Dismantling an argument all about a man being a woman shows how many hoops he goes through, how many mountains you have to climb and leaps of faith you must make. Rebuttals to arguments aren't always for the one being argued with: Jesse would just stomp his clompers and say no. These types are for others, the ones undecided and the ones who need extra ammo for their own points.
True. None of Jessie's fans will ever doubt him. But a terfling on Ovarit or elsewhere might.
That's the thing, though, I'm not sure anybody in this is really a true believer, not even the troons themselves - that's why they flip the fuck out whenever their views are challenged or mocked.
You'd be surprised. Troons like Erin Reed will ride it until they do, and I'm pretty sure Jessie hangs around him too. The entire psyche of a Troon is to be a believer of sorts; as Jessie argued, what he makes of himself overrides his physical traits - all other things are redundant.
When he made his cluster argument, for example, he unironically sounded like a TERF: a woman doesn't have to like pink or wear skirts to be a woman. But since he personally likes those things, and assigns them to "what a woman is", he therefore is a woman. The fact he, like Choob, makes the argument that since black women are seen as more masculine, they aren't women irks me too. He's white as white can be - hell even I'm darker than him.
Plus, he just came out with a nearly three hour documentary going after detransitioners. and a three hour one on Matt Walsh. He also fed into the "Hogwarts Legacy is genocide" schtick, which saw a lot of people threatened for playing it. He never apologized for that - why would he?
What I wasn't surprised by is that he didn't reference any sources. Someone mentioned Lily Alexandre - I watched that one too, and that white boy can't answer the question I pose to Jessie:
If your ancestors has no idea what sex was, how'd they know which ones were the women when they took them as sex slaves?
They know. They just don't want you to notice.