My peak nostalgic period is the mid 2000s, 2005-2007 to be exact, things were already starting to get a bit lame by 2009 (think Twilight, Jersey Shore) but the late 2000s were still decent, as was the early 2010s up to 2013.
It was when the shitstorm that was 2014 happened did things start to go south and it's never been the same since.
Amen. Early to mid 2000's were great. Especially 2004-2007
I still think 2005 was the happiest year of my life the more I look back on it.
I hated the late 2000's and in retrospect, I still wouldn't want to go back to 2008 or especially 2009.
When 2010 rolled around, I was actually kind of hopeful for the future and that the 2010's would turn out to be a good decade, especially since I was nearing the end of high school and a brand new decade made me feel things were due for a fresh start. Boy, I was wrong on that one.
2010-2013 was a decent time that was better than 2008-2009 and especially everything from 2015 onward. While 2014 was more or less the start of "Current Year" in the wider mainstream, I enjoyed 2014 on a personal level and kinda dismissed BLM as a flash in the pan movement like Occupy at the time and didn't follow GamerGate at all.
The weirdest part was that around 2010-2013, there was a wider sense of cautious optimism and I think it was especially strong in 2012. Like, 2007 had this palpable atmosphere of great change and this is a sentiment I've seen expressed by many people in many places.
2012 had that aura of change to a lesser extent, but there was also a palpable aura of cautious optimism and hope. But that might have been just me
Fuck, Toonami came back despite all the odds back in 2012. As trivial and unimportant as that was in the grand scheme of things, it was one of those events that made me and a lot of others cautiously hopeful for the future. The worst of the Great Recession was over and everyone knew things were bad and wanted to make things better.
The big nostalgia boom at that time was actually enjoyable and not just a heavily beaten and long dead horse. It wasn't until 2013 that there started to be a sense that something was wrong. 2007 had the feeling of great change in both good and bad ways, while 2012 had this weird hopeful naivety to it, like the calm just before the storm...
I do think the Sandy Hook massacre at the very end of 2012 played a role in that cultural shift, as did the Zimmerman trial the following year.