Science Arla ends methane-reducing cow feed trial as review begins - They don't mention that it ended early.

Archive | Live

A major UK trial testing a feed additive designed to cut methane emissions from dairy cows has ended, with Arla Foods reviewing the results before deciding whether to continue its use.

The Bovaer supplement, developed by DSM-Firmenich, was trialled on 30 Arla farms across Britain. It works by reducing methane-producing enzymes in a cow’s stomach and is claimed to lower emissions by up to 45%.

The product has been promoted as a major step towards climate-friendly farming — though its rollout has sparked heated debate.

The trial’s launch last year stirred debate about food safety and sparked online protests, including videos of people discarding milk in opposition.

DSM-Firmenich maintains that Bovaer is “proven, effective and safe”, and has been used by thousands of farmers in more than 25 countries.

A company spokesperson said the firm was aware that “some farmers have raised concerns about cow health” and that these were being fully investigated. “In previously reported cases, Bovaer was not identified as a contributing factor,” they added.

The Food Standards Agency approved Bovaer for UK use in 2023, concluding that milk from treated cows is safe to drink at approved doses. Methane has a much stronger short-term warming effect than carbon dioxide, making livestock emissions a key climate target.

In October 2023, Defra reaffirmed its commitment to reducing methane emissions from livestock, pledging to promote the use of methane-suppressing feed products in England.

However, the NFU said last year that such products must “work in real-life situations” and be supported alongside other emission-reducing techniques like genetics and efficiency improvements.

NFU Dairy Board chair Paul Tompkins said “questions remain about long-term efficacy” and whether the additive can be used “practically and effectively on farm” without affecting animal health or welfare.

He noted that Defra research had shown shoppers were generally positive about methane-suppressing feed “if human and animal health are not affected,” but warned that “a strong evidence base” was needed to give farmers confidence.

“This trial project between Arla, Morrisons, Aldi and Tesco could help provide this evidence,” Tompkins said, adding that “it’s important the supply chain and government continue to work together to enable informed decision-making on greenhouse gas reduction.”

Arla said that its trial findings were “currently being reviewed” before any decision on future adoption.
 
I've been getting milk delivered, from a company that explicitly avoids bovaer-adulterated milk, since I heard about this shit. I also get eggs, yoghurt, and strawberry milkshake, wi't proper foil tops, just like when I were a lad.
 
I'm pretty sure that this is the feed trial that was reported to be causing the cows to collapse recently.
If it ended early and the company that tried it is speaking of the whole product in corporate terms... that's not good.
How bad of a sign is it that they are speaking in corporate terms? Complete failure?
 
I don't know why they have to use synthetic chemicals for shit like this, when there's a naturally-occurring seaweed (Asparagopsis) that has the same or better effect when added to cattle feed. There's been a lot of promising work done in that area; I get periodic emails from one of the orgs doing it, Symbrosia, but there are others out there.

Of course when I say I don't know why they're insisting on synthetic chemicals, I mean we all know why, because that's where the real money and research grants come in and the big paychecks for pharma CEOs. Same as it ever was.
 
Are they still harping about this "cow farts are warming our planet" bullshit? While at the same time we have a continent's worth of coal burning power plants working 24/7.
 
I've been getting milk delivered, from a company that explicitly avoids bovaer-adulterated milk, since I heard about this shit. I also get eggs, yoghurt, and strawberry milkshake, wi't proper foil tops, just like when I were a lad.
I'll have to check on where I get milk from as well. I wonder if in the UK "organic" excludes bovaer supplementation. It certainly should, but the government likes to try and make sneaky exceptions for stuff like this. Such as how you don't need to list Bill Gates' "Apeel" treatment on food, despite that that many would distrust it and it also makes food taste weirdly rubbery. (The only way I can describe the bizarre texture).
 
The Food Standards Agency approved Bovaer for UK use in 2023, concluding that milk from treated cows is safe to drink at approved doses.
Approved doses. For milk.

Get fucked. If I can only eat/drink/consume a certain amount of milk or cheese or ice cream or half & half before it becomes toxic due to something in the cow's fodder, then don't use that fodder at all.
 
Approved doses. For milk.

Get fucked. If I can only eat/drink/consume a certain amount of milk or cheese or ice cream or half & half before it becomes toxic due to something in the cow's fodder, then don't use that fodder at all.
It's approved doses of the "supplement" for cows, not the milk for people. They're claiming that the dose given to cows isn't enough to cause problems for people. It leads one to infer there's an unsafe dose, which they've never actually defined.
 
Approved doses. For milk.

Get fucked. If I can only eat/drink/consume a certain amount of milk or cheese or ice cream or half & half before it becomes toxic due to something in the cow's fodder, then don't use that fodder at all.
Yeah the minute that anybody starts talking about approved doses like that in any kind of food it should be setting off instant alarm bells that this is dangerous as fuck

That said if they're so worried about farting causing serious emission issues they should start coming up with additives to add to the food in india. That and take away their curries. Global fart emissions would drop like a rock
 
Are they still harping about this "cow farts are warming our planet" bullshit? While at the same time we have a continent's worth of coal burning power plants working 24/7.
Modern environmentalists are just a bunch of people paid to find ways to kill cattle so they can yell about carbon and get more bullshit regulations pushed.
 
Cows are ruminants. Ruminants have evolved along with their gut bacteria and are dependent on them.
The Food Standards Agency approved Bovaer for UK use in 2023, concluding that milk from treated cows is safe to drink at approved doses.
I’d like to see what data they used because I haven’t seen any at all that proves it’s safe
I've been getting milk delivered, from a company that explicitly avoids bovaer-adulterated milk, since I heard about this shit. I also get eggs, yoghurt, and strawberry milkshake, wi't proper foil tops, just like when I were a lad.
Good. I’ve been a strict organic only dairy since I heard of it
"Moving up the foodchain" level bad.
At least, that's what I heard.
Tell me more,
I wonder if in the UK "organic" excludes bovaer supplementation. It certainly should, but the government likes to try and make sneaky exceptions for stuff like this.
It does for now as far as I know. There is of course a huge push to say ‘well it’s green so…’
This has been a massive experiment using the British public. Nobody has been asked if they want to drink milk laced with this stuff. Nobody has consented. Cows need the bacteria in their guts. They may well need the gases to form to have healthy guts. We have no idea what the stuff does when it gets pissed out into fields either, but buggering up the microbiome of the soil is rarely a good idea.
Bovaer requires full PPE to handle. It isn’t a benign food additive.
I’d be interested to see what the guys actual values are for somatic cell count in the milk. Milk is deemed u fit for human consumption once that value hits a certain threshold. I think it’s something like 4x whatever is normal.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo