I am Islams AMA

Rate majority Islamic countries from best to worst?

What do you think of the blasphemy laws in many Islamic nations? Specifically when used to punish secularists etc.

Is there a primary/significant "Satan/Antichrist" devil figure in Islamic theology?
ok, this list is pure personal preference. I will limit it to my two favorite, to two least favorite.
1.Turkey
2.Jordan
3.Pakistan
4.I.S. (Daesh)

Blasphemy laws are shirk. It is not our duty to punish anyone on this planet, leave that to god.

Oh, there is indeed a Satan figure in Islam. He has a very complex name in arabic, Shaitan. Hahahaha
What about the fatwa on Salman Rushdie for writing an excellent novel that didn't even insult the Prophet?
Something to bear in mind, one, the fatwa was made by Salafists. They are morons. Also, fatwas are not binding. Islam has no central leader, like a pope. A fatwa is simply a judgement made by a man based on his interpretation of fiqh. These can vary very wildly, and your mileage may vary. If you disagree with a fatwa, simply ignore it. It is only one man's judgement.

Stop blowing everything up you fucking sand barbarians.
Blaming every Muslim for every terrorist attack would be like saying all Christians are part of the Westboro Baptist Church. The people you speak of do indeed profess to be Muslims, however, they ignore some very basic tenets of the religion. Islam also includes Sufis, which are complete pacifists, I will not lie and say they are not extremists, but it is very important to make that distinction.

Salafists and the marginally more radical Wahhabis are the source of the broad majority of the attacks you speak of, and I will tell you yes, they are here in the US, and yes, they need to be stamped out.

So how come you chop the tips off your dicks?
Funny you mention that! There are actually differing views on circumcisions in Islam. One argument is that it was what Abraham did, so we should do it too. The other argument is that if we were created by Allah, why change anything? Do we think we can improve upon his creation? So either it is required, or it is a shirk, based on your school of thought.
 
Última edición por un moderador:
What are your thoughts on slavery and jizya? Do you believe slavery was practiced by Mohammed?

Do you believe the punishment for apostasy is death? If not, explain how you can justify this.
 
What are your thoughts on slavery and jizya? Do you believe slavery was practiced by Mohammed?

Do you believe the punishment for apostasy is death? If not, explain how you can justify this.
Slavery is wrong, and Mohammed didn't practice it. It was the later dynasties that had encouraged it. Jizya is also wrong and does not apply in modern society, or in real Islam.
I believe there should be no punishment for apostasy since people should have the freedom to believe in what they want.
 
What are your thoughts on slavery and jizya? Do you believe slavery was practiced by Mohammed?

Do you believe the punishment for apostasy is death? If not, explain how you can justify this.

Slavery was practiced by some of the sahaba after Muhammad (PBUH) emulating some of the people and empires they had conquered, like Persia and chunks of the Byzantine empire. It makes no sense in modern society.

Jizya tax made sense for a long time. It was every man's duty to provide military service for his country. In lieu of this, people of other faiths were permitted to pay a tax instead if they could afford it. you could always provide military service and forego the tax as well. Personally, I don't have a problem with this. We have conscientious objectors in the United States as well, and if they are drafted, they still have to provide service. Why not just simplify it and make the the service a financial contribution to pay those who protect you if you can afford it

Of course, this in and of itself has nothing to do with islam, but rather a political matter.

I believe people have free will. If they turn their back on their faith, then god will judge them. If they deserve it, then god will punish them. Not my job.
Why do you follow a 'messiah' that was confirmed a pedophile in the Quran?
You mean Jesus? We call him Isa. He's the Messiah. If you mean our prophet (PBUH), then, times were very different. When 17 is middle aged, you got to figure out who is marrying who and start families a bit sooner if you actually want to make sure you are there to see your children into adulthood. We live longer now, and this no longer applies.

Are genies real?
Not in the western sense, no. Djinn are just Islam's equivalent to demons.
 
What makes the Quran different from the Bible? Is there a difference?

And since you call Jesus (Isa) the Messiah above, what exactly is Islam's stance on Him?
 
What makes the Quran different from the Bible? Is there a difference?

And since you call Jesus (Isa) the Messiah above, what exactly is Islam's stance on Him?
The Bible has undergone centuries of translation that has altered it's original meaning. More than half of it was written by a man who lived as a hermit on an island and never even met Isa (Jesus). The quran is the same book, no matter where you are. A Quran in Malaysia is the same book in Arabia. Every word of the Quran is exactly as it was given to the prophet (PBUH). We believe that the true Bible, the gospel of Jesus, has been lost to time. Ultimately the Bible has some truth to it, but it hS been corrupted. It isn't inherently good or bad, just altered.

In Islam, Isa (Jesus) is treated as a prophet and Messiah. We believe he did indeed rise from the dead, and we both believe about 90% of the thing the Christians think about him. Where we disagree, we believe Jesus was just a man. A good and just man, but still just a man. He is a prophet just like Ibrahim (Abraham), and Musa (Moses) before him, and Muhammad (PBUH) after him. The difference is Muhammad (PBUH) is the final prophet.
 
You mean Jesus? We call him Isa. He's the Messiah. If you mean our prophet (PBUH), then, times were very different. When 17 is middle aged, you got to figure out who is marrying who and start families a bit sooner if you actually want to make sure you are there to see your children into adulthood. We live longer now, and this no longer applies.
Lmao you're defending a pedo piece of shit fucking a nine year old and trying to justify it by saying seventeen was middle age back then, no it fucking wasn't.

Fucking nine year olds is fucking ridiculous what a shit prophet to follow.
 
Lmao you're defending a pedo piece of shit fucking a nine year old and trying to justify it by saying seventeen was middle age back then, no it fucking wasn't.

Fucking nine year olds is fucking ridiculous what a shit prophet to follow.
There is just as much evidence that Muhammad (PBUH) consummated his marriage with Aisha when she was much older. The only source for the age of 6 for marriage and 9 for consumation is a Hadith, and not all Hadith are accurate. These were written down several hundred years after Muhammad (PBUH) left us. When referring to how you should look at Islam, look to the Quran first, then the Hadith for context. Many Hadith are contradictory, that is why it is important to use common sense.

Edit: here is an excellent source on life expectancy in medieval Arabia and Europe. 17 was about middle age it seems. http://www.sarahwoodbury.com/life-expectancy-muslim-world-verses-christian-world-in-the-middle-ages/
 
Última edición por un moderador:
What happens to a Muslim if his suicide is a sacrifice?
Like being left behind intentionally to allow others to escape, or a fighter pilot crashing into the enemy.
 
Lmao you're defending a pedo piece of shit fucking a nine year old and trying to justify it by saying seventeen was middle age back then, no it fucking wasn't.

Fucking nine year olds is fucking ridiculous what a shit prophet to follow.
You better be fucking trolling. Muhammed was probably a pedophile but people were dropping well before they hit 40.
 
What happens to a Muslim if his suicide is a sacrifice?
Like being left behind intentionally to allow others to escape, or a fighter pilot crashing into the enemy.
In the first case, that is not suicide. In the second case, unless there is literally no other option, say maybe you are going to crash anyway, then it'd be ok. Suicide is never acceptable.
 
Nobody cares if some Muslims aren't outright terrorists, we're more concerned with the fact that none of y'all bitches are doing shit about the fact that many of you are, and those of you who aren't are your enemies.

As Western society, we're going to continue bombing the shit out of you until your so-called "brethren" quit doing that shit.

Not to be too much of a dick or anything.
 
Can I spend you at Middle-Eastern McDonalds #TYCED
Only in Israel where we are currency.

Edit to avoid double post:

Nobody cares if some Muslims aren't outright terrorists, we're more concerned with the fact that none of y'all bitches are doing shit about the fact that many of you are, and those of you who aren't are your enemies.

As Western society, we're going to continue bombing the shit out of you until your so-called "brethren" quit doing that shit.

Not to be too much of a dick or anything.

The problem we currently have is that the moderate muslims in the country are far outweighed by the more radicalized ones from other countries. The US attracts the poorest of the poor to it, and that means you get a lot of mud hut dwellers from the third world. Go to a modernized country that isn't reliant on oil for its income, and you will see an immediate difference. Prime examples are Jordan and Turkey. Both of these countries are fighting against terrorists as well.

If you want to hear more moderate voices? Want to see more Muslims willing to fight Salafists? Stop bringing in somalians, west africans, syrians, and pakis. You will see a world of difference.
 
Última edición por un moderador:
Nobody cares if some Muslims aren't outright terrorists, we're more concerned with the fact that none of y'all bitches are doing shit about the fact that many of you are, and those of you who aren't are your enemies.

As Western society, we're going to continue bombing the shit out of you until your so-called "brethren" quit doing that shit.

Not to be too much of a dick or anything.
The west can't caliphate fast enough.

Edit: Also, I'm not saying 17 isn't middle age in term of numbers. I'm saying to even consider it middle aged, even back then when most people died 40-60 is retarded. With that logic, would you two also say that a six year old would be considered a fucking adult back then, too? No.
 
The west can't caliphate fast enough.

Edit: Also, I'm not saying 17 isn't middle age in term of numbers. I'm saying to even consider it middle aged, even back then when most people died 40-60 is exceptional. With that logic, would you two also say that a six year old would be considered a fucking adult back then, too? No.
Pretty sure at this point you're just trolling, but i'm bored so i'll answer.

let's assume you wait until 26 to have your first child, as is the norm today (http://www.npr.org/sections/health-...-of-first-time-moms-keeps-climbing-in-the-u-s) you raise the child until you reach the ripe old age of 37. Your child is now an orphan in a society without any sort of safety net, in the desert, at age 11. Brilliant, no?

Also, married does not mean consummated. There is a single hadith that indicates Aisha's age at the time of marriage. Truth be told, we will never know at what age Aisha lost her virginity.

However, you claim that Muhammad (PBUH) was a pedophile. That is easy enough to refute. A pedophile is someone who is sexually attracted to children. Muhammad (PBUH) was a successful business man who took as his first wife someone 15 years his senior. If anything, he liked older women, and took a younger wife so he could have more children, which isn't exactly what happened.
 
Atrás
Top Abajo