Brian Cox says physics 'ruled out' the human soul at particle level

Estado
No está abierto para más respuestas.

LIFE after death theories collapse under scientific scrutiny because the field of particle physics has "ruled out" the possibility of humans having a soul, renowned physicist Brian Cox has claimed.​

Questions about the afterlife remain unanswered with the jury still out on whether life after death is real. Many people claim to know what happens when we die, based on anecdotal evidence and stories from so-called near-death experiences or NDEs. People who have stood on the brink of death often recall visions of bright lights or memories of seeing their deceased loved ones.

NDEs are often reported by people who have gone into cardiac arrest or were briefly declared clinically dead while on the operating table.

In some instances, the visions and memories are very detailed, such as the man who claimed he met Satan in hell.

The medical sciences have tried to explain these phenomena through residual brain activity or chemical reactions triggered by intense trauma.

Particle physicist and TV presenter Brian Cox has, however, taken the discussion one step further and explained why there is no measurable evidence of humans having souls that could live on after death.

The popstar-turned-scientist appeared on the Joe Rogan Podcast where he discussed the idea of humans having souls, among other topics.

In his estimate, there is no observable force - the soul - that interacts with the human body at the subatomic level.

If such a force existed within us, it would strongly react with the particles our bodies are made of.

Instead, physicists have so far only observed four fundamental forces governing this world - gravity, the weak and strong nuclear force, and electromagnetism.

None of these forces could explain the concept of a soul trapped inside the body.

Professor Cox, who teaches at the School of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Manchester, said: "So, here is my arm. It is made of electrons and protons and neutrons.

"If I have a soul in there, something we don't understand but it's a different kind of energy or whatever it is we don't have in physics at the moment.

"It interacts with matter because I'm moving my hand around.

"So whatever it is, it is something that interacts very strongly with matter."

Professor Cox went on to say scientists have made ultra-high precision measurements looking for a fifth force of nature, but have not found one.

Consequently, the human soul can be ruled out on the most fundamental level imaginable.

The physicist added: "If you want to suggest there's something else that interacts with matter strongly, then I would say that it's ruled out.

"I would go as far as to say it is ruled out by experiments.

"Or at least it is extremely subtle and you would have to jump through a lot of hoops to come up with a theory of some stuff that we wouldn't have seen when we've observed how matter interacts."

According to one theory, NDEs are caused by residual brain activity even when the body is shutting down.

Some researchers have proposed the visions and memories are hallucinations caused by not enough oxygen flowing into the brain.

Similarly, some theories speculate NDEs are hallucinations caused by brain cell death.

A more out-there theory suggests the dying body synthesises the psychoactive chemical N,N-Dimethyltryptamine or DMT.

Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU) researchers Neil Dagnall and Ken Drinkwater said: "Currently, there is no definitive explanation for why near-death experiences happen.

"But ongoing research still strives to understand this enigmatic phenomenon."
 
image--043.jpg

my soul is in HD.
 
>We haven't found a fifth force of nature, therefore one doesn't exist
The retarded fedora sperging aside, this is one of the reasons I argue that many of these modern-day scientists are just atheistic mysticists. His assertion is obviously conjecture because it would require him to prove the null hypothesis, but he states it as absolute fact.
 
>We haven't found a fifth force of nature, therefore one doesn't exist
The retarded fedora sperging aside, this is one of the reasons I argue that many of these modern-day scientists are just atheistic mysticists. His assertion is obviously conjecture because it would require him to prove the null hypothesis, but he states it as absolute fact.

"It-it totally exists and we know about it because reasons but nobody can find it but it totally exists guys I swear!"

cope harder soulcuck
 
"It-it totally exists and we know about it because reasons but nobody can find it but it totally exists guys I swear!"

cope harder soulcuck
We have determined, based on cause-and-effect analysis, that matter spontaneously generates at heretofore incalculable points in spacetime. Therefore, science is valid.
 
"It-it totally exists and we know about it because reasons but nobody can find it but it totally exists guys I swear!"

cope harder soulcuck
"It-it totally doesn't exist because grantwhores say it doesnt no i havent seen evidence and i wudnt understand it anyway but it totally doesn't exists guys experts say so please trust experts dont question what experts say you guys!"

cope harder soycuck
 
We have determined, based on cause-and-effect analysis, that matter spontaneously generates at heretofore incalculable points in spacetime. Therefore, science is valid.

"Oh-Oh yeah science guy if you're so smart why don't you know literally everything got em few that was close"

Souls are the ultimate form of copium.

Oh no! I'm going to die one day and can't do anything to stop it! I-its OK tho because I'll totally go to a better place once that happens! Trust the plan!
Oh no! People are living hedonistic sinful lives while I'm stuck here doing work! I-its OK tho because they'll get punished while I'm at the good place! Trust the plan!
Oh no! Terrible things are happening all the time but its just a test trust the plan its OK man!
 
>We haven't found a fifth force of nature, therefore one doesn't exist
The retarded fedora sperging aside, this is one of the reasons I argue that many of these modern-day scientists are just atheistic mysticists. His assertion is obviously conjecture because it would require him to prove the null hypothesis, but he states it as absolute fact.
Multiple parallel quantum worlds is the same shit; but scientist cling to parallel galaxies as like a weird sort of surrogate afterlife.
 
Instead, physicists have so far only observed four fundamental forces governing this world - gravity, the weak and strong nuclear force, and electromagnetism.

None of these forces could explain the concept of a soul trapped inside the body.
This sounds like the kind of shit you’d see on a late 90s geocities website.

I wonder what he would say about consciousness, since that’s a property that doesn’t look particularly different to any other electrical signals.
 
In his estimate, there is no observable force - the soul - that interacts with the human body at the subatomic level.
:optimistic:

What if he was looking for the wrong thing at the wrong place? Humans invented the concept of the "soul". Of course it's not real.

But there could be "something" which is either similar to the soul concept or completely different that remains after the body dies and fucks off to somewhere else. Also what if it's not even inside the body?

Oh well everyone alive will (perhaps) never know the truth and the dead can't tell us.
 
"Or at least it is extremely subtle and you would have to jump through a lot of hoops to come up with a theory of some stuff that we wouldn't have seen when we've observed how matter interacts."

It's as if his final statement is "it's possible, but we have yet to find evidence based on our understanding of how matter works", which is as honest as anyone can get on the matter.
 
Making the assumption that a soul is a detectable entity that exists physically in the body like in cartoons is already a huge assumption. The concept of a soul necessities the existence of a higher power in some form. Something this powerful and wide reaching would operate on a level we couldn't even begin to understand with our limited place in the world. Which is why proving the soul through science is pointless, as it either doesn't exist at all, or it does and we would somehoe need to discover this higher power to become aware of it.
 
Estado
No está abierto para más respuestas.
Atrás
Top Abajo