- Registrado
- 12 de Jul, 2015
Does anyone else think this is a super common response to the Farms, where they completely miss the point? Yeah, some people here just wanna be mean bigoted ignorant trolls, sure. But the majority of us are completely aware that real autistic people fit your description, and lots of our members are autistic or have autistic family members. Nobody is saying those things are untrue (except maybe a few posts from dumb people). What we're looking at here are the inconsistencies and the exhibitionism. We're not interested in "normal" people here, including "normal" autistics.Have any of you actually read her blog?
I've read a lot of it. She does not deny or try to hide that she was once considered gifted and spoke fluently. She talks a lot about her childhood and adolescence, about how she used to speak, about how she used to have a gifted-level IQ and attended gifted programming and an elite college at age 14.
I don't know if she's autistic or not. But she certainly seems to genuinely think that she is, and always has been, even when she spoke and was labeled as gifted. I don't think she's trying to trick anyone. If she was, she wouldn't be posting about her history as a gifted, fluently speaking child on the internet.
I'm autistic. I have an official diagnosis from neuropsych testing and everything. Autistic people can be gifted. Many are. Autistic people can speak. Many do. Even non-speaking autistic people can write well. Many non-speaking autistic people communicate entirely through writing, and are some of the best writers I know. And it is not at all uncommon for autistic people's abilities to vary, sometimes drastically, over the course of their lives. There are many reasons this can happen. Some people regress after going through trauma or more change than they can handle. Some regress when they are stressed. I speak, I am generally very articulate and extroverted, but I sometimes go nonverbal when I'm stressed and need to use AAC similar to what Amanda now uses all the time.
We know that Amanda went through trauma when she was institutionalized for two years as a teenager following her breakdown at Simon's Rock. She claims to have been abused at that facility. That can certainly cause regression (and even if she *wasn't* autistic, anyone who has been traumatized will respond to that with behavioral changes of some kind). She also used recreational drugs at Simon's Rock, and has been prescribed various psychotropic drugs since she was a child. Heavy, long-term drug use can absolutely cause changes in behavior as well as brain damage.
I do think it's highly unusual that her IQ dropped from 140 as a child to 85 at age 22. Amanda has expressed confusion with this as well (she said she expected to get around 125). That usually doesn't happen, even to actually autistic people. The only explanation I can think of for that is the combination of drug use causing brain damage and the trauma. The IQ test is just a test. You can definitely do poor on a test, even if you're a smart person, if you're having a mental breakdown because you were recently abused/traumatized.
This combination of trauma and drug use could also be causing all the health issues (and the health issues, in turn, are probably not helping either her intelligence or her functioning).
If a person's IQ dropped to 85 due to trauma or TBI, they would not maintain the capability of writing at the level Amanda uses. For example, studies show the use of transitional expressions is correlated with IQ. This implies that she's either lying about taking the IQ, or purposely did poorly on it. (I've had an IQ test, many years ago, it is reasonably easy to fake low.)
Edit: Also, hi Amanda.
A side note to everybody-- technically it's called Factitious Disorder, not Munchausens. Malingering is when you pretend to be sick for attention but aren't sick (like many Tumblrites). With FD, you intentionally make yourself sick. They seem to be driven by some internal obsession, or validation. I'd argue this latest episode where she allowed her tube to get infected due to neglect is proof that she's willing to put her life in danger to maintain a "sick identity".