Before everybody here gets all crazy, it should be stressed there's no "smoking gun" Mandy is a dude.
Yet. Personally, I'm 50/50 on what their gender is.
That said, this certainly
does appear to be a catfish, and from what we've seen with prior catfishing, the possibility we're dealing with a dude
definitely exists. Plus, MAN-D is too funny of a joke.
As far as the catfishing goes, what cinched it for me was when
@Balldo's Gate was doing his research in preparation for his post,
@Himedall All-seeing Waifu shared caps from Nick's Locals in which Mandy was suggesting she had taken these images from her potato phone.
Example:
As Balldo's Gate points out in his post, he came across the original unedited pictures that were actually posted on Reddit some
seven years prior (if not earlier). The originals are of far higher quality, and were taken with a much better camera. In other words, she didn't drop her potato phone on her face in that picture. They are all originally part of a
deliberate porn shoot (some of the images in the set are quite graphic, and those ones were not utilized on Locals).
Those images were then manipulated in a way to spoof a reverse image search and then uploaded to Nick's Locals to be fawned over. That's why this wasn't exposed earlier.
TL;DR: Nick and his Locals have been thirsting over somebody (gender indeterminate) posting old porn images and who went out of their way to try to obfuscate their origin. Coupled with the fact we have no confirmation anybody has heard "her" voice, and she has rebuffed Nick's efforts to meet up IRL, it's suspicious as all hell.
I can't put my hand on my heart a swear Mandy is a dude, but I think they could very well be. They could also be a troon, or fat chick, or any number of other things. They are not who they claim to be though.
For my money, Mandy turning out to be a dude would be the ultimate insult to the injury, but the initial injury already came in the form of Nick thirsting over this weirdo in the first place.
I would also point out that Nick's Locals used to shit on KF and claim "well, at least we have Mandy's epic tits." Congratulations. You have the tits of some amateur porn thot who is almost certainly
not Mandy. The absolute state of Nick's current fanbase.
I hope his wife confronts him about this.
“You’re going to believe those retards on Kiwi Farms?”
The thing is, even if Mandy weren't catfishing, what wife in a monogamous relationship (according to Nick) would put up with their husband publicly thirsting over another woman like he did? It shouldn't even matter what Mandy turns out to be.
That's what I don't get. Maybe I'm just too old fashioned, but that seems to undermine Nick's claim. It doesn't exactly make her look good either.
EDIT: Punctuation.