Culture Actually can’t believe this? Dance music has a gender equality problem

Dazed (Archive) - August 3, 2022
by, Serena Smith

1659552918224.png

Less than one per cent of electronic tracks played on radio were made exclusively by female and non-binary artists, according to a new report by Jaguar Foundation​


The Jaguar Foundation – founded by DJ and radio presenter Jaguar – published their Progressing Gender Representation in UK Dance Music report today.

The report investigates the “gendered representation of artists with the UK electronic music scene” and is said to be the “first of its kind”.

The findings paint a damning picture of the state of gender inequality within the UK dance music industry. In the foreword to the report, Jaguar says that she hopes the research “becomes a launchpad for much-needed change in our industry, which once began as a haven for inclusivity and diversity.”

The report found that just 5 per cent of dance songs in the charts were made exclusively by female and non-binary artists, while less than 1 per cent of dance or electronic tracks played on radio were made exclusively by female and non-binary artists.

Only 28 per cent of artists on electronic festival lineups in 2022 were female or non-binary – shrinking to 15 per cent at larger festivals. Hardly any of these female and non-binary artists were headliners.

The report also highlighted the fact that many women and non-binary people feel unsafe in clubs. “The combination of late-night travel, dark and crowded spaces, and intoxicated crowds make for a more unappealing environment for women,” Jaguar said. “There are issues with unwanted attention physically and verbally, mostly from men towards women.”

The report also included recommendations for industry leaders, including “focusing on initiatives targeted at marginalised groups”, “support grassroots organisations”, and “education and awareness of the experiences of trans and non-binary people”.

“The findings of this report are not simply a woman’s or non-binary person’s problem. This affects all of us,” Jaguar wrote in the report. “It’s often men who are in the most powerful positions to influence change. So I ask that we all join forces, and work on a solution, together.”
 
What do autistic cock coke-addled white women do with their free time? Draw shitty art on twitter? Cause it sure isn't music or sound engineering, I can tell you that
 
A weirdo knows where middle-c is, wonderful, now we have to deal with this in some other field of interest.

The flow of this seems to go:
  1. Someone does 'research' that shows X group of people don't do Y activity
  2. 'Researcher' or organization goes around promoting the need to have more X group
  3. Groups that want to be nice or whatever make special accommodations for X group
  4. X group and 'researcher' determine that more X are needed
  5. There aren't much of X because X doing Y just isn't a thing
  6. Promote lack of X in Y do to threat of toxicity or violence or something
  7. Y is ruined
 
Look, us weirdos who listen to electronica get shit on by everyone. Keep this shit out of my music. If you want representation then learn some musical theory and understand what sounds good (hint: it's not a mush-mouth jogger ramblin' about how gangsta they are or how hot dey pussy is).
 
The only actual artist that I can think of that would satisfy this writer's complaint would be Sewerslvt who is a mtf aussie tranny groomer and doesn't make music anymore. he made some good breakbeat and prog DnB stuff though.
 
They could start their own super special gender radio instead of an useless blablabla foundation.
 
I have a hard time believing the female Venetian Snares or Lustmord exist, and that's ok.
 
Is the author of this article absolutely retarded? Have they ever been a part of the UK or even global dance scene? Is their view of what defines a ‘woman produced track’ so fucking narrow it excludes the majority of house divas from the classic era? Literally half of the tracks produced these days have a female vocal, vocalists who tour and have huge fan bases at that (Kelly Llorenna anyone?). Dance music is incredibly inclusive, you have huge artists that are black (Carl Cox), female (Nervo), gay (Frankie Knuckles), etc. plus clubs are usually filled with young women, it’s a pretty normal coming of age activity in the UK.

This person knows shit about the genre and has never been in a club/rave in their life. Manufacturing outrage over absolutely nothing.
 
I love how Jaguar says she hopes her report "becomes a launchpad for much-needed change in our industry, which once began as a haven for inclusivity and diversity” - when the whole conceit of her report is that not enough tracks are being made exclusively by one type of person; ie. the "problem" she's identifying and fighting against IS the inclusivity and diversity of dance music. I think a lot of readers are missing that, which is understandably, given how stupid Jaguar's take is. But read the article carefully: she's not saying that women aren't present in dance music. She's saying that there are too many non-women mucking about, and that this diversity is, shockingly, making her music non-exclusive.


But the most glaring problem here is that saying "such-and-such a percent of dance music is made exclusively by one sort of person", seems to rather miss the point of dance music.

Dance music is, by its very nature, a collaborative effort. Dance music is full of samples, remixes, and remixes of remixes; any given track may have elements of music pulled from more a dozen contributors, including men, women, gays, straights, white people, black people, Asians, pedos, troons, furries, you name it. I remember one dance music album whose "contributing artists" list included a box of matchsticks falling on the floor. You don't find tracks with exclusively one kind of contributing artist, because that's how dance music works. That's what diversity means.




What I'd like to see, if it's available, is the data for tracks created 'exclusively by' men. Or exclusively by men and enbies, because why not? If you want to lump enbies in with women, might as well lump enbies in with men. Either way, if you want to play the RadFem angle here, this is the data you'd need in order to draw any sort of meaningful conclusion: you'd need to compare male-exclusive tracks to female-exclusive tracks, to see if (and to what degree) one sort of gender-exclusive track dominates the other.

I'd also like to see the data on tracks created exclusively by blacks, exclusively by Belgians, exclusively by homosexuals (likely the biggest percentage) - hell, might as well do a whole massive study on which groups have the most tracks made exclusively by them! Then start banning those people - maybe take them out back, shoot them in the head? - and replace these liquidated privileged groups with the least-represented group or groups. Because again, why not, right? Social justice.

My money's on the least represented group being Klansmen from north Texas, and I look forward to them being given DJ spots at the expense of talented, deserving, but nevertheless too-gay and thus too-overrepresented homo DJs. But we'll have to wait until the data comes out.
 
Última edición:
Oh, and in case anyone's curious, here are some of her sets:




I'll leave it to Kiwis to decide whether she's any good or whether this is just a PR stunt to save a doomed career, but I will point out that all three of these sets have diverse contributing artists behind them; none are exclusively female or enbie, leading one to wonder whether Jaguar is really part of the solution, or just another part of the problem?

(should note, however, that the Pride 2020 set is exclusively LGBT, per orders of Pride 2020. "Called it"...)
 
I'll leave it to Kiwis to decide whether she's any good or whether this is just a PR stunt to save a doomed career, but I will point out that all three of these sets have diverse contributing artists behind them; none are exclusively female or enbie, leading one to wonder whether Jaguar is really part of the solution, or just another part of the problem?
She's certainly got the ample space between her nose and top lip that's characteristic of DJs
 
Atrás
Top Abajo