author to return home from getting smokes

 

[ringtones]

Two for sure, a part of my dark soul still felt hope that Netflix adapting Bastard!! would get the author to return home from getting smokes

you think that's bad you should see what happened to Act-Age

 

[Red Dragon]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

1 for sure. MHA is a prime example of how stretching too much turns things braindead. Option 2 at leats gives you hope.

You forgot option 3: sudden cancelation. They done dirt on my Gundam X.

 

[Newcomer 42]

2. The trick is that both aren't mutually exclusive. See Berserk.

 

[HexFag]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

1 absolutely. At least with 2 it's still a good show/manga at the end of the day. You can't recover from a 1, but you can absolutely wait long enough for a 2.

 

[Ensok]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

2. You at least have fanfiction no matter what, but at least with 1 you have genuine closure.

Houseki no Kuni, xxxholic, are good examples of 1 for me, so much that I regret reading them, but I'm glad they at least ended unlike some shit out there. Like Twelve Kingdoms. I guess this is the One Piece or HxH question? Samurai Jack is a good western example of why 2 is worse, 13 years of not knowing if Jack made it back to the past, even if you didn't like some of the shit season 5 did you can't tell me that's worse.

 

[God of Nothing]

2. You at least have fanfiction no matter what, but at least with 1 you have genuine closure.

Houseki no Kuni, xxxholic, are good examples of 1 for me, so much that I regret reading them, but I'm glad they at least ended unlike some shit out there. Like Twelve Kingdoms. I guess this is the One Piece or HxH question? Samurai Jack is a good western example of why 2 is worse, 13 years of not knowing if Jack made it back to the past, even if you didn't like some of the shit season 5 did you can't tell me that's worse.

Finding good fanfiction is really hard though. You're lucky if the author even finishes their rewrite or what if.

 

[Evil Peter Griffin]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

Both can be applied to Berserk and Hunter X Hunter.

 

[wtfNeedSignUp]

What's worse:
1. a series going on for so long it turns to shit and you lose all interest?
2. a series put on hiatus for so long you lose all hope of ever seeing a proper conclusion?

I'd go with 2. People will speak about Berserk and HxH for years to come.

 

[Honka Honka Burning Love]

MHA's Length wasn't the problem, if anything I would say it is a little too short...because Deku goes from "Oh shit One for All is manifesting the quirks it absorbed along the way" to "I HAVE ALL 7 QUARKS AND MASTERED THEM" in like a single arc.

MHA's Problem was turning Shigiraki and All For One into Gods who couldn't be reasonably defeated.

 

[Red Dragon]

MHA's Problem was turning Shigiraki and All For One into Gods who couldn't be reasonably defeated.

You do have a point about being too short for the powercreep that happens in the series, but a shorter series may had warded off said powercreep by using the limited time to develop the story better.

There's also the fact that Shigaraki was a lame villain, stuck in a teenager "destroy everything" phase. His underlings were way more interesting than him and had more believable motives.

 

[Honka Honka Burning Love]

You do have a point about being too short for the powercreep that happens in the series, but a shorter series may had warded off said powercreep by using the limited time to develop the story better.

I am not even sure I would call it power creep.

It's just that "Enemy that can one shot the hero with a single touch" and "Enemy with Regeneration" being the same people makes the fight super lame, you can't wear them down cause they have regeneration.

 

[Lone MacReady II]

2. The trick is that both aren't mutually exclusive. See Berserk.

Berserk ended when Miura died.

a part of my dark soul still felt hope that Netflix adapting Bastard!!

Why would you ever think anything good would come from Netfux? How many asian characters do you want nigger'd this time?

 

[Oddjob OTP]

Why would you ever think anything good would come from Netfux? How many asian characters do you want nigger'd this time?

I wasn't hoping for anything from Netflix (and it was animated and a Japanese production for Japanese tastes even if it wasn't good) I was hoping the mangaka would finish his story, which, if memory serves, left Dark Schneider recently deceased and sent to hell.

 

[Red Dragon]

"Enemy with Regeneration"

Lamest super power ever, right beside superspeed. Only plot armor can defeat those.

This reminds me of Dragon Ball. If you think about it, Kuririn is the strongest character of the entire series: his energy-discs that can cut anything forced the author to make every single enemie afterwards have regeneration. The guy was so powerful the author had to make plot armor for the bad guys!