2024 Syrian opposition offensives - The first Syrian rebel offensive against Government forces since March 2020

Angela Merkel also went from deputy spokesman of the East German democratic government to head of the German Christian Democratic Union in just eleven years, and at the wise, ripe age of 46, becoming Germany's Reichskanzler five years later. Oh, and her predecessor as Reichskanzler, Gerhard Schroeder of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (who have been in bed with the Commies both within and without ever since the Weimar years) has been heavily involved with Rosneft, Gazprom, and both Nordstream pipelines to the tune of some very large sums of money.

But hey, there's no Russian influence over the German government at all and never has been!
If you actually dig into it first it's Bundeskanzler, secondly, Merkel just became that after the Wind of Change swept thru the DDR and her party was actually democratically elected into power there.

That sperging aside, do we know where Assad is now? Is he dead?
 
The SAA was clearly caught off-guard
Not really. They knew something was coming, but the problem is that the SAA was just hollowed out. There wasn't anything left. I want to be clear, the SAA was one of the most effective and professional fighting forces in the region for a long time, and what they were able to accomplish in the early stages of the war can be described as nothing short of Herculean. One of my favorite examples was near the Homs military academy, where the SAA had encircled a number of Hezbollah fighters, and intentionally withdrew along the thinnest salient, which caused Hezbollah to overcommit and surge over a thousand fresh troops into the bulge. Immediately afterwards the SAA reclaimed the salient and killed something like two thousand Hezbollah fighters. We're talking tactical considerations on the level of individual buildings. Absolutely stellar leadership and discipline.

That was in 2014. All of that leadership, all of those men, are dead or retired. What came up after them was a hollow force, made up of poorly trained and poorly equipped conscripts. For instance, that battle in Homs, was itself conducted by military academy cadets and the training cadre. They took severe casualties during the Siege of Homs, which lasted almost 3 years. You just don't get that experience back. Military tradition like that takes generations to develop, and if mismanaged, it can can all go up in smoke in a single war. To give you an example, there are direct descendants of Robert E. Lee serving as officers in the US military. Abrams has multiple grandchildren actively serving in the US military.

Do you know why German fighter aces in average scored multiples of the number of kills that American aces did? It's because once someone became an ace, they were pulled from combat and placed in the training cadre, whereas German pilots just flew until they got unlucky and died. With them died thousands of hours of combat experience, and dozens of lessons learned from air victories. The SAA gambled by surging their best and brightest into the front, and it won them the battle, but lost them the war.

I apologize, I'm a military historian and I am very passionate about my work, and therefore tend to go off on these tangents, but what I'm saying is true. Christmas is coming up for our Gregorian friends, which means you'll be seeing a lot of your family. I know many people here have fathers and grandfathers and uncles that are retired from the military, and I'm sure more than a few of you will be bored to tears hearing stories of "when I was in the service." This year, listen. Understand that the reason they survived was because they are standing on the shoulders of giants. The information that kept them alive was passed down over a half dozen generations of men that came before them, and their experiences and the information they handed down saved the lives of many young men that came after them.

Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox now. Thank you for reading my diatribe.
I hate this strawman shit. Nobody is saying he's a moderate democratic freedom man. Again, HTS is a terror organization as designated by the United States.
If before the whole invasion of Kuwait had the US pressured the Gulf states to come to an agreement with Iraq regarding oil production quotas, which the US could easily do since
The problem really was HW's weak signals. The Cold War was over, and Bush Sr. was, understandably, not wanting to drag the US into a conflict when it looked like a new era of peace was on the horizon, but this unclear message emboldened Saddam. A lot of my colleagues disagree with me, but I firmly believe that if the US had told Saddam that, in no uncertain terms, that an invasion of Iraq's neighbors would be met by military force, I do not believe Saddam would've launched an invasion. Saddam had several conversations with US State Department officials before he launched his invasion and basically told them his plans, and, without clear guidance from the President, basically said "please do not." Now, do I agree with the US response? Absolutely. Desert Storm was one of the most resounding military successes in US history. 100 hours and Kuwait was liberated. The US laid an absolute smackdown on Iraq (which at the time had the world's 4th largest army) the world hadn't seen since the opening days of the Blitz. That being said, as the Art of War tells us, the apex of skill is not winning a thousand battles out of a thousand battles fought, but winning a battle without fighting at all. I think it could've been avoided.
 
Its not over until its over. Damascus could hold out for months or fall in ten days depending on what their soldiers are willing to die for and how good they can manage supplies through Lebanon.
Damascus fell practically without a fight less than twenty-four hours after I made this post. No will to survive from Assad's forces. Such goes the arab nationalists.
 
It appears to me that HTS is genuinely attempting to play ball with the US and Gulf States. I don't know if this line will hold, but at least right now, in this moment, it appears that their objective is to build a big tent moderate base of support. I am genuinely praying that this line holds. Screenshot_20241209-144344.png
 
It appears to me that HTS is genuinely attempting to play ball with the US and Gulf States. I don't know if this line will hold, but at least right now, in this moment, it appears that their objective is to build a big tent moderate base of support. I am genuinely praying that this line holds.Ver archivo adjunto 6734387
It appears, at least right now, they REALLY want to be un designated as a terror organization. Even the Taliban didn't try this hard.
 
I'm curious about where Assad is, if he went to Russia/Iran/Abu Dhabi you'd think he'd have some plain post on him "not really losing yet" and showing he is alive. Especially if he is in Russia where the chance for someone to assassinate him (that wasn't Putin) was high.

Also it's interesting how Israel sideline striking against Syria did enough military and economic damage that it helped with giving the rebels the chance to finish the civil war.
 
I'm curious about where Assad is, if he went to Russia/Iran/Abu Dhabi you'd think he'd have some plain post on him "not really losing yet" and showing he is alive. Especially if he is in Russia where the chance for someone to assassinate him (that wasn't Putin) was high.

Also it's interesting how Israel sideline striking against Syria did enough military and economic damage that it helped with giving the rebels the chance to finish the civil war.
He'll become a wagie.
 
So what happens to Christians there now?
Right now? Not much yet. The winning side is still trying to portray itself as having 'gone woke' by Islamist standards, that they'll be far nicer than ISIS (or themselves 10 years ago for that matter), have chastised their own men for trying (poorly) to knock down Christmas trees in Christian districts and put said trees back up, etc. It's still kinda up in the air whether they'll even form a semi-functional government or if we're actually just about to witness a new phase of the Syrian Civil War.

Check back sometime early next year, within a couple months we should have a much better idea of whether HTS has genuinely reformed (as much as an Islamist army can) or if it was all taqiyya all along. The Christians probably shouldn't expect to enjoy full civil rights like they would in a normal western country any time soon, but by then we'll be able to see whether they're still alive & doing the best they can in-country under Saudi-style conditions (missionary work banned, public displays of faith restricted, etc.) or if they've all been forced to flee to Lebanon to not get their heads lopped off.
Not really. They knew something was coming, but the problem is that the SAA was just hollowed out. There wasn't anything left. I want to be clear, the SAA was one of the most effective and professional fighting forces in the region for a long time, and what they were able to accomplish in the early stages of the war can be described as nothing short of Herculean. One of my favorite examples was near the Homs military academy, where the SAA had encircled a number of Hezbollah fighters, and intentionally withdrew along the thinnest salient, which caused Hezbollah to overcommit and surge over a thousand fresh troops into the bulge. Immediately afterwards the SAA reclaimed the salient and killed something like two thousand Hezbollah fighters. We're talking tactical considerations on the level of individual buildings. Absolutely stellar leadership and discipline.

That was in 2014. All of that leadership, all of those men, are dead or retired. What came up after them was a hollow force, made up of poorly trained and poorly equipped conscripts. For instance, that battle in Homs, was itself conducted by military academy cadets and the training cadre. They took severe casualties during the Siege of Homs, which lasted almost 3 years. You just don't get that experience back. Military tradition like that takes generations to develop, and if mismanaged, it can can all go up in smoke in a single war. To give you an example, there are direct descendants of Robert E. Lee serving as officers in the US military. Abrams has multiple grandchildren actively serving in the US military.

Do you know why German fighter aces in average scored multiples of the number of kills that American aces did? It's because once someone became an ace, they were pulled from combat and placed in the training cadre, whereas German pilots just flew until they got unlucky and died. With them died thousands of hours of combat experience, and dozens of lessons learned from air victories. The SAA gambled by surging their best and brightest into the front, and it won them the battle, but lost them the war.

I apologize, I'm a military historian and I am very passionate about my work, and therefore tend to go off on these tangents, but what I'm saying is true. Christmas is coming up for our Gregorian friends, which means you'll be seeing a lot of your family. I know many people here have fathers and grandfathers and uncles that are retired from the military, and I'm sure more than a few of you will be bored to tears hearing stories of "when I was in the service." This year, listen. Understand that the reason they survived was because they are standing on the shoulders of giants. The information that kept them alive was passed down over a half dozen generations of men that came before them, and their experiences and the information they handed down saved the lives of many young men that came after them.

Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox now. Thank you for reading my diatribe.
I don't think we're in disagreement, I made a similar point (albeit not in the post you quoted, it was somewhere many pages ago in this thread). The SAA did have good elements to it, they really weren't all useless & spineless cannon fodder (and further back in time, under Assad Sr. they did at times manage to fight well against Israel, like in the early stages of the Yom Kippur War or when they met head-to-head in Lebanon later on), but yes those good elements were hollowed out due to attrition and I don't think the regime ever got good at recovering from their losses. When guys like Issam Zahreddine or these cadets you're talking about died, that was it, Assad couldn't find anyone to replace them. That was somewhat manageable when he could still count on outside reinforcements like Hezbollah (they've always been an Assad ally, I assume you meant rebels there? IIRC Homs was originally contested by the local FSA-aligned Farouq Brigade & Khalid Ibn Walid Brigade, plus Ahrar al-Sham and some Islamic Front rebels) or Wagner/the Russian Air Force to fill the gap, but since he couldn't anymore this time...

This trend got even worse in the high-speed, high-stress conditions of the recent rebel blitz when the remainder of this hard core was stationed along the front lines with HTS and took shattering losses in the first few days, depriving Assad of his best men in an extremely short span of time & creating panic as news of the losses got out. The Tiger Forces I mentioned earlier reportedly fought hard in Saraqib (before Aleppo fell) and along the major M4 highway, where they apparently took massive casualties at the hands of the new & improved HTS. Whatever was left of them then got reorganized for the stand at Hama, which is where they were finished off and HTS proceeded to dance on their mass grave online. The same probably happened with all the other remaining SAA formations still worth a damn as of last month.

From what I've heard the SAA's paper strength of 170,000 last year (plus ~50,000 NDF militiamen) was also mostly bullshit, a lot of those men didn't actually exist and their real fighting strength this time was closer to 40-50,000. Not too dissimilar a problem compared to Afghanistan's ghost soldiers. Supposedly a lot of soldiers were demobilized between 2020 and now, not only because there was a ceasefire nominally in place with Idlib, but also because Assad literally didn't have the funds to pay to keep so many men under arms (since he thought he had won, he & his friends at the top of the gov't pocketed the defense budget instead). While HTS was leveling up as an army in Idlibistan, I read that the SAA got deeply involved with the drug trade (namely captagon, along with Hezbollah, although Hez didn't decay as much as they did) to the point that the post-2020 SAA which just got destroyed was more of a drug cartel than an actual military, and we are now looking at the consequences of that + Assad's more general absolute failure at meaningfully rebuilding Syria in any way despite receiving up to $50 billion from Iran.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo