Ruthless timeshare fraud robbed elderly of savings

Link: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgvxg47gl6o
Credit: Nikki Mitchell, South of England home affairs correspondent, and Stephen Stafford, South of England
Archive: https://archive.ph/wip/jx7R4

431936a0-aa8a-11f0-978a-a301e44bcdc7.jpg.webp

A man duped out of £14,000 has said those responsible are "scum", as the shocking scale of a £28m timeshare fraud involving more than 3,500 victims is revealed.

Fourteen people, including managing director Mark Rowe and his wife Nicola, have been convicted over the scheme which operated under the Sell My Timeshare brand.

The couple, both 54 and from Hampshire, bankrolled a lavish lifestyle by exploiting vulnerable victims - many in their 70s and 80s - who were desperate to sell their holiday homes.

Des, 73, from south London, told the BBC the moment he realised he had lost thousands felt "like a kick in the guts" - a devastating setback that forced him to delay his retirement.
The "elaborate" and "complex" fraud, which began in 2013, is thought to be one of the biggest conspiracies of its kind in the UK.

Timeshares usually involve paying a one-off lump sum, plus annual maintenance fees, in return for being able to use a property for an agreed number of weeks each year, every year for life.

Predominantly in the 1980s and 1990s, timeshares were marketed as holidays without the hassle, and many investors were told they would increase in value and be easy to get out of, whenever they wanted.

As owners aged or suffered failing health, many found they could no longer use the homes or afford the rising maintenance payments and wanted to dispose of them.

These are the people Mark Rowe and his accomplices targeted, the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) said.

Victims were "lured" with offers of exchanging their timeshares for "Monster Credits" which promised holiday discounts and shopping vouchers.

It was claimed these would grow in value and be tradable at a future date. Clients typically invested about £8,000 each.

They would later discover not only were the credits "worthless", but in most cases, they still owned and incurred the costs of their timeshares.

Police investigators described "high-pressure" sales meetings in offices in Bournemouth, York, Stratford-on-Avon or Tenerife, which often lasted up to six hours.

db89cc30-aa97-11f0-b2a1-6f537f66f9aa.png.webp

Mark and Nicola Rowe lived a lavish lifestyle from the profits of their crimes


In total, 3,583 people across the UK were defrauded out of £28.1m, with the highest individual loss being £80,000.

Nearly 500 victims lost more than £10,000. Most were aged between 60 and 80, with some in their 90s.

Des, from Mitcham, recalled how he was persuaded to take out a loan by the company.

The police have asked us not to reveal his surname.

The former engineer had been trying to sell his family's timeshares in Tenerife and was alerted to the con by the police.

"We were devastated because I wanted to retire at the time, but now I couldn't afford to," he said.

"I was absolutely gutted and every phone call I made to the Bournemouth office, I got fobbed off."

Des, who branded the fraudsters "scum", said: "How do these people sleep at night?

"They don't care about us normal people. They're greedy, they get greedier and they're living their life of luxury from their ill-gotten gains."

8ccafb80-aa94-11f0-ba75-093eca1ac29b.jpg.webp

Victims were persuaded to buy so-called Monster Rewards which were "worthless"


Mark Rowe spent millions of pounds of his victims' cash on advertising, glossy brochures, websites, virtual offices, accomplices and unsuspecting employees - things that police and prosecutors say made the brand look like a "highly credible" and "prestige" enterprise.

But Mark and Nicola Rowe had £8m from the fraud paid into their personal bank accounts.

Their spending included almost £1m on home, garden and stable improvements, £185,000 on art, including a pencil sketch by the artist LS Lowry, and £26,000 on private jet hire.

Mark Rowe was jailed for seven-and-a-half years in August after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud.

Passing sentence, Judge Alexander Milne called him "profoundly dishonest" and a "corrupting influence" who had "left a trail of misery".

"The anger, embarrassment and humiliation of the clients who realised they had been duped was palpable in court," he said.

ebf1cdf0-a9db-11f0-b2dc-37eb57bf4de6.jpg.webp

Mark and Nicola Rowe's £2.4m Hampshire home, which has since been sold, was financed by their fraud


Nicola Rowe is due to be sentenced later at Southwark Crown Court after pleading guilty to money laundering.

Senior investigating officer Peter Highway, from the South West Regional Organised Crime Unit, described how Mark Rowe continually invented new methods to deceive.

"He paid for TV and magazine ads, put victims up in hotels and even created fake virtual offices and fake personas," he said.

A BBC Scotland investigation uncovered evidence in 2016 that ageing timeshare owners were having problems relinquishing their contracts.

Gayle Ramsay, from the CPS, said some of the victims had died before seeing justice.

She said the criminals had "acted in a completely selfish and manipulative manner to make huge sums for themselves" while exploiting elderly timeshare owners.

She added the victims had been left tens of thousands of pounds out of pocket after purchasing something which was worthless.

Twelve other people were also convicted:

Jodi Beard, 43, of El Roque, Tenerife, two years' imprisonment suspended for two years after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Paul Harrison, 55, of Weymouth, four-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Nihat Salih, 57, of Poole, Dorset, three years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Lisa Salih, 56, of Poole, two years' imprisonment suspended for two years after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Samantha Macaulay, 52, of San Miguel De Abona, Tenerife, 18 months' imprisonment suspended for 18 months after being found guilty of fraud by false representation. Macaulay was found not guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Simon Walker, 58, of Costa Adeje in Tenerife, was sentenced to four-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Joanne Physick, 46, of Los Christianos Arona, Tenerife, two-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

David Taylor, 65, of East Yorkshire, three years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Joanne Taylor, 53, of East Yorkshire,12 months' imprisonment, suspended for two years, after pleading guilty to fraud by false representation

Lee Evans, 51, of Preston, two years' imprisonment, suspended for two years, after pleading guilty to fraud by false representation

Barrie Fox, 69, of Worcester, and Josephine Cuthill-Fox, 60, of Worcester, are due to be sentenced later after pleading guilty to fraud by false representation
 
It's easy to blame the victims of scams like this, because it just seems so stupid. But really we're seeing the remnants of a high-trust society exploited in exactly the manner that produces a low-trust society. If you just let this happen, you don't have a country anymore. It's pretty obvious what would solve this problem. Mass bloodshed. Genocide of the dysgenic. Corpses filleted, crucified on the sides of streets. Make criminals ask "what the fuck did that guy do" and say "okay I'm not doing that." But none of that will happen in our lifetimes, because too many of our peers are fuckin' retards.
 
It's easy to blame the victims of scams like this, because it just seems so stupid. But really we're seeing the remnants of a high-trust society exploited in exactly the manner that produces a low-trust society. If you just let this happen, you don't have a country anymore. It's pretty obvious what would solve this problem. Mass bloodshed. Genocide of the dysgenic. Corpses filleted, crucified on the sides of streets. Make criminals ask "what the fuck did that guy do" and say "okay I'm not doing that." But none of that will happen in our lifetimes, because too many of our peers are fuckin' retards.

I don't disagree with you on any point. I just find it a teeny tiny bit heart warming that the generation that destroyed that high trust society feels the sting of it just a little at the end of their lives.
 
Anybody with half a brain knows timeshares have been scams since the 70's and maybe even further back than that. Even the 'monster credit' package looks like it's something Grok or google AI spun up after photoshopping out the watermark. Have people just forgot the old adage "If it seems too good to be true, it probably is"?
If it wasn't this time-share scam they got caught up in, it would have been something else. Some people are just dumb and believe whatever they're told.
Article makes it seem like the mystery meat browns are doing the most time besides one dude who's probably White. If a jeet comes to you with ANY deal or offer, it's 100% a scam and you should just get up and leave.
 
Twelve other people were also convicted:

Jodi Beard, 43, of El Roque, Tenerife, two years' imprisonment suspended for two years after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Paul Harrison, 55, of Weymouth, four-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Nihat Salih, 57, of Poole, Dorset, three years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Lisa Salih, 56, of Poole, two years' imprisonment suspended for two years after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Simon Walker, 58, of Costa Adeje in Tenerife, was sentenced to four-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

Joanne Physick, 46, of Los Christianos Arona, Tenerife, two-and-a-half years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud

David Taylor, 65, of East Yorkshire, three years' imprisonment after being found guilty of conspiracy to defraud
The shortest sentence given to a man is longer than the longest sentence given to a woman despite all being convicted of the same crime.

Always remember, the patriarchy is super real.
 
My dad’s side of the family was incredibly grateful that their parents dealt with their timeshare way back in the 80s/90s, so that was one shitshow they didn’t have to deal with as part of the estate.
 
Anybody with half a brain knows timeshares have been scams since the 70's and maybe even further back than that. Even the 'monster credit' package looks like it's something Grok or google AI spun up after photoshopping out the watermark. Have people just forgot the old adage "If it seems too good to be true, it probably is"?
If it wasn't this time-share scam they got caught up in, it would have been something else. Some people are just dumb and believe whatever they're told.
Article makes it seem like the mystery meat browns are doing the most time besides one dude who's probably White. If a jeet comes to you with ANY deal or offer, it's 100% a scam and you should just get up and leave.
If you have already bought a time-share you are already on the gullible mark list and viewed as ripe to be picked again. Any one who buys a time-share has proven the hard sell is effective on them and critical thinking in short supply.

The “we will buy your time share” scams proliferate in the USA but I never hear of any criminal prosecutions of them. They do take the suckers for round two somehow though, but not via laughable “monster credits” but probably something similar.
 
My dad’s side of the family was incredibly grateful that their parents dealt with their timeshare way back in the 80s/90s, so that was one shitshow they didn’t have to deal with as part of the estate.
It was already widely known among Brits to be a pile of shit by the 90s. I can remember being on holiday in Spain in the early 90s with my parents and having some other Brit try to sell them timeshart bollocks as we were walking down the street. Interestingly, the age range of this bunch of fraudsters is about the same as what those timeshart pushers would be by now.
 
The shortest sentence given to a man is longer than the longest sentence given to a woman despite all being convicted of the same crime.

Always remember, the patriarchy is super real.
"Women are dumb and uncreative, men are superior born leaders"
also
"Women were the instigators in the scam, men were just hred muscle"

take ur meds
 
I feel like the timeshare scam can't last another generation, right? When you hear the word "timeshare" the first associations are sitcom episodes where the dad regrets being tricked into buying a timeshare and daytime adverts for the timeshare escape industry. There's no convincing people to buy into that anymore

Well I looked and apparently they've rebranded as "vacation clubs" and
According to the latest published numbers — a 2022 report by the American Resort Development Association (ARDA), millennials now account for half of all timeshare owners. In fact the average age of a timeshare owner is now 39 years old.

In the past decade, the timeshare industry has been quietly transforming from something your grandparents owned for an annual week in January to a dynamic, anytime vacation rental.

Millennials are embracing this change, and becoming the newest generation to buy timeshares.

Unlike the traditional timeshare owner — retired grandparents who almost always went to Hawaii or Florida — today’s owner doesn’t rely on certain properties or dates. Timeshare programs like Club Wyndham and Hilton sell ownership by way of points, exchangeable for stays in any of their hundreds of properties worldwide.

 
Atrás
Top Abajo