Standardized Profile
kiwifarms.net
- Registrado
- 5 de Oct, 2018
It seems my last post was a repeat of something Nemui did back in June. I should have gotten clocks for that one. But I will try to redeem myself. I decided to compare the US and Japanese data for 2022. This was primarily to further validate both data sources, but also to see if maybe Byuu's death will show up in the subsequent year for some reason and we're a bunch of idiots for not considering that possibility.
First, here is the State Department's list of deaths for 2022:
Here's the Japanese data for 2022 (link):
In this case, the US data includes two suicides that are not in the Japanese data. This is curious, but I'm not joining Team Dead Byuu just yet. While it would be nice if the US Embassy and Japanese vital statistics agreed on everything all the time, they don't have to. In fact, a minor disagreement increases my confidence because it means one agency isn't simply mirroring the other, they're collecting their own data and/or adjudicating cause of death under their own rules. That means when they do agree--like in 2021--that's pretty compelling.
But why do they differ in 2022?
First, here is the State Department's list of deaths for 2022:
There is no cluster of suicides to suggest the previous year's deaths were dumped into 2022, which we might expect under a "slow Japanese" or "slow consular officers" scenario. I imagined someone could have fat-fingered the year and moved Byuu's death forward a year, but there are no suicides in late June. There was one suicide in Arakawa, but no reason to think someone changed Byuu's date of death to April 30. There is no readily apparent path for that error to occur.
Date City Cause of Death Japan 01-22-2022 2-19-31 Uenonishi,Toyonaka, Osaka 560-0011 Other Accident 02-26-2022 Tashiro, Aikawamachi, Aiko-gun, Kanagawa-ken Suicide 03-17-2022 1-2-23-205 Mihagino, Kokurakita-ku,Kitakyushu-shi,Fukuoka-Ken 802-0065 Suicide 03-26-2022 1-1-2-510 Minowacho, Kouhoku-ku,Yokohama-shi,Kanagawa-ken Suicide 04-30-2022 7-45-15 Nishi-Ogu, Arakawa-ku, Tokyo Suicide 05-01-2022 The Ocean Area Around 5600 meters at 87 degrees true azimuth ,Cape Zanpamisaki Lighthouse located at ,1933 Uzamisachibaru, Yomitan, Okinawa Maritime Accident 05-02-2022 Japanese Red Cross Medical Center, Tokyo Veh. Accid-Pedestr. 05-23-2022 Found approximately 30 meters off the coast of Headland Beach,Chigasaki-shi,Kanagawa-Ken Drowning 06-01-2022 6-317-1 Makuhari-cho, Hanamikawa-ku, Chiba-shi,Chiba-ken Suicide 06-25-2022 Dai-go jiwari jinai, Shimo Yatsugi,Yahaba-cho, Shiwa-gun,Iwate Prefecture Other Accident 07-02-2022 Miyako Hospital, Okinawa Suicide 08-19-2022 Yokosuka-shi, Kanagawa-ken Suicide 08-23-2022 Kamaza-dori, Kamigyo-ku,Kyoto Suicide 09-23-2022 Tokyo Medical University Hospital, Shinjuku-ku, Tokyo Suicide 11-11-2022 Nagasaki Medical Center,Omura,Nagasaki Other Accident 12-04-2022 near the Udosaki Lighthouse In Nichinan-Shi,Miyazaki Drowning 12-10-2022 Saiseikai Fukuoka General Hospital,Fukuoka Suicide 12-25-2022 Hanno-shi, Saitama Homicide 12-25-2022 Hanno-shi, Saitama Homicide
Here's the Japanese data for 2022 (link):
In this case, the US data includes two suicides that are not in the Japanese data. This is curious, but I'm not joining Team Dead Byuu just yet. While it would be nice if the US Embassy and Japanese vital statistics agreed on everything all the time, they don't have to. In fact, a minor disagreement increases my confidence because it means one agency isn't simply mirroring the other, they're collecting their own data and/or adjudicating cause of death under their own rules. That means when they do agree--like in 2021--that's pretty compelling.
But why do they differ in 2022?
- Perhaps dual citizens are counted as Japanese in the Japanese data, and do not show up in the US column.
- State reported three suicides in hospitals. Might the Japanese have attributed two of those to illness?
- The Japanese recorded three "accidental threats to breathing," two males and a female. Sometimes people hang themselves, and it's hard to tell whether they were trying to kill themselves or accidentally whacked themselves while whacking off. I can see how a consular officer might record such a death as suicide to spare a family the image of their loved one jerking off until they jerk spasmodically at the end of a rope.
- I'm a right-wing conspiracy theorist and made this up to justify harassing trans people.